检查者经验与足月超声估计胎儿体重准确性的纵向评估
这项多中心研究纳入18名超声培训初期检查者完成的4613次超声估计胎儿体重,采用多变量混合回归模型分析检查者经验(检查次数)对准确性(百分比误差和绝对百分比误差)的影响,并用累积和法分析个体学习曲线。结果显示检查次数对准确性有显著影响(P < .001),典型学习曲线在约200次检查前准确性改善,200至300次之间诊断性能开始下降并持续至研究结束;个体学习曲线差异很大。结论提示在超声估计胎儿体重中持续质量控制体系非常重要。
要点
- 检查次数对超声估计胎儿体重准确性有显著影响(P < .001)。
- 典型学习曲线在约200次检查前准确性改善,200至300次之间诊断性能开始下降。
- 个体累积和学习曲线在不同检查者间差异很大。
核心结论
- 检查者经验(检查次数)对足月超声估计胎儿体重的准确性有显著影响,典型学习曲线在约200次检查前准确性改善,之后诊断性能下降,提示持续质量控制体系非常重要。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心研究,纳入18名超声培训初期检查者完成的4613次超声估计胎儿体重;采用多变量混合回归模型分析,以百分比误差和绝对百分比误差为结局变量,检查者、检查者经验(检查次数)、出生体重、孕龄、超声至分娩间隔及母亲体重指数为固定效应,围产中心为随机截距。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 回归分析显示检查次数对超声估计胎儿体重准确性有显著影响(P < .001)。
- 典型学习曲线显示准确性改善直至约200次检查;200至300次检查之间诊断性能开始下降,并持续下降至研究期结束。
- 累积和图表显示的个体学习曲线在不同检查者间差异很大。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the influence of examiner experience on the accuracy of sonographic weight estimation and to further analyze examiners' individual learning curves.
METHODS: In this multicenter study, 4613 sonographic weight estimations performed by 18 examiners at the beginning of their ultrasound training were included. To assess the effect of experience on the accuracy of weight estimation, a multivariable mixed regression model analysis was performed, with percentage error and absolute percentage error as outcome variables and the examiner, the examiner's experience (number of examinations), birth weight, gestational age, scan-to-delivery interval, and maternal body mass index as fixed effects and the perinatal center as random intercepts. To further analyze the individual learning curves of the examiners, the cumulative summation technique was used.
RESULTS: Regression analyses showed a significant influence of the number of examinations on the accuracy of sonographic weight estimation after adjustment for the above-mentioned parameters (P < .001). A typical learning curve with improving accuracy was found until approximately 200 examinations. Between 200 and 300 examinations, the diagnostic performance started to deteriorate again, with a continuous decrease until the end of the study period. Cumulative summation charts representing individual learning curves varied greatly between different examiners.
CONCLUSIONS: These findings indicate the great importance of continuous quality control systems in sonographic weight estimation.
引用
- Faschingbauer F, Heimrich J, Raabe E, et al. Longitudinal Assessment of Examiner Experience and the Accuracy of Sonographic Fetal Weight Estimation at Term. J Ultrasound Med. 2016. PMID: 27914178. doi:10.7863/ultra.16.01074
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。