疑似非故意创伤骨骼调查的双读:我们的经验
该研究分两阶段评估疑似非故意创伤儿童骨骼调查双读与单读的差异,共纳入178名儿童(67名女孩,平均年龄9个月)。双读在8/178(4.5%)的调查中发现16处差异,阴性调查差异率1.0%(1/104)显著低于阳性调查9.5%(7/74)(P=0.01),两阶段间差异率无显著变化(P=0.59)。结论认为双读在初始正常骨骼调查中不常发现差异,将双读限制于初始阳性研究可提高收益。
要点
- 双读在4.5%(8/178)的骨骼调查中发现差异,其中7项为额外骨折(共15处)。
- 初始阴性调查的差异率1.0%(1/104)显著低于初始阳性调查的9.5%(7/74)(P=0.01)。
- 将双读限制于初始阳性研究可提高双读收益。
核心结论
- 双读可发现少量假阴性骨折,罕见发现假阳性骨折诊断;初始正常骨骼调查中双读不常发现差异,将双读限制于初始阳性研究可提高收益。
研究设计与样本
- 两阶段研究,第一阶段(2013年4月至2013年9月)对所有工作日工作时间获得的骨骼调查进行双读;第二阶段(2014年1月至2014年3月)仅对初次阅读阳性的骨骼调查进行双读,期末回顾性对所有初始阴性骨骼调查进行双读;排除随访骨骼调查;共178名儿童(67名女孩),平均年龄9个月(范围3天至3.7年)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 双读共发现16处差异,分布于8/178(4.5%)的骨骼调查;其中7项研究显示额外骨折(n=15),1项研究初始阅读的颅骨骨折在二次阅读中判为变异;阴性骨骼调查差异率1.0%(1/104) vs 阳性骨骼调查9.5%(7/74),Fisher精确检验P=0.01;两阶段间差异率变化无统计学显著(P=0.59,分层Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel检验)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Missing a fracture in a child on skeletal surveys for suspected non-accidental trauma can have devastating results. Double-read has the potential to improve fracture detection. However the yield of double-read is unknown.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the advantage of double-read versus single-read of radiographic skeletal surveys for suspected non-accidental trauma.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study was performed in two phases. In the first phase (April 2013 to September 2013), double-read was performed for all skeletal surveys obtained during weekday working hours. Because we had no new double-read findings in studies initially read as negative, we conducted a second phase (January 2014 to March 2014). In the second phase we limited double-reads to skeletal surveys found positive on the first read. At the end of this period, we retrospectively performed double-read for all initially negative skeletal surveys. We excluded follow-up skeletal surveys. The difference in discrepancy (new fracture or false diagnosis of a fracture) ratio between negative and positive skeletal surveys was evaluated using the Fisher exact test, and change in discrepancy ratio between the first and second study phases was evaluated using the stratified Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel test.
RESULTS: Overall in the two phases, 178 skeletal surveys were performed in 178 children (67 girls) with mean age of 9 months (range 3 days to 3.7 years). Double-read found 16 discrepancies in 8/178 (4.5%) skeletal surveys. Seven of these studies showed additional fractures (n=15). In one study, an initial read of a skull fracture was read as a variant on the second read. There was a significant (P=0.01) difference between rate of disagreement in negative skeletal surveys (1/104, 1.0%) and positive skeletal surveys (7/74, 9.5%). No significant change in disagreement rate was demonstrated between the two phases of the study (P=0.59).
CONCLUSION: Double-read of skeletal survey for suspected non-accidental trauma found false-negative fractures in a few cases and rarely found false-positive diagnosis of a fracture. Double-read uncommonly found discrepancies in an initially normal skeletal survey. Limiting double-read to initially positive studies improves the yield of the double-read.
引用
- Karmazyn B, Miller EM, Lay SE, et al. Double-read of skeletal surveys in suspected non-accidental trauma: what we learned. Pediatr Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28236132. doi:10.1007/s00247-017-3783-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。