文献速递骨肌CT

CT关节造影分级股骨与胫骨软骨表面病变的多评估者一致性及不一致原因分析

Multirater agreement for grading the femoral and tibial cartilage surface lesions at CT arthrography and analysis of causes of disagreement.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2016-12-31

研究评估5名不同经验阅片者按改良Outerbridge系统对962个膝关节CT关节造影软骨分区进行两次间隔三个月的分级,总体观察者间一致性为一般(k=0.35),一致性随分级升高而增加(k=0.14至0.76),观察者内一致性随经验从中等(k=0.59)到几乎完全(k=0.92)不等;不一致主要源于软骨厚度正常变异的评估困难(44%)及可回顾性避免的判读错误(32%)。

要点

  • 改良Outerbridge系统在CT关节造影上的总体观察者间一致性仅为一般(k=0.35),但4级病变一致性达显著水平(k=0.76)。
  • 不一致病例中44%源于软骨厚度正常变异的评估困难,其中弥漫性软骨变薄占23%、软骨厚度正常变异占22%。
  • 32%的不一致归因于可回顾性避免的判读错误,阅片者经验影响观察者内一致性(k=0.59至0.92)。

核心结论

  • 当纳入不同经验水平的阅片者时,改良Outerbridge系统在CT关节造影上的多评估者一致性仅为一般,观察者间一致性随阅片者经验增加而提高;然而4级病变的观察者间一致性达显著水平。作者报告了可能提高软骨病变报告一致性的软骨厚度正常变异。

研究设计与样本

  • 对预先划分的962个膝关节CT关节造影软骨分区(股骨胫骨骨关节炎,Kellgren/Lawrence=3)进行多阅片者一致性研究;5名不同经验阅片者(2名初级放射科医生、3名肌肉骨骼放射科医生含2名软骨成像专家)间隔三个月独立两次分级,采用改良5级Outerbridge系统;评估观察者间与观察者内一致性,第二次阅片后对121个观察者间不一致最高的区域进行共识回顾以确定不一致来源。

关键影像表现/征象

  • CT关节造影上评估股骨胫骨软骨表面病变时,软骨厚度正常变异(包括弥漫性软骨变薄和正常厚度变异)是判读不一致的主要来源。
  • 不一致病例中44%由于评估软骨厚度正常变异的困难,其中弥漫性软骨变薄占23%、软骨厚度正常变异占22%。
  • 32%的不一致病例归因于可回顾性避免的判读错误。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 采用改良5级Outerbridge系统对股骨胫骨软骨分区进行分级。
  • 总体观察者间一致性为一般(k=0.35),一致性随分级从0级至4级升高(k=0.14至0.76)。
  • 观察者内一致性随阅片者经验从中等(k=0.59)到几乎完全(k=0.92)不等。
  • 4级病变的观察者间一致性达显著水平(k=0.76)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 阅片者经验影响观察者内一致性(k=0.59至0.92),经验较丰富者一致性更高。
  • 报告软骨病变时需注意软骨厚度正常变异(包括弥漫性软骨变薄和正常厚度变异),其占不一致病例的44%(23%+22%)。
  • 可回顾性避免的判读错误占不一致病例的32%。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To assess the multirater agreement of the modified Outerbridge system for the grading of predefined areas of femorotibial cartilage at CT arthrography with multiple readers, with varying experience.

DESIGN: Five readers with varying experience (two junior radiologists, three musculoskeletal radiologists including two experts in cartilage imaging) separately analyzed 962 cartilage sectors from pre-divided knee CT arthrograms with femorotibial osteoarthritis (Kellgren/Lawrence=3). Each cartilage area was graded twice by each reader, at a three-month interval, according to the modified 5-grade Outerbridge system. Interobserver and intraobserver agreement were assessed. After the second reading, 121 areas exhibiting the highest interobserver disagreement were reviewed in consensus to determine the sources of disagreement.

RESULTS: The global interobserver agreement was fair (k=0.35), and increased with the grade (from k=0.14 to k=0.76 from grade 0-4). The intraobserver agreement varied with the readers' experience from moderate (k=0.59) to almost perfect (k=0.92). The majority of cases of disagreement (44%) was due to difficulties in assessing the normal variations of cartilage thickness, including diffuse cartilage thinning (23%) and normal variants of cartilage thickness (22%). 32% of cases of disagreement were due to retrospectively avoidable interpretation errors.

CONCLUSIONS: The multirater agreement of the modified Outerbridge system is only fair when readers of different level of experience are taken into account, and interobserver agreement increases with readers' experience. However, interobserver agreement is substantial for grade 4 lesions. We report normal variations of cartilage thickness that may improve observer agreement in reporting cartilage lesions.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Omoumi P, Michoux N, Larbi A, et al. Multirater agreement for grading the femoral and tibial cartilage surface lesions at CT arthrography and analysis of causes of disagreement. Eur J Radiol. 2016. PMID: 28189216. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2016.12.026

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。