文献速递技术与安全介入CTMRUSDR

高保真动手模拟与计算机模拟培训对对比剂反应管理和团队合作技能的比较效果

Comparative Effectiveness of Hands-on Versus Computer Simulation-Based Training for Contrast Media Reactions and Teamwork Skills.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Coll Radiol · 2016-11-02

本研究将护士、技师和放射科住院医师随机分为11个三人跨专业团队,分别接受高保真动手模拟(6队)或计算机模拟(5队)培训,比较对比剂反应管理和团队合作技能的表现。动手组在对比剂反应管理场景评分上倾向更高(95% vs 81%,P=0.17),团队合作技能两组相似(51% vs 52%,P=0.66),但两种培训的单次课程可能均不足以掌握团队合作技能。

要点

  • 动手模拟组对比剂反应管理场景评分95%,计算机模拟组81%,差异未达统计学显著(P=0.17)。
  • 两组团队合作技能评分相似(动手组51% vs 计算机组52%,P=0.66),且均低于对比剂反应管理技能评分。
  • 动手模拟作为有效教育工具的评分显著高于计算机模拟(P=0.01),在教授对比剂反应管理和团队沟通技能有效性上也更高(P=0.02)。

核心结论

  • 高保真模拟可用于培训和测试由放射科医师、技师和护士组成的跨专业团队在对比剂反应管理和团队合作技能方面的表现,且参与者对动手模拟作为有效教育工具的评价高于计算机模拟;但单次任何一种培训可能均不足以掌握团队合作技能。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机对照研究,将护士、技师和放射科住院医师随机分为11个三人团队(每队各一名),6队接受高保真动手模拟培训,5队接受计算机模拟培训,培训前后进行笔试,并使用高保真模拟场景进行测试。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 最终场景测试中,动手模拟组对比剂反应管理评分95% vs 计算机模拟组81%(P=0.17)。
  • 肾上腺素给药错误:动手模拟组0/6 vs 计算机模拟组2/5(P=0.18)。
  • 团队合作技能评分:动手模拟组51% vs 计算机模拟组52%(P=0.66)。
  • 团队合作技能评分低于对比剂反应管理技能评分:动手模拟组P=0.03,计算机模拟组P=0.06。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 高保真模拟可用于培训和测试跨专业团队在对比剂反应管理和团队合作技能方面的表现。
  • 单次任何类型的培训可能不足以掌握团队合作技能。
  • 参与者对动手模拟作为有效教育工具的评价高于计算机模拟(P=0.01),在教授对比剂反应管理和团队沟通技能有效性上也更高(P=0.02)。

局限性

  • 单次任何一种培训可能均不足以掌握团队合作技能。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: To assess the performance of interprofessional teams of radiologists, technologists, and nurses trained with high-fidelity hands-on (HO) simulation and computer-based (CB) simulation training for contrast reaction management (CR) and teamwork skills (TS).

METHODS: Nurses, technologists, and radiology residents were randomized into 11 teams of three (one of each). Six teams underwent HO training and five underwent CB training for CR and TS. Participants took written tests before and after training and were further tested using a high-fidelity simulation scenario.

RESULTS: HO and CB groups scored similarly on all written tests and each showed improvement after training (P = .002 and P = .018, respectively). During the final scenario test, HO teams tended to receive higher grades than CB teams on CR (95% versus 81%, P = .17) and made fewer errors in epinephrine administration (0/6 versus 2/5, P = .18). HO and CB teams scored similarly on TS (51% versus 52%, P = .66), but overall scores were lower for TS than for CR skills in both the HO (P = .03) and CB teams (P = .06). HO training was more highly rated than CB as an effective educational tool (P = .01) and for effectiveness at teaching CR and team communication skills (P = .02).

CONCLUSIONS: High-fidelity simulation can be used to both train and test interprofessional teams of radiologists, technologists, and nurses for both CR and TS and is more highly rated as an effective educational tool by participants than similar CB training. However, a single session of either type of training may be inadequate for mastering TS.

来源:J Am Coll Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Wang CL, Chinnugounder S, Hippe DS, et al. Comparative Effectiveness of Hands-on Versus Computer Simulation-Based Training for Contrast Media Reactions and Teamwork Skills. J Am Coll Radiol. 2016. PMID: 27815053. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2016.07.013

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。