动态对比增强MRI与动态磁敏感对比MRI在脑胶质瘤研究中的可重复性:不同商业软件所得数据的比较
目的为评估两种不同商业软件计算和分析灌注图所得数据的可重复性,对20例脑胶质瘤患者的DSC与DCE分析进行软件内和软件间可重复性检验,并评估血管输入函数选择及去卷积算法对灌注生物标志物定量的影响。结果显示各软件内观察者内和观察者间可重复性几乎完美,而软件间ICC为0.311至0.577,提示一致性一般至中等,Bland-Altman分析显示数据离散度高。结论认为使用单一软件可保证很好的观察者内和观察者间可重复性,但比较不同软件或同一软件内不同后处理所得数据时应谨慎,因为可重复性不再有保证。
要点
- 同一软件内观察者内和观察者间可重复性几乎完美。
- 不同软件间ICC为0.311至0.577,一致性一般至中等。
- 比较不同软件或同一软件内不同后处理数据时应谨慎。
核心结论
- 使用单一软件可保证很好的观察者内和观察者间可重复性,但比较不同软件或同一软件内不同后处理所得数据时应谨慎,因为可重复性不再有保证。
研究设计与样本
- 对20例脑胶质瘤患者的DSC和DCE分析进行软件内(观察者内和观察者间)及软件间可重复性检验,并评估血管输入函数选择与去卷积算法对血浆容量(Vp)、容积转移常数(K trans)和rCBV定量的影响,采用组内相关系数(ICC)和Bland-Altman分析评价数据可重复性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 各软件内观察者内和观察者间可重复性对全部生物标志物均几乎完美一致。
- 软件间可重复性ICC为0.311至0.577,提示一致性一般至中等。
- DCE生物标志物不同血管输入函数估计方法比较:K trans的ICC为0.636,Vp的ICC为0.662。
- DSC两种去卷积算法比较:ICC为0.999。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Dynamic susceptibility contrast MRI (DSC) and dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI (DCE) are useful tools in the diagnosis and follow-up of brain gliomas; nevertheless, both techniques leave the open issue of data reproducibility. We evaluated the reproducibility of data obtained using two different commercial software for perfusion maps calculation and analysis, as one of the potential sources of variability can be the software itself.
METHODS: DSC and DCE analyses from 20 patients with gliomas were tested for both the intrasoftware (as intraobserver and interobserver reproducibility) and the intersoftware reproducibility, as well as the impact of different postprocessing choices [vascular input function (VIF) selection and deconvolution algorithms] on the quantification of perfusion biomarkers plasma volume (Vp), volume transfer constant (K trans) and rCBV. Data reproducibility was evaluated with the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and Bland-Altman analysis.
RESULTS: For all the biomarkers, the intra- and interobserver reproducibility resulted in almost perfect agreement in each software, whereas for the intersoftware reproducibility the value ranged from 0.311 to 0.577, suggesting fair to moderate agreement; Bland-Altman analysis showed high dispersion of data, thus confirming these findings. Comparisons of different VIF estimation methods for DCE biomarkers resulted in ICC of 0.636 for K trans and 0.662 for Vp; comparison of two deconvolution algorithms in DSC resulted in an ICC of 0.999.
CONCLUSIONS: The use of single software ensures very good intraobserver and interobservers reproducibility. Caution should be taken when comparing data obtained using different software or different postprocessing within the same software, as reproducibility is not guaranteed anymore.
引用
- Conte GM, Castellano A, Altabella L, et al. Reproducibility of dynamic contrast-enhanced MRI and dynamic susceptibility contrast MRI in the study of brain gliomas: a comparison of data obtained using different commercial software. Radiol Med. 2017. PMID: 28070841. doi:10.1007/s11547-016-0720-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。