儿童全身MRI:仅用3D STIR序列是否足以评估常见儿科病变?一项对比研究
本研究在54例有不同临床指征的儿科患者中,比较单独3D IR T2加权STIR序列与包含DWI、T1加权和STIR 3D IR的全身MRI方案(3S)的诊断性能。两位阅片者间隔2周分别独立判读,仅报告阳性发现,并与病理特异性金标准对照。结果显示两种方案敏感度无差异(阅片者1:81.6% vs 81.0%;阅片者2:74.1% vs 74.7%),但两位阅片者间敏感度存在差异;阳性预测值随疾病类型而异。
要点
- 在儿童全身MRI中,单独3D STIR序列与完整3S方案的敏感度无差异,但阳性预测值高度依赖疾病类型。
- 淋巴瘤和神经母细胞瘤的阳性预测值低于70%,而组织细胞增生症和骨肉瘤可达100%。
- 两位阅片者间的敏感度存在差异,提示判读一致性可能受经验影响。
核心结论
- 对于每位阅片者,两种方案的敏感度无差异;对于每种方案,两位阅片者间的敏感度存在差异;阳性预测值取决于疾病类型。
研究设计与样本
- 比较性研究,纳入54例儿童全身MRI,平均年龄6岁10个月(范围1个月至15岁),两位分别有15年和30年经验的放射科医生间隔2周先后判读单独3D STIR和3S方案,仅报告阳性发现,第三位阅片者将结果与针对病理的金标准检查对照。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 3D STIR的阅片者间一致性为0.87 [0.82-0.91],3S方案的阅片者间一致性为0.89 [0.83-0.93]。
- 阅片者1的敏感度:3D STIR为81.6%,3S为81.0%;阅片者2的敏感度:3D STIR为74.1%,3S为74.7%。
- 阳性预测值因疾病类型而异:组织细胞增生症和骨肉瘤为100%,儿童虐待>90%,慢性复发性多灶性骨髓炎>85%,淋巴瘤和神经母细胞瘤<70%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To test the performance of a single 3D IR T2-Weighted sequence compared to a Whole-body MRI protocol including DWI, T1-Weighted and STIR 3D IR (3S) in a pediatric population.
METHODS: Two radiologists (15 and 30 years of experience),reviewed WBMRIs: first the STIR alone and 2 weeks later the 3S protocol. The indications were variable. Only positive findings were explicitly reported. A third reader compared the results to gold standard (GS) exams specific for the pathology. Agreement between the two readers, sensitivity and positive predictive value of STIR were calculated.
RESULTS: fifty-four WBMRIs were included (16 suspected child abuse, 8 chronic recurrent multifocal osteomyelitis (CRMO), 11 lymphomas, 4 osteosarcomas, 9 neuroblastomas, 6 histiocytosis). The mean age was 6 years 10 months, range: 1 month to 15 years. Agreement between readers was of 0.87 [0.82-0.91] for 3D STIR, and 0.89 [0.83-0.93] for the 3S protocol. For reader 1 sensitivity of 3D STIR was 81.6% and of 3S 81.0%. For reader 2 it was 74.1% for 3D STIR and 74.7% for 3S. For both readers and for both protocols, the positive predictive value (PPV) depended on the type of disease (for example 100% histocytosis and osteosarcomas, >90% for child abuse, >85% CRMO but <70% for lymphoma and neuroblastoma).
CONCLUSIONS: Sensitivities were not different between the 2 protocols, for each reader and were different between the 2 readers for each protocol.
引用
- Merlini L, Carpentier M, Ferrey S, et al. Whole-body MRI in children: Would a 3D STIR sequence alone be sufficient for investigating common paediatric conditions? A comparative study. Eur J Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28189202. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2017.01.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。