多学科骨科肿瘤会议中肌肉骨骼亚专科二次判读的临床影响
研究分析2014年1月至2016年12月多学科骨科肿瘤会议中肌肉骨骼放射科医生对外院MRI进行二次判读的临床影响。409例患者中,22.2%的判读差异导致临床管理显著改变;有病理结果时二次判读与病理一致率93.4%,外院判读一致率63.9%(P < .05)。
要点
- 外院MRI二次判读中22.2%存在临床显著差异并改变管理。
- 有病理对照时二次判读一致率93.4%,外院判读63.9%。
- 亚专科参与多学科团队有助于指导合适治疗方案。
核心结论
- 原发与二次判读间临床显著差异率为22.2%,大量临床相关差异表明亚专科专长常改变原诊断,亚专科放射科医生参与多学科团队有助于指导适当治疗方案。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为PACS数据库检索分析,纳入2014年1月至2016年12月多学科骨科肿瘤会议中对外院MRI研究进行二次判读的409例患者,平均年龄47.9 ± 19.2岁,报告与可获取的原判读比较,采用7点评分分类。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 7点评分:I无差异;II未发现临床不显著异常;III临床不显著判读差异;IV影像随访建议差异;V初始判读不确定后亚专科确定判读;VI临床显著判读差异;VII未发现临床显著异常。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 二次判读中91例(22.2%)存在导致临床管理显著差异的判读分歧,其中67例(16.4%)为VI类、24例(5.9%)为VII类;另有72例(17.6%)为IV类、28例(6.8%)为V类,临床相关差异共191例(46.7%)。有病理时二次判读一致57/61例(93.4%),外院判读一致39/61例(63.9%,P < .05)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To analyze the impact on clinical management when musculoskeletal radiologists render second-opinion consultations during multidisciplinary orthopedic oncology conference.
METHODS: A PACS database was searched for secondary interpretations on outside MRI studies reviewed during a multidisciplinary orthopedic oncology conference from January 2014 to December 2016. Reports were compared with the original interpretations, when available. Reports were categorized using a 7-point scale: I (no discrepancy), II (undetected clinically insignificant abnormality), III (clinically insignificant difference in interpretation), IV (difference in imaging follow-up recommendation), V (equivocal initial interpretation with subsequent definitive subspecialty interpretation), VI (clinically significant difference in interpretation), VII (failure to detect a clinically significant abnormality).
RESULTS: A total of 409 patients met inclusion criteria, with an average age of 47.9 ± 19.2. There were 91 (22.2%) instances of discrepant interpretations resulting in clinically significant differences in management; 67 (16.4%) were category VI and 24 (5.9%) were category VII. An additional 72 subjects (17.6%) were identified as category IV and 28 (6.8%) as category V, yielding at total of 191 (46.7%) clinically relevant discrepancies. When pathology was available, the secondary consultations were concordant in 57 of 61 cases (93.4%) and the outside interpretations were concordant in 39 of 61 cases (63.9%, P < .05).
CONCLUSION: A 22.2% rate of clinically significant difference was observed between primary and secondary interpretations. The substantial rate of clinically relevant discrepancies demonstrates that subspecialty expertise often changed the primary diagnosis. Thus, by participating in a multidisciplinary team, subspecialty radiologists have a unique opportunity to help direct appropriate treatment plans.
引用
- Rozenberg A, Kenneally BE, Abraham JA, et al. Clinical Impact of Second-Opinion Musculoskeletal Subspecialty Interpretations During a Multidisciplinary Orthopedic Oncology Conference. J Am Coll Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28238666. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2017.01.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。