皮肤病变成像技术标准:一项德尔菲共识声明
国际皮肤成像协作组(ISIC)采用混合德尔菲法,经5轮评分与修订,就全身、区域、特写和皮肤镜水平的图像采集指标达成共识,最终形成33条推荐,涵盖光照、背景色、视野、图像方向、对焦/景深、分辨率、比例尺、色彩校准和图像存储等方面;共识认为采用这些标准化方法可能改善临床实践、信息交换、电子健康记录文档、临床研究协调和数据库建设,并指出需在真实临床条件下进行可行性和有效性测试。
要点
- 共识推荐覆盖皮肤图像采集的光照、背景色、视野、方向、对焦/景深、分辨率、比例尺、色彩校准和存储等指标。
- 最终形成33条推荐,包括一般推荐1条、光照5条、背景色3条、视野3条、图像方向8条、对焦/景深3条、分辨率4条、比例尺3条、色彩校准2条、图像存储1条。
- 采用标准化图像采集方法可能改善临床实践、信息交换、电子健康记录文档、临床研究协调和临床决策支持。
核心结论
- 通过迭代评分与评论过程,德尔菲法在皮肤科实践中的皮肤成像标准上达成了强共识。
- 采用这些图像标准化方法可能改善临床实践、信息交换、电子健康记录文档、临床研究协调和数据库建设以及临床决策支持。
- 需要在真实临床条件下进行可行性和有效性测试。
研究设计与样本
- 采用混合德尔菲法,进行5轮评分和修订直至达成相对共识。
- 初始陈述由核心组基于文献回顾和临床经验制定,经过2轮评分和修订。
- 共识过程由ISIC成员组成的扩展组通过2轮评分和修订进行验证。
- 所有轮次中,受访者对草案推荐按1(强烈同意)至5(强烈不同意)量表评分,对低于5分的评分解释原因,并可选择提供评论。
- 任何阶段,若平均评分和中位评分均为4或更高,则保留该推荐。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 最终扩展组推荐集共33条:一般推荐1条、光照5条、背景色3条、视野3条、图像方向8条、对焦/景深3条、分辨率4条、比例尺3条、色彩校准2条、图像存储1条。
- 初始45项(第1轮)经核心组扩展为56个变体(第2轮),随后缩减为42项由扩展组在第3轮评分,最终形成33条推荐(第4轮和第5轮)。
- 推荐保留标准为平均评分和中位评分均≥4(量表1=强烈同意至5=强烈不同意)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需要在真实临床条件下进行可行性和有效性测试。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Variability in the metrics for image acquisition at the total body, regional, close-up, and dermoscopic levels impacts the quality and generalizability of skin images. Consensus guidelines are indicated to achieve universal imaging standards in dermatology.
OBJECTIVE: To achieve consensus among members of the International Skin Imaging Collaboration (ISIC) on standards for image acquisition metrics using a hybrid Delphi method.
EVIDENCE REVIEW: Delphi study with 5 rounds of ratings and revisions until relative consensus was achieved. The initial set of statements was developed by a core group (CG) on the basis of a literature review and clinical experience followed by 2 rounds of rating and revisions. The consensus process was validated by an extended group (EG) of ISIC members through 2 rounds of scoring and revisions. In all rounds, respondents rated the draft recommendations on a 1 (strongly agree) to 5 (strongly disagree) scale, explained ratings of less than 5, and optionally provided comments. At any stage, a recommendation was retained if both mean and median rating was 4 or higher.
RESULTS: The initial set of 45 items (round 1) was expanded by the CG to 56 variants in round 2, subsequently reduced to 42 items scored by the EG in round 3, yielding an EG set of 33 recommendations (rounds 4 and 5): general recommendation (1 guideline), lighting (5), background color (3), field of view (3), image orientation (8), focus/depth of field (3), resolution (4), scale (3), color calibration (2), and image storage (1).
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This iterative process of ratings and comments yielded a strong consensus on standards for skin imaging in dermatology practice. Adoption of these methods for image standardization is likely to improve clinical practice, information exchange, electronic health record documentation, harmonization of clinical studies and database development, and clinical decision support. Feasibility and validity testing under real-world clinical conditions is indicated.
引用
- Katragadda C, Finnane A, Soyer HP, et al. Technique Standards for Skin Lesion Imaging: A Delphi Consensus Statement. JAMA Dermatol. 2017. PMID: 27892996. doi:10.1001/jamadermatol.2016.3949
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。