高危女性乳腺MRI筛查的假阴性
研究分析高危女性年度乳腺MRI筛查中假阴性的频率与原因。32例乳腺癌中23例有MRI图像可回顾,10例(43%)存在可避免的诊断延迟,前次MRI被分类为假阴性筛查5例、假阴性评估7例、微小征象3例;常见原因包括遗漏小强化肿块、无变化的非肿块强化、对常规影像的过度信赖及过度依赖短期复查MRI。
要点
- 小强化灶、肿块和节段性非肿块强化是早期乳腺癌常见MRI特征。
- 非肿块强化在连续检查中无变化不能排除恶性。
- 建议对筛查和评估检查均进行双阅片,并确保MRI活检可及。
核心结论
- 小强化灶、肿块和节段性非肿块强化是早期乳腺癌常见MRI特征;非肿块强化在连续检查中无变化不能排除恶性;建议对筛查和评估检查均进行双阅片,确保MRI活检可及,短期复查MRI应限于重新评估可能为良性腺体强化的低怀疑区域,年度乳腺X线摄影在这些女性中仍重要。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,查询家族史门诊数据库,纳入高危乳腺癌女性中接受筛查MRI后2年内诊断为乳腺癌者;32例诊断为乳腺癌,23例有MRI图像可供两位放射科医生回顾并分类。
关键影像表现/征象
- 常见诊断延迟原因包括被遗漏的小强化肿块、在筛查间期几乎无变化的非肿块强化区域、评估时正常常规影像带来的虚假安心感,以及过度依赖短期复查MRI。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 前次MRI被分类为假阴性筛查5例(1例患病期、4例偶发期),假阴性评估7例,微小征象3例(3例女性被赋予双重分类)。
- 32例乳腺癌女性中23例有MRI图像可回顾;14例在MRI诊断,4例在间期乳腺X线摄影诊断,2例有症状诊断,1例超声偶然发现,2例在降低风险乳房切除术中诊断。
- 10例女性(43%)存在可能可避免的诊断延迟。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 双阅片筛查和评估检查被推荐。
- MRI活检的便捷可及至关重要。
- 短期复查MRI应限于重新评估可能为良性腺体强化的低怀疑区域。
- 年度乳腺X线摄影在这些女性中仍重要。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To determine the frequency of and reasons for false-negative breast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) examinations in high-risk women undergoing annual screening.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The family history clinic database was interrogated and women at high risk of breast cancer who had undergone screening MRI and been diagnosed with breast cancer within 2 years of the MRI examination were identified. All available MRI examinations were reviewed and classified by two radiologists.
RESULTS: Of 32 women diagnosed with breast cancer, 23 had MRI images available for review. Fourteen were diagnosed at MRI, four at interim mammography, two symptomatically, one incidentally on ultrasound, and two at risk-reducing mastectomy. Ten women (43%) had potentially avoidable delays in diagnosis. The preceding MRIs were classified as false-negative screens in five women (one prevalent, four incident), false-negative assessment in seven and minimal signs in three (three women were assigned dual classifications). Common reasons for diagnostic delay included small enhancing masses that were overlooked, areas of non-mass enhancement that showed little or no change between screens, false reassurance from normal conventional imaging at assessment, and overreliance on short-interval repeat MRI.
CONCLUSION: Small enhancing foci, masses, and areas of segmental non-mass enhancement are common MRI features of early breast cancer. Lack of change of non-mass enhancement on serial examinations does not exclude malignancy. Double reading of both screening and assessment examinations is recommended. Ready access to MRI biopsy is essential. Short-interval repeat MRI should be limited to reassessing low suspicion areas likely to be benign glandular enhancement. Annual mammography remains important in these women.
引用
- Maxwell AJ, Lim YY, Hurley E, et al. False-negative MRI breast screening in high-risk women. Clin Radiol. 2016. PMID: 27932250. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2016.10.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。