放射科医生与放射技师对超声作为局灶性乳腺症状首选影像检查的考量:概念图研究
本研究采用数字概念图法,让放射科医生和放射技师独立生成、分类并评分与超声首选路径实施相关的陈述。放射科医生生成43条陈述分7类,最重视诊断准确性(5.41分)、指南(5.21分)和后勤规划(4.88分);放射技师生成35条陈述分4类,最重视组织与职责(4.91分)和沟通(4.74分)。结论认为两类人员既有共同也有专业特异的考量,优先主题差异反映不同专业角色,凸显改变既定影像路径的复杂性。
要点
- 放射科医生最关注超声首选的诊断准确性与指南依据。
- 放射技师更关注组织职责分工与沟通流程等操作层面。
- 实施超声首选路径需兼顾诊断可行性与运营角色差异。
核心结论
- 放射科医生和放射技师识别出与超声首选路径相关的共同和专业特异考量。
- 优先主题的差异反映不同专业角色,并凸显改变既定影像路径的复杂性。
- 这些发现可为未来研究和实施工作提供参考。
研究设计与样本
- 采用数字概念图法,放射科医生和放射技师独立生成、分类并评分相关陈述。
- 参与者基于7点量表对陈述进行评分,并据此推导和优先排序主题聚类。
- 放射科医生生成43条陈述归为7类,放射技师生成35条陈述归为4类。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 超声作为局灶性乳腺症状的首选诊断工具时,放射科医生应重点关注诊断准确性、指南依据和后勤规划。
- 放射技师在实施中需重视组织与职责分工及沟通流程,以保障路径顺畅。
- 改变既定影像路径时需认识不同专业角色的优先考量差异,协调推进。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告研究样本量、中心数及具体设备信息。
- 概念图法基于参与者主观评分,可能存在专业视角偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: Emerging evidence indicates that breast ultrasound can function as an effective stand-alone diagnostic tool for focal breast complaints, with digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) reserved for inconclusive cases. This study identifies and prioritizes radiologists' and radiographers' professional considerations regarding an ultrasound-first approach.
METHODS: Using digital concept mapping, radiologists and radiographers independently generated, categorized, and rated statements related to the implementation of ultrasound as the initial modality. Thematic clusters were derived and prioritized based on participant ratings (7-point scale).
RESULTS: Radiologists produced 43 statements across seven clusters: 1) Diagnostic accuracy, 2) Logistics and planning, 3) Communication, 4) Guidelines, 5) Patient satisfaction, 6) Age and screening, and 7) Accessibility of approach, prioritizing the clusters Diagnostic accuracy (rating 5.41), Guidelines (rating 5.21), and Logistics and planning (rating 4.88). Radiographers produced 35 statements in four clusters: 1) Communication, 2) Logistics and planning, 3) Organization and responsibilities, and 4) Patient satisfaction, placing greatest emphasis on the clusters Organization and responsibilities (rating 4.91) and Communication (rating 4.74). These patterns indicate that radiologists primarily emphasized diagnostic and clinical feasibility, whereas radiographers focused more on operational and role-related considerations.
CONCLUSION: Radiologists and radiographers identified both shared and profession-specific considerations related to an ultrasound-first approach. Differences in prioritized themes reflect distinct professional roles and highlight the complexity of changing established imaging pathways. These findings may inform future research and implementation efforts by drawing attention to profession-specific considerations relevant to the adoption of such pathways.
引用
- Siebers CCN, Appelman L, Mann RM, et al. Radiologists' and radiographers' considerations regarding the implementation of targeted ultrasound as primary imaging modality in patients with focal breast complaints: A concept mapping study. Eur J Radiol. 2026. PMID: 42913346. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2026.113307
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。