主治放射科医师的变异性及其对放射科住院医师差异率的影响
该研究回顾了5年内PGY-3住院医师在值班情况下解读的胸部X线、肌肉骨骼X线、胸部CT、腹盆CT和头部CT,发现住院医师阅片量与差异率呈强负相关,主治医师在复核量和发布差异的倾向性上存在广泛变异,模拟显示既往基准对胸部X线、腹盆CT和头部CT匹配良好,但对肌肉骨骼X线和胸部CT不匹配。
要点
- 住院医师阅片量与差异率呈强负相关。
- 主治医师在复核量和发布差异的倾向性上存在广泛变异。
- 既往基准对肌肉骨骼X线和胸部CT可能过于严格。
核心结论
- 主治医师实践模式的巨大变异性表明,使用差异率直接比较住院医师不太可能反映真实表现;当前胸部X线、腹盆CT和头部CT的基准是合适的,而肌肉骨骼X线和胸部CT的基准可能过于严格。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入5年内PGY-3住院医师在值班情况下解读的所有胸部X线、肌肉骨骼X线、胸部CT、腹盆CT和头部CT,使用Gibbs抽样模拟「平均住院医师」的预期差异分布并与实际分布比较。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,当前胸部X线、腹盆CT和头部CT的基准能正确标记出表现可能需要额外关注的住院医师;而肌肉骨骼X线和胸部CT的基准可能过于严格。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Discrepancy rates for interpretations produced in a call situation are one metric to evaluate residents during training. Current benchmarks, reported in previous studies, do not consider the effects of practice pattern variability among attending radiologists. This study aims to investigate the impact of attending variability on resident discrepancy rates to determine if the current benchmarks are an accurate measure of resident performance and, if necessary, update discrepancy benchmarks to accurately identify residents performing below expectations.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: All chest radiographs, musculoskeletal (MSK) radiographs, chest computed tomographies (CTs), abdomen and pelvis CTs, and head CTs interpreted by postgraduate year-3 residents in a call situation over 5 years were reviewed for the presence of a significant discrepancy and composite results compared to prior findings. Simulations of the expected discrepancy distribution for an "average resident" were then performed using Gibbs sampling, and this distribution was compared to the actual resident distribution.
RESULTS: A strong inverse correlation between resident volume and discrepancy rates was found. There was wide variability among attendings in both overread volume and propensity to issue a discrepancy, although there was no significant correlation. Simulations show that previous benchmarks match well for chest radiographs, abdomen and pelvis CTs, and head CTs but not for MSK radiographs and chest CTs. The simulations also demonstrate a large effect of attending practice patterns on resident discrepancy rates.
CONCLUSIONS: The large variability in attending practice patterns suggests direct comparison of residents using discrepancy rates is unlikely to reflect true performance. Current benchmarks for chest radiographs, abdomen and pelvis CTs, and head CTs are appropriate and correctly flag residents whose performance may benefit from additional attention, whereas those for MSK radiographs and chest CTs are likely too strict.
引用
- Wildenberg JC, Chen PH, Scanlon MH, et al. Attending Radiologist Variability and Its Effect on Radiology Resident Discrepancy Rates. Acad Radiol. 2017. PMID: 28130051. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2016.12.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。