早期至中期职业放射科医师对非增强简化MRI用于HCC监测的阅片者间一致性研究
本研究回顾性分析614例非增强简化MRI(HASTE和DWI序列),评估四位早期至中期职业放射科医师在图像质量、观察检测及提出的AMRI-LI-RADS分类的阅片者间一致性。结果显示图像质量、观察检测和分类的一致性分别为显著至几乎完美(PABAK 0.807-0.995,kappa 0.742-0.993,kappa 0.641-0.915),但经验较少者倾向于给予更高图像质量评分并检测到更多观察,提示需标准化判读标准。
要点
- 非增强简化MRI在早期至中期职业放射科医师中显示出高阅片者间一致性。
- 经验较少的医师可能高估图像质量并过度检测观察,需注意判读阈值差异。
- AMRI-LI-RADS分类一致性较高,但经验对分类无显著影响。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Abbreviated MRI (AMRI) protocols may offer an alternative to ultrasound for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) surveillance in high-risk patients, but standardized assessment and interreader agreement are essential for clinical implementation. As surveillance programs expand, these examinations will increasingly be interpreted by early-to-mid career radiologists, making it critical to evaluate agreement within this workforce segment.
PURPOSE: To evaluate interreader agreement for image quality assessment, observation detection, and proposed AMRI-LI-RADS classification in non-contrast (NC) AMRI for HCC surveillance among early-to-mid career radiologists, and to assess the influence of experience within this cohort on interpretation patterns.
METHODS: In this retrospective analysis of 614 NC-AMRI examinations (HASTE and DWI sequences), four early-to-mid career radiologists (2, 4.5, 5.5, and 5.5 years of post-training experience in abdominal MRI) independently evaluated image quality (5-point scale), presence of observations (≥ 10mm), and proposed AMRI-LI-RADS classification (benign, equivocal, or malignant). Agreement was assessed using percentage agreement and prevalence-adjusted bias-adjusted kappa (PABAK) for image quality, and Cohen's kappa for observation detection and proposed AMRI-LI-RADS classification. Friedman test, Cochran's Q test, and Bhapkar test for marginal homogeneity were used to evaluate differences across experience levels, with subsequent pairwise comparisons and regression analyses to quantify experience-related effects.
RESULTS: Most examinations received excellent image quality ratings across all readers (HASTE: 73.3%-97.1%; DWI: 66.3%-93.7%). Interreader agreement was substantial for dichotomized image quality (PABAK: 0.807-0.995), observation detection (kappa: 0.742-0.993), and proposed AMRI-LI-RADS classification (kappa: 0.641-0.915). Reader experience significantly influenced assessments , with less experienced readers assigning higher quality scores and detecting more observations. There was no significant influence of reader experience on AMRI-LIRADS classification.
CONCLUSION: NC-AMRI demonstrates high interreader agreement for image quality assessment, observation detection, and proposed AMRI-LI-RADS classification among early-to-mid career radiologists, supporting reproducibility of NC-AMRI interpretation. However, significant reader-dependent differences in quality ratings and observation detection indicate systematic variations in reader thresholds, highlighting the importance of standardized interpretation criteria and reader calibration when implementing NC-AMRI surveillance programs.
引用
- Gupta P, Soundararajan R, Kumar A, et al. Interreader agreement for image quality, observation detection, and proposed AMRI-LI-RADS classification in non-contrast abbreviated MRI for hepatocellular carcinoma surveillance among early-to-mid career radiologists. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2026. PMID: 42377545. doi:10.1007/s00261-026-05659-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。