血管封堵器与可推送弹簧圈在TIPS术后静脉曲张栓塞中的比较
单中心回顾性比较TIPS术后静脉曲张栓塞使用血管封堵器(20例)与匹配弹簧圈队列的结局和材料成本。封堵器组透视时间和总手术时间更短,但单次手术材料成本显著更高;随访≥30天患者再出血率和死亡率两组相似。作者认为两种材料结局相似,封堵器的时间优势可能被增加的材料成本抵消,这一权衡值得进一步研究。
要点
- 封堵器组透视时间中位数49.05分钟,低于弹簧圈组的68分钟(p=0.006)。
- 封堵器组总手术时间中位数255分钟,低于弹簧圈组的275分钟(p=0.05)。
- 随访≥30天患者再出血率封堵器组2/17(12%)vs弹簧圈组4/15(27%),p=0.40,差异无统计学意义。
核心结论
- TIPS术后静脉曲张栓塞使用血管封堵器或弹簧圈的结局相似;封堵器减少透视时间和手术时间的优势可能被增加的材料成本抵消,这一权衡值得进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性研究,回顾2003年5月至2014年12月TIPS联合静脉曲张栓塞的医疗记录;封堵器组20例与按年龄、性别和MELD匹配的弹簧圈栓塞队列比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 封堵器组透视时间中位数49.05分钟(IQR 36–62)vs弹簧圈组68分钟(IQR 49–76),p=0.006。
- 封堵器组总手术时间中位数255分钟(IQR 205–290)vs弹簧圈组275分钟(IQR 230–330),p=0.05。
- 封堵器组对比剂总量中位数180 mL(IQR 155–234)vs弹簧圈组210 mL(IQR 185–261),p=0.14。
- 随访≥30天患者再出血率封堵器组2/17(12%)vs弹簧圈组4/15(27%),p=0.40。
- 随访≥30天患者死亡率封堵器组2/17(12%)vs弹簧圈组4/15(27%),p=0.66;单次手术材料成本封堵器组1292±676美元vs弹簧圈组228±292美元,p<0.0001。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为封堵器与弹簧圈结局相似,封堵器减少透视或手术时间的优势可能被增加的材料成本抵消。
- 作者指出在当前医疗成本关注下,这一权衡值得进一步研究。
局限性
- 作者指出封堵器减少透视或手术时间的优势可能被增加的材料成本抵消,这一权衡值得进一步研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) with variceal embolization is routinely performed to treat variceal bleeding. Embolization using vascular plugs is reported, but outcomes are not known. Outcomes and material costs of embolization using vascular plugs and coils are compared.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A single center's medical records of TIPS procedures (May 2003-December 2014) with variceal embolization were reviewed. Twenty patients with vascular plug embolization (age [± SD], 50 ± 10 years; seven men and 13 women; median Model for End-Stage Liver Disease [MELD], 20; interquartile range [IQR], 14-23) were compared with an age-, sex-, and MELD-matched cohort who underwent coil embolization (age, 50 ± 9 years; seven men and 13 women; median MELD, 17; IQR, 15-19; p = 0.52). Procedure details, primary outcome (rebleeding), secondary outcome (mortality), and costs were compared.
RESULTS: Vascular plug use was associated with a lower fluoroscopy time (49.05 minutes [IQR, 36-62] vs 68 minutes [IQR, 49-76]; p = 0.006) and total procedure time (255 minutes [IQR, 205-290] for vascular plugs vs 275 minutes [IQR, 230-330]; p = 0.05). Total volume of contrast agent used was similar (180 mL [IQR, 155-234] for vascular plugs vs 210 mL [IQR, 185-261]; p = 0.14). In patients with at least a 30-day follow-up, rebleeding rates (2/17 [12%] for vascular plugs vs 4/15 [27%]; p = 0.40) and mortality (2/17 [12%] for vascular plugs vs 4/15 [27%]; p = 0.66) were similar. Per procedure, vascular plugs cost significantly more than coils ($1292 ± $676 vs $228 ± $292, p < 0.0001).
CONCLUSION: The use of vascular plugs or coils has similar outcomes for variceal embolization after TIPS. The advantages of vascular plug use (i.e., reduced fluoroscopy or procedure time) may be offset by increased material cost, a trade-off that merits further study given current cost concerns in health care.
引用
- Sarwar A, Esparaz AM, Tapper EB, et al. Comparison of Vascular Plugs and Pushable Coils for Variceal Embolization After TIPS. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2016. PMID: 27959638. doi:10.2214/AJR.16.16012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。