对比增强能谱乳腺X线摄影与乳腺X线摄影及MRI的多阅片者临床效能评估
前瞻性两中心多阅片者研究纳入178例浸润性乳腺癌和/或导管原位癌患者,比较对比增强能谱乳腺X线摄影(CESM)、乳腺X线摄影(MG)及MRI的诊断效能。CESM单独及CESM+MG的ROC曲线下面积均显著大于MG,与MRI无显著差异;CESM联合MG未提高诊断效能;致密乳腺获益最大。
要点
- CESM单独诊断效能与MRI相当,ROC-AUC分别为0.84和0.85,无显著差异。
- CESM及CESM+MG的ROC-AUC均显著大于MG(0.84、0.83 vs 0.76),致密乳腺优势最大。
- CESM联合MG未提高诊断效能,CESM敏感度低于MRI但特异度高于MRI。
核心结论
- CESM单独及联合MG诊断准确性与MRI相当,病灶检出优于MG。
- 致密乳腺患者从CESM获益最大,且相比MG增加的辐射剂量最小。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性两中心多阅片者研究,纳入178例浸润性乳腺癌和/或导管原位癌女性(平均年龄53岁)。
- MG、CESM及CESM+MG由3名盲法放射科医生基于修订的ACR BI-RADS标准评估;MRI由另一组3名阅片者评估。
- 比较ROC曲线,并将各模态所有阅片者均检出的70个病灶的尺寸测量与病理结果进行相关性分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CESM单独ROC-AUC为0.84,CESM+MG为0.83,均显著大于MG的0.76。
- MRI的ROC-AUC为0.85,与CESM单独及CESM+MG均无显著差异。
- 病灶尺寸测量与病理的Pearson相关系数:MG为0.61,CESM为0.69,CESM+MG为0.70,MRI为0.79。
- CESM敏感度低于MRI但特异度高于MRI;敏感度差异在致密乳腺更明显,在非致密乳腺无统计学意义。
临床应用与阅片要点
- CESM单独及联合MG诊断准确性与MRI相当,病灶检出优于MG,尤其适用于致密乳腺。
- CESM联合MG未提高诊断效能,阅片时可关注CESM单独评估价值。
- CESM敏感度低于MRI但特异度高于MRI,在致密乳腺中敏感度差异更明显。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the diagnostic performance of contrast-enhanced spectral mammography (CESM) to digital mammography (MG) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in a prospective two-centre, multi-reader study.
METHODS: One hundred seventy-eight women (mean age 53 years) with invasive breast cancer and/or DCIS were included after ethics board approval. MG, CESM and CESM + MG were evaluated by three blinded radiologists based on amended ACR BI-RADS criteria. MRI was assessed by another group of three readers. Receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curves were compared. Size measurements for the 70 lesions detected by all readers in each modality were correlated with pathology.
RESULTS: Reading results for 604 lesions were available (273 malignant, 4 high-risk, 327 benign). The area under the ROC curve was significantly larger for CESM alone (0.84) and CESM + MG (0.83) compared to MG (0.76) (largest advantage in dense breasts) while it was not significantly different from MRI (0.85). Pearson correlation coefficients for size comparison were 0.61 for MG, 0.69 for CESM, 0.70 for CESM + MG and 0.79 for MRI.
CONCLUSIONS: This study showed that CESM, alone and in combination with MG, is as accurate as MRI but is superior to MG for lesion detection. Patients with dense breasts benefitted most from CESM with the smallest additional dose compared to MG.
KEY POINTS: • CESM has comparable diagnostic performance (ROC-AUC) to MRI for breast cancer diagnostics. • CESM in combination with MG does not improve diagnostic performance. • CESM has lower sensitivity but higher specificity than MRI. • Sensitivity differences are more pronounced in dense and not significant in non-dense breasts. • CESM and MRI are significantly superior to MG, particularly in dense breasts.
引用
- Fallenberg EM, Schmitzberger FF, Amer H, et al. Contrast-enhanced spectral mammography vs. mammography and MRI - clinical performance in a multi-reader evaluation. Eur Radiol. 2016. PMID: 27896471. doi:10.1007/s00330-016-4650-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。