放射科医生对肺部影像报告和数据系统分类是否清晰?韩国胸放射学会会员对十个难以分类场景的调查
该研究以在线问卷形式调查韩国胸放射学会会员,评估其对十个难以分类的虚拟肺结节场景进行肺部影像报告和数据系统(Lung-RADS)分类的变异性。42名受访者共420个答案中310个(73.8%)与共识答案一致,11名(26.2%)受访者仅答对六个或更少问题,将结节分类高于共识答案(16.0%)比低于共识答案(5.5%)更常见,两个场景的一致率低于50%。
要点
- 42名受访者中仅73.8%(310/420)答案与共识一致,11名(26.2%)答对≤6题。
- 分类偏高(16.0%)比偏低(5.5%)更常见,两个场景一致率低于50%。
- 对难以分类场景,胸放射科医生Lung-RADS分类存在较大变异性。
核心结论
- 面对难以分类的场景,胸放射科医生对Lung-RADS分类的解读存在较大变异性,部分特定场景分歧频率高。
研究设计与样本
- 在线问卷调查韩国胸放射学会会员,纳入十个难以分类的虚拟肺结节场景(描述年度复查CT所见的结节大小、密度及间隔变化),要求从2、3、4A、4B或「无法分类」中选择;共识答案由韩国肺癌影像研究组成员建立;排除重复提交后共42名受访者、420个答案。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 420个答案中310个(73.8%)与共识答案一致;11名(26.2%)受访者与共识答案一致的问题为六个或更少;将虚拟结节分类高于共识答案(16.0%)比低于共识答案(5.5%)更常见;两个场景的一致率低于50%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在报告难以分类的肺结节时,需注意Lung-RADS分类可能存在观察者间差异。
- 分类偏高(16.0%)比偏低(5.5%)更常见,两个场景一致率低于50%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate possible variability in chest radiologists' interpretations of the Lung Imaging Reporting and Data System (Lung-RADS) on difficult-to-classify scenarios.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ten scenarios of difficult-to-classify imaginary lung nodules were prepared as an online survey that targeted Korean Society of Thoracic Radiology members. In each question, a description was provided of the size, consistency, and interval change (new or growing) of a lung nodule observed using annual repeat computed tomography, and the respondent was instructed to choose one answer from five choices: category 2, 3, 4A, or 4B, or "un-categorizable." Consensus answers were established by members of the Korean Imaging Study Group for Lung Cancer.
RESULTS: Of the 420 answers from 42 respondents (excluding multiple submissions), 310 (73.8%) agreed with the consensus answers; eleven (26.2%) respondents agreed with the consensus answers to six or fewer questions. Assigning the imaginary nodules to categories higher than the consensus answer was more frequent (16.0%) than assigning them to lower categories (5.5%), and the agreement rate was below 50% for two scenarios.
CONCLUSION: When given difficult-to-classify scenarios, chest radiologists showed large variability in their interpretations of the Lung-RADS categories, with high frequencies of disagreement in some specific scenarios.
引用
- Han DH, Goo JM, Chong S, et al. Are Lung Imaging Reporting and Data System Categories Clear to Radiologists? A Survey of the Korean Society of Thoracic Radiology Members on Ten Difficult-to-Classify Scenarios. Korean J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28246521. doi:10.3348/kjr.2017.18.2.402
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。