患者如何看待介入放射科医生:基于领先医生评分网站的评价
本研究通过领先的医生评分网站Healthgrades,对全美2,774名参与Medicare的自我认定介入放射科医生(IRs)进行查询,最终纳入781名有患者评价的IRs。结果显示IRs的平均推荐可能性评分为4.3±1.2(中位数5.0),64.5%获得5分,10.5%获得低于3分;推荐可能性与等待时间较短显著相关(P<.001),而与医生性别、地理区域、年龄、毕业年限或执业组规模无关。结论认为美国IRs在领先医生评分网站上的满意度评分总体为很好至优秀。
要点
- IRs平均推荐可能性评分为4.3±1.2,中位数5.0,64.5%获5分,10.5%获低于3分。
- 推荐可能性与办公室相关因素(r=0.738至0.780)和医生相关因素(r=0.918至0.946)均呈显著相关。
- 等待时间较短者推荐可能性显著更高(P<.001),与医生性别、地理区域、年龄、毕业年限或执业组规模无关。
核心结论
- 美国IRs在领先医生评分网站上的满意度评分总体为很好至优秀,多数留下评价的患者可能向亲友推荐自己的IRs,推荐可能性与等待时间差异强烈相关。
研究设计与样本
- 研究通过手动查询医生评分网站Healthgrades,针对所有2,774名参与Medicare的自我认定IRs,纳入781名主要「向亲友推荐可能性」字段有评分的患者评价IRs;医生特征从Medicare数据集提取,所有可用患者满意度评分(1分差至5分优秀)和等待时间从Healthgrades提取,并探索各指标间的关联。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 患者满意度评分采用1分(差)至5分(优秀)量表,包括推荐可能性、预约便利性、办公环境、员工友好度、对医生决策的信任、医生解释病情的好坏、医生倾听并回答问题的好坏、医生是否花费适当时间与患者相处。
- IRs平均推荐可能性评分为4.3±1.2(中位数5.0;64.5%获5分;10.5%获低于3分)。
- 办公室相关因素平均评分为4.4至4.5,医生相关因素平均评分为4.3至4.5。
- 推荐可能性与办公室相关因素相关系数r=0.738至0.780,与医生相关因素相关系数r=0.918至0.946。
- 等待时间较短者推荐可能性显著更高(P<.001);与医生性别或地理区域无关(P=0.370-0.791);与医生年龄、毕业年限或执业组规模无相关性(r=-0.089至0.096)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to evaluate patient satisfaction scores for interventional radiologists (IRs) across the United States using a leading physician ratings website.
METHODS: The physician ratings website Healthgrades was manually queried for all 2,774 Medicare-participating self-designated IRs. All patient-reviewed IRs for whom the primary "likelihood of recommending to family and friends" field was scored were included, resulting in 781 included IRs. Physician characteristics were extracted from Medicare data sets. All available patient satisfaction scores (1 [poor] to 5 [excellent]: likelihood to recommend, ease of scheduling, office environment, staff friendliness, trust in physician's decisions, how well physician explains condition, how well physician listens and answers questions, whether physician spends appropriate time with patients) and wait times were extracted from Healthgrades. Associations among measures were explored.
RESULTS: IRs' mean likelihood-to-recommend score was 4.3 ± 1.2 (median, 5.0; 64.5% received a score of 5; 10.5% received scores < 3). Mean scores ranged from 4.4 to 4.5 for office-related factors and from 4.3 to 4.5 for physician-related factors. Likelihood-to-recommend scores showed substantial correlations with office-related factors (r = 0.738 to 0.780) and physician-related factors (r = 0.918 to 0.946). Likelihood to recommend was significantly higher for IRs with shorter wait times (P < .001) but was not associated with physician gender or geographic region (P = 0.370-0.791), nor was there any correlation with physician age, years since graduation, or group practice size (r = -0.089 to 0.096).
CONCLUSIONS: Satisfaction scores on a leading physician ratings website generally range from very good to excellent for US IRs. Most patients leaving reviews are likely to recommend their own IRs to friends or family members. The likelihood to recommend is strongly associated with differences in wait times.
引用
- Obele CC, Duszak R, Hawkins CM, et al. What Patients Think About Their Interventional Radiologists: Assessment Using a Leading Physician Ratings Website. J Am Coll Radiol. 2016. PMID: 28017529. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2016.10.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。