急性腹痛中常规与选择性CT成像的随机临床试验:患者年龄对治疗费用和医院资源使用的影响
300例急性腹痛成人随机分为常规CT组(n=150)和选择性成像组(n=150),最终分析254例。两组成像与治疗费用及住院时间均随年龄增长而增加,且常规CT组一般高于选择性成像组。若获得明确诊断至关重要,常规CT在65岁以上患者中比年轻患者更具成本效益;考虑到老年人急性腹痛的诊断挑战,可提倡在该人群宽松使用CT。
要点
- 常规CT组治疗费用、成像费用和住院时间一般高于选择性成像组,且两组均随年龄增长而增加。
- 选择性成像组中,65岁以下患者34%(27/79)接受了CT,65岁及以上患者59%(19/32)接受了CT(p=0.02)。
- 常规CT获得明确诊断的ICER:65岁以下1682 €,65岁及以上1055 €。
核心结论
- 急性腹痛治疗费用随年龄增长而增加,常规CT组一般高于选择性成像组。
- 获得急性腹痛明确诊断的概率随年龄增长而增加。
- 若获得明确诊断至关重要,常规CT在65岁以上患者中比年轻患者更具成本效益。
- 考虑到老年人急性腹痛的诊断挑战,可提倡在该患者群体中宽松使用CT。
研究设计与样本
- 随机临床试验,300例急性腹痛成人随机分为常规CT组(n=150)和选择性成像实践组(n=150),最终分析254例。
- 常规CT组143例(其中42例≥65岁),选择性成像组111例(其中32例≥65岁)。
- 常规CT组所有患者接受腹部CT;选择性成像组根据临床评估决定是否成像。
- 计算每位患者的住院时间、急性腹痛相关诊断和治疗操作的数量与费用,并估计常规CT的增量成本效果比(ICER)和自举法成本效果可接受曲线(CEAC)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 选择性成像组中,65岁以下患者CT使用率为34%(27/79),65岁及以上患者为59%(19/32)(p=0.02)。
- 65岁及以上患者非特异性腹痛比例显著低于较年轻患者(p=0.04)。
- 常规CT组获得明确诊断的ICER:65岁以下患者1682 €,65岁及以上患者1055 €。
- 根据CEAC估计,若社会愿意为65岁以下患者每额外获得一个明确诊断支付14087 €、为65岁及以上患者支付4204 €,则对每位急性腹痛患者行常规CT有95%概率具有成本效益。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,若获得明确诊断至关重要,常规CT在65岁以上患者中比年轻患者更具成本效益。
- 作者提出,考虑到老年人急性腹痛的诊断挑战,可提倡在该患者群体中宽松使用CT。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the impact of patient age on hospital resource use and treatment costs of acute abdominal pain (AAP).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 300 adult patients with AAP were randomised to either computed tomography (CT, n=150) or selective imaging practice (SIP, n=150) groups. Final analysis included 254 patients, 143 (42 patients ≥65years) in the CT and 111 (32 patients ≥65years) in the SIP group. All CT group patients underwent abdominal CT whereas in the SIP group, imaging was based on the clinical assessment. For each patient, the hospital length of stay (LOS), the numbers and costs of diagnostic and treatment procedures arising from AAP were calculated and registered. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) and bootstrapped cost-effectiveness acceptability curve (CEAC) were estimated for routine CT.
RESULTS: Treatment costs, imaging costs and LOS increased in conjunction with aging in both study groups, and were generally higher in the CT group compared to the SIP group. In the SIP group, CT was undertaken in 34% (27/79) of the <65year olds but in 59% (19/32) of the older patients (≥65years) (p=0.02). The proportion of patients with non-specific abdominal pain was significantly lower in patients ≥65years than in their younger counterparts (p=0.04). In the routine CT group, the ICER of obtaining a specific diagnosis was 1682 € for patients <65years and 1055 € for patients ≥65years. According to CEAC estimation, routine CT for every patient with AAP has a 95% probability of being cost-effective if society is willing to pay 14087 € for an additional specific diagnosis for patients <65 years but only 4204 € in those ≥65years.
CONCLUSION: Treatment costs of AAP increase in parallel with aging, and the costs are generally higher with routine CT compared to selective imaging. The probability of obtaining a specific diagnosis of AAP increases with aging. If obtaining a specific diagnosis is deemed crucial, then routine CT is more cost-effective in patients over 65 years compared to younger patients. Considering the diagnostic challenges of AAP in the elderly, liberal CT use can be advocated in this patient group.
引用
- Lehtimäki TT, Valtonen H, Miettinen P, et al. A randomised clinical trial of routine versus selective CT imaging in acute abdomen: Impact of patient age on treatment costs and hospital resource use. Eur J Radiol. 2016. PMID: 28065368. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2016.11.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。