英国国家审计:成人非创伤性腹痛急诊腹部CT解读准确性
英国皇家放射学院注册的188个放射科中109个参与回顾性审计,纳入2013年连续4931例(外科2568例、非外科2363例)因非创伤性腹痛行急诊腹部CT的患者。住院医师、现场顾问及顾问补充报告的初报重大差异率分别为4.6%、3.1%、2.9%,均达标;院外报告者总体8.7%、外科患者12.7%,未达标。外科组患者受害率1.5%未达标,总体1%接近未达标。
要点
- 住院医师初报重大差异率4.6%、现场顾问3.1%、顾问补充报告2.9%,均达到审计标准。
- 院外报告者重大差异率总体8.7%、外科患者12.7%,未达到5%的审计标准。
- 外科组患者受害率1.5%未达标(目标<1%),总体1%接近未达标。
核心结论
- 院外急诊CT报告质量不达标,现场及更高级别(顾问)放射科医师的解读/复核可带来明确获益。
研究设计与样本
- 英国皇家放射学院注册的放射科参与的回顾性审计,109/188个科室提供数据,共4931例(外科2568例、非外科2363例),纳入2013年连续前50例(每科室25例外科、25例非外科)因非创伤性腹痛行急诊腹部CT的患者。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 住院医师初报重大差异率目标<10%,实际4.6%。
- 现场顾问初报重大差异率目标<5%,实际3.1%。
- 顾问补充报告重大差异率目标<5%,实际2.9%。
- 院外报告者重大差异率目标<5%,总体实际8.7%、外科患者实际12.7%。
- 患者受害率目标<1%,外科组实际1.5%、总体实际1%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为本研究应推动改进非工作时间CT报告。
- 作者指出现场及更高级别(顾问)放射科医师的CT解读/复核已显示出明确获益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To evaluate major/minor discrepancy rates for provisional (initial) and addendum (supplementary senior review) emergency computed tomography (CT) reports in patients presenting with non-traumatic abdominal pain.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Ethical approval for this type of study is not required in the UK. All radiology departments with an approved lead for audit registered with the Royal College of Radiologists were invited to participate in this retrospective audit. The first 50 consecutive patients (25 surgical, 25 non-surgical) who underwent emergency abdominal CT for non-traumatic abdominal pain in 2013 were included. Statistical analyses were performed to identify organisational and report/patient-related variables that might be associated with major discrepancy.
RESULTS: One hundred and nine (58%) of 188 departments supplied data to the study with a total of 4,931 patients (2,568 surgical, 2,363 non-surgical). The audit standard for provisional report major discrepancy was achieved for registrars (target <10%, achieved 4.6%), for on-site consultants (target <5%, achieved 3.1%) and consultant addendum (target <5%, achieved 2.9%). Off-site reporters failed to meet the standard target (<5%, achieved 8.7% overall and 12.7% in surgical patients). The standard for patients coming to harm was not met in the surgical group (target <1%, achieved 1.5%) and was narrowly missed overall (target <1%, achieved 1%).
CONCLUSION: This study should be used to provide impetus to improve aspects of out-of-hours CT reporting. Clear benefits of CT interpretation/review by on-site and more senior (consultant) radiologists have been demonstrated.
引用
- Howlett DC, Drinkwater K, Frost C, et al. The accuracy of interpretation of emergency abdominal CT in adult patients who present with non-traumatic abdominal pain: results of a UK national audit. Clin Radiol. 2016. PMID: 27927488. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2016.10.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。