文献速递泌尿生殖腹部CT

前列腺癌放疗中直肠作为危及器官的不同勾画定义及预测直肠炎症的剂量-体积参数比较:应选用哪种定义

Comparison of different contouring definitions of the rectum as organ at risk (OAR) and dose-volume parameters predicting rectal inflammation in radiotherapy of prostate cancer: which definition to use?
PubMed 文献 · Br J Radiol · 2016-12-12

这项回顾性计划研究比较了13种直肠勾画定义,筛选出RTOG解剖定义与两种基于靶区的功能定义,在97例根治性三维适形外照射和66例术后生化复发挽救性放疗患者中分析剂量-体积直方图参数与直肠炎症的相关性。结果显示各勾画定义下DVH参数均与直肠毒性无相关性,加入临床因素后预测能力提高,但三种定义间预测直肠炎症的概率无实质差异。

要点

  • RTOG解剖定义勾画的直肠体积大于功能定义,且相对DVH参数方差更大。
  • 无论采用哪种直肠勾画定义,所研究的DVH参数均与直肠毒性无相关性。
  • 三种勾画定义预测直肠炎症发生概率的效能无实质差异。

核心结论

  • 与功能定义相比,RTOG基于解剖的推荐意见值得质疑,因其导致多个相对DVH参数方差更高。
  • 解剖定义在临床终点预测价值上既不优于也不劣于功能定义。
  • 功能定义更易应用、勾画更快、方差更小,且提供的信息不少于解剖定义。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性计划研究:预研究分析23例接受根治性外照射的前列腺癌患者计划CT,按13种定义勾画直肠并生成DVH曲线。
  • 主研究在两个连续队列中分析三种勾画定义(RTOG解剖定义及两种基于靶区的功能定义)衍生的相对DVH参数与放疗期间及之后直肠毒性的相关性。
  • 第一队列97例接受初次根治性外照射,第二队列66例接受前列腺切除术后生化复发的挽救性治疗。
  • 直肠毒性通过临床检查评估并按不良事件通用术语标准评分。
  • 候选参数包括直肠体积、平均剂量、最大剂量、V60、DVH曲线25 Gy以下面积及75 Gy以下面积,并采用多变量逻辑回归纳入盆腔淋巴引流区vs局部靶区、糖尿病、既往直肠手术、抗凝治疗或痔疮等临床因素。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 队列1中RTOG、基于计划靶区(PTV)及PTV关联三种定义的直肠平均体积分别为100 cm3(标准差43 cm3)、60 cm3(标准差26 cm3)和74 cm3(标准差31 cm3),p<0.01(方差分析)。
  • 队列1中上述三种定义的直肠平均剂量分别为35 Gy(标准差8 Gy)、48 Gy(标准差4 Gy)和44 Gy(标准差5 Gy),p<0.01。
  • 队列2中三种定义的直肠平均体积分别为114 cm3(标准差47 cm3)、64 cm3(标准差26 cm3)和81 cm3(标准差30 cm3),p<0.01。
  • 队列2中三种定义的直肠平均剂量分别为36 Gy(标准差8 Gy)、49 Gy(标准差5 Gy)和44 Gy(标准差5 Gy),p<0.01。
  • 队列1急性或亚急性直肠炎症发生69例(71.9%),队列2发生43例(70.5%)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者认为功能定义的直肠危及器官勾画更易应用、勾画更快、方差更小,且提供的信息不亚于解剖定义。
  • 作者认为RTOG基于解剖的推荐意见值得质疑,因其导致多个相对DVH参数方差更高。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this retrospective planning study was to find a contouring definition for the rectum as an organ at risk (OAR) in curative three-dimensional external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) for prostate cancer (PCa) with a predictive correlation between the dose-volume histogram (DVH) and rectal toxicity.

METHODS: In a pre-study, the planning CT scans of 23 patients with PCa receiving definitive EBRT were analyzed. The rectum was contoured according to 13 different definitions, and the dose distribution was correlated with the respective rectal volumes by generating DVH curves. Three definitions were identified to represent the most distinct differences in the shapes of the DVH curves: one anatomical definition recommended by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) and two functional definitions based on the target volume. In the main study, the correlation between different relative DVH parameters derived from these three contouring definitions and the occurrence of rectal toxicity during and after EBRT was studied in two consecutive collectives. The first cohort consisted of 97 patients receiving primary curative EBRT and the second cohort consisted of 66 patients treated for biochemical recurrence after prostatectomy. Rectal toxicity was investigated by clinical investigation and scored according to the Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events. Candidate parameters were the volume of the rectum, mean dose, maximal dose, volume receiving at least 60 Gy (V60), area under the DVH curve up to 25 Gy and area under the DVH curve up to 75 Gy in dependence of each chosen rectum definition. Multivariable logistic regression considered other clinical factors such as pelvine lymphatics vs local target volume, diabetes, prior rectal surgery, anticoagulation or haemorrhoids too.

RESULTS: In Cohort 1 (primary EBRT), the mean rectal volumes for definitions "RTOG", planning target volume "(PTV)-based" and "PTV-linked" were 100 cm3 [standard deviation (SD) 43 cm3], 60 cm3 (SD 26 cm3) and 74 cm3 (SD 31 cm3), respectively (p < 0.01; analysis of variance). The mean rectal doses according to these definitions were 35 Gy (SD 8 Gy), 48 Gy (SD 4 Gy) and 44 Gy (SD 5 Gy) (p < 0.01). In Cohort 2 (salvage EBRT), the mean rectal volumes were 114 cm3 (SD 47 cm3), 64 cm3 (SD 26 cm3) and 81 cm3 (SD 30 cm3) (p < 0.01) and the mean doses received by the rectum were 36 Gy (SD 8 Gy), 49 Gy (SD 5 Gy) and 44 Gy (SD 5 Gy) (p < 0.01). Acute or subacute rectal inflammation occurred in 69 (71.9%) patients in Cohort 1 and in 43 (70.5%) in Cohort 2. We did not find a correlation between all investigated DVH parameters and rectal toxicity, irrespective of the investigated definition. By adding additional variables in multivariate analysis, the predictive ability was substantially improved. Still, there was essentially no difference in the probability of predicting rectal inflammation occurrence between the tested contouring definitions.

CONCLUSION: The RTOG anatomy-based recommendations are questionable in comparison with functional definitions, as they result in higher variances in several relative DVH parameters. Moreover, the anatomy-based definition is no better and no worse in the predictive value concerning clinical end points. Advances in knowledge: Functional definitions for the rectum as OAR are easier to apply, faster to contour, have smaller variances and do not offer less information than the anatomy-based RTOG definition.

来源:Br J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nitsche M, Brannath W, Brückner M, et al. Comparison of different contouring definitions of the rectum as organ at risk (OAR) and dose-volume parameters predicting rectal inflammation in radiotherapy of prostate cancer: which definition to use? Br J Radiol. 2016. PMID: 27936891. doi:10.1259/bjr.20160370

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。