CT检查中降低辐射剂量水平下观察者性能的评估:剔除过低剂量水平是首要步骤
本研究利用131例腹部、胸部和头部CT数据,重建4%-100%常规临床剂量的图像,由放射科医生评估并采用jackknife替代自由响应ROC分析观察者性能。结果显示腹部CT和胸部CT分别在低于50%和4%剂量时读者一致性判定性能不足,但仅最低剂量配置(腹部30%、胸部4%、头部10%)未达到非劣效标准;低剂量下主观图像质量先于观察者性能下降,迭代重建仅在滤波反投影无法达到非劣效性能时才有益。
要点
- 腹部CT剂量低于50%时读者一致性判定对肝转移瘤检测性能不足。
- 胸部CT剂量低至4%时读者一致性仍判定对肺结节检测性能不足。
- 低剂量下主观图像质量先于观察者性能下降,迭代重建仅在滤波反投影未达非劣效时有益。
核心结论
- 使用现有CT技术对常见诊断任务存在大幅降低辐射剂量的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入131例CT检查(腹部CT 44例、胸部CT 44例、头部CT 43例),将对应4%-100%常规临床剂量的图像分别用滤波反投影或迭代重建进行重建,由放射科医生评估并标记目标、给出置信度评分和图像质量分级,采用参考标准、读者一致性规则和jackknife替代自由响应ROC品质因数评估非劣效性。
关键影像表现/征象
- 低剂量下主观图像质量在观察者性能下降之前即出现下降。
- 迭代重建仅在滤波反投影未达到非劣效性能时才有益。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 读者一致性要求低剂量下多数读者能识别常规剂量下多数读者所见的目标病灶。
- 读者一致性判定腹部CT剂量低于50%时对肝转移瘤检测性能不足,胸部CT剂量低至4%时对肺结节检测性能不足,头部CT未能排除任何低剂量水平。
- jackknife替代自由响应ROC品质因数差异显示仅最低剂量配置(腹部CT 30%、胸部CT 4%、头部CT 10%常规剂量)未达到非劣效标准。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: This study aims to estimate observer performance for a range of dose levels for common computed tomography (CT) examinations (detection of liver metastases or pulmonary nodules, and cause of neurologic deficit) to prioritize noninferior dose levels for further analysis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Using CT data from 131 examinations (abdominal CT, 44; chest CT, 44; head CT, 43), CT images corresponding to 4%-100% of the routine clinical dose were reconstructed with filtered back projection or iterative reconstruction. Radiologists evaluated CT images, marking specified targets, providing confidence scores, and grading image quality. Noninferiority was assessed using reference standards, reader agreement rules, and jackknife alternative free-response receiver operating characteristic figures of merit. Reader agreement required that a majority of readers at lower dose identify target lesions seen by the majority of readers at routine dose.
RESULTS: Reader agreement identified dose levels lower than 50% and 4% to have inadequate performance for detection of hepatic metastases and pulmonary nodules, respectively, but could not exclude any low dose levels for head CT. Estimated differences in jackknife alternative free-response receiver operating characteristic figures of merit between routine and lower dose configurations found that only the lowest dose configurations tested (ie, 30%, 4%, and 10% of routine dose levels for abdominal, chest, and head CT examinations, respectively) did not meet criteria for noninferiority. At lower doses, subjective image quality declined before observer performance. Iterative reconstruction was only beneficial when filtered back projection did not result in noninferior performance.
CONCLUSION: Opportunity exists for substantial radiation dose reduction using existing CT technology for common diagnostic tasks.
引用
- Fletcher JG, Yu L, Fidler JL, et al. Estimation of Observer Performance for Reduced Radiation Dose Levels in CT: Eliminating Reduced Dose Levels That Are Too Low Is the First Step. Acad Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28262519. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2016.12.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。