社区放射科医生对乳腺X线召回意见的一致性:按病例难度与发现类型分析
研究纳入6个乳腺X线登记处的119名社区放射科医生,随机分配阅读4套测试集之一(每套109例筛查乳腺X线),评估召回意见与专家共识的一致性。结果显示肿块和明显病变的召回一致率为100%,而细微病变(50%)和非对称致密影(60%)在癌症病例中一致性较低;非对称致密影和结构扭曲的发现类型一致率最低(分别为40%和43%),且大多数不必要召回(51%)为非对称致密影。作者认为针对这些解读的培训可提高乳腺X线准确性并减少不必要召回。
要点
- 肿块和明显病变的召回一致率达100%,细微病变和非对称致密影在癌症病例中一致率分别为50%和60%。
- 非对称致密影和结构扭曲的发现类型一致率低(分别为40%和43%),且51%的不必要召回为非对称致密影。
- 针对非对称致密影和结构扭曲解读的培训可能提高乳腺X线准确性并减少不必要召回。
核心结论
- 乳腺X线解读在非对称致密影和结构扭曲上的一致性较低,针对这些解读的培训可提高准确性并减少不必要召回。
研究设计与样本
- 从6个乳腺X线登记处招募119名社区放射科医生,随机分配阅读4套测试集之一(每套109例筛查乳腺X线,含对比研究),评估是否召回、最显著发现类型(肿块、钙化、非对称致密影或结构扭曲)及位置;以专家放射学小组的共识解读为参考标准,计算按癌症状态、发现类型和难度水平(患者、乳腺、病变水平)的平均一致比例,并分析发现类型的一致性和不必要召回比例。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 肿块和明显病变的召回一致率为100%(癌症和非癌症病例均如此)。
- 癌症病例中,细微病变的召回一致率为50%,非对称致密影为60%。
- 非癌症病例中,细微病变和良性钙化的召回一致率为33%。
- 发现类型一致率:结构扭曲43%,非对称致密影40%。
- 不必要召回(研究放射科医生召回但专家小组未召回)中51%为非对称致密影。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为针对非对称致密影和结构扭曲解读的培训可提高乳腺X线准确性并减少不必要召回。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to assess agreement of mammographic interpretations by community radiologists with consensus interpretations of an expert radiology panel to inform approaches that improve mammographic performance.
METHODS: From 6 mammographic registries, 119 community-based radiologists were recruited to assess 1 of 4 randomly assigned test sets of 109 screening mammograms with comparison studies for no recall or recall, giving the most significant finding type (mass, calcifications, asymmetric density, or architectural distortion) and location. The mean proportion of agreement with an expert radiology panel was calculated by cancer status, finding type, and difficulty level of identifying the finding at the patient, breast, and lesion level. Concordance in finding type between study radiologists and the expert panel was also examined. For each finding type, the proportion of unnecessary recalls, defined as study radiologist recalls that were not expert panel recalls, was determined.
RESULTS: Recall agreement was 100% for masses and for examinations with obvious findings in both cancer and noncancer cases. Among cancer cases, recall agreement was lower for lesions that were subtle (50%) or asymmetric (60%). Subtle noncancer findings and benign calcifications showed 33% agreement for recall. Agreement for finding responsible for recall was low, especially for architectural distortions (43%) and asymmetric densities (40%). Most unnecessary recalls (51%) were asymmetric densities.
CONCLUSIONS: Agreement in mammographic interpretation was low for asymmetric densities and architectural distortions. Training focused on these interpretations could improve the accuracy of mammography and reduce unnecessary recalls.
引用
- Onega T, Smith M, Miglioretti DL, et al. Radiologist Agreement for Mammographic Recall by Case Difficulty and Finding Type. J Am Coll Radiol. 2016. PMID: 27814827. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2016.09.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。