辐射剂量随时间的演变:三代计算机断层扫描设备全身检查患者队列的测量
该研究从PACS提取1451例、747例和1861例分别使用第三代双源CT、第二代双源CT和64层单源CT行胸腹盆单期螺旋CT检查的患者,比较辐射剂量与图像质量;第三代双源CT的CTDIvol较第二代双源CT和单源CT分别低26.9%和44.3%,SSDE分别低31.5%和51%,主观图像质量在三代设备间均优良(p=0.38-0.98)。
要点
- 第三代双源CT在个体间分析中CTDIvol较第二代双源CT低26.9%、较单源CT低44.3%。
- 第三代双源CT的SSDE较第二代双源CT低31.5%、较单源CT低51%。
- 三代CT主观图像质量均优良(p=0.38-0.98),定量图像质量双源CT优于单源CT(p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 现代CT设备可在不影响图像质量的前提下大幅降低辐射剂量。
研究设计与样本
- 研究从PACS服务器提取1451例、747例和1861例分别使用第三代双源CT、第二代双源CT和64层单源CT行胸腹盆单期螺旋CT检查的患者,并进行个体间分析;个体内分析纳入203例第三代双源CT患者,其中155例有第二代双源CT同种检查、91例有单源CT同种检查、43例有三代设备检查。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 个体间分析中,第三代双源CT的CTDIvol较第二代双源CT低26.9%、较单源CT低44.3%。
- 个体间分析中,第三代双源CT的SSDE较第二代双源CT低31.5%、较单源CT低51%。
- 个体内分析中,第三代双源CT的CTDIvol较第二代双源CT低33%、较单源CT低45%。
- 个体内分析中,第三代双源CT的SSDE较第二代双源CT低29%、较单源CT低43%。
- 三代CT主观图像质量均优良(p=0.38-0.98);双源CT定量图像质量优于单源CT(p<0.001);第三代双源CT肝实质SNR和CNR优于第二代双源CT(p<0.001),主动脉无差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate and compare the radiation dose and image quality of whole-body-CT (WBCT) performed on the 3rd-generation dual-source-CT (DSCT) with 2nd-generation DSCT and 64-slices-Single-Source-CT (SSCT) in a large patient cohort.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: Using a monitoring and tracking software 1451, 747 and 1861 patients scanned with a one-spiral-thorax-abdomen-pelvis-CT-examination on a 3rd-, 2nd-generation DSCT and SSCT, respectively, were extracted from the PACS server. For the intra-individual analysis, 203 patients on the 3rd-generation DSCT were identified. Out of those 203 patients, 155 had the same examination on the 2nd-generation DSCT, 91 patients had the same examination on the SSCT and 43 patients had an examination on all three CT-generations. Automatic tube current modulation was active on all three CT-generations, whereas automatic tube voltage selection was only available on both DSCT-generations. Dose was recorded by the size-specific-dose-estimate-method (SSDE); signal-to-noise-ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise-ratio (CNR) were calculated placing a ROI on the ascending aorta/liver and the subcutaneous adipose tissue at comparable level. Image quality of axillary and mediastinal lymph nodes and adrenal glands was assessed by two experienced radiologists.
RESULTS: Subjective image quality was excellent throughout all three CT-generations (p=0.38-0.98). Quantitative image quality in both DSCT generations was superior to SSCT (p<0.001). SNR and CNR in the liver parenchyma were superior in the 3rd-generation DSCT compared to the 2nd generation DSCT (p<0.001), whereas there was no difference in the aorta. In the inter-individual analysis, CTDIvol was lower by 26.9% and 44.3% in the 3rd-generation DSCT, when compared to the 2nd-generation DSCT and SSCT, respectively; SSDE was lower by 31.5% and 51% in the 3rd-generation DSCT, when compared to the 2nd-generation DSCT and SSCT, respectively. In the intra-individual comparison CTDIVol in the 3rd-generation DSCT was lower by 33% and 45%, when compared to the 2nd-gneration DSCT and the SSCT, respectively. Consequently, SSDE in the 3rd-generation DSCT was lower by 29% and by 43% when compared to the 2nd-generation DSCT and SSCT, respectively.
CONCLUSION: State-of-the-art CT-equipment substantially reduce radiation dose without affecting image quality.
引用
- Marcus RP, Koerner E, Aydin RC, et al. The evolution of radiation dose over time: Measurement of a patient cohort undergoing whole-body examinations on three computer tomography generations. Eur J Radiol. 2016. PMID: 28027768. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2016.11.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。