稀释对比剂三维旋转血管造影上的黑带征作为与血流导向装置治疗后颅内动脉瘤闭塞相关的潜在新生内膜标志物
单中心回顾性队列研究纳入2015年4月至2024年12月接受血流导向装置治疗的123例患者142个动脉瘤,评估稀释对比剂三维旋转血管造影上的黑带征(BBS)。稀释三维旋转血管造影评分者间信度最优(Light's κ=0.82),BBS分期随6个月O'Kelly-Marotta分级改善而进展,6个月未完全闭塞动脉瘤中完全BBS者12个月完全闭塞率71%,完全BBS较无BBS的12个月闭塞风险比为7.14(95%CI,1.07-47.8)。
要点
- 稀释对比剂三维旋转血管造影是评估黑带征的最佳技术,评分者间信度Light's κ=0.82。
- 6个月完全BBS者12个月完全闭塞率71%,无BBS者10%,完全BBS较无BBS的风险比为7.14(95%CI,1.07-47.8)。
- 白领征最常见于部分BBS且O'Kelly-Marotta B级的动脉瘤(75%),可能反映新生内膜形成不成熟。
核心结论
- 稀释三维旋转血管造影为评估BBS的最佳技术;BBS与同期动脉瘤闭塞状态一致并预测后续完全闭塞,支持其作为血流导向装置治疗后潜在新生内膜生物标志物;白领征可能反映血流导向装置治疗后不成熟的新生内膜形成。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性队列研究,纳入2015年4月至2024年12月连续接受血流导向装置治疗、完成6个月和12个月随访并在6个月时接受稀释三维旋转血管造影、纯三维旋转血管造影和高分辨率锥形束CT的患者,共123例患者142个动脉瘤;由3名盲法评估者分级6个月BBS(无、部分、完全);以评分者间信度确定最佳技术;采用Cochran Armitage检验比较不同6个月O'Kelly-Marotta分级间的BBS分期;在6个月未完全闭塞动脉瘤中比较不同BBS分期的12个月完全闭塞率,并用改良Poisson回归以患者水平聚类稳健标准误估计风险比;记录6个月二维DSA上的白领征。
关键影像表现/征象
- BBS为三维旋转血管造影上的管腔内带状充盈缺损。
- 随6个月O'Kelly-Marotta分级改善,主要BBS分期由无向部分、完全转变(无/部分/完全:OKM A为62/38/0%;B为25/75/0%;C为3/59/38%;D为1/7/91%;趋势P<.01)。
- 白领征最常见于部分BBS且OKM B级的动脉瘤(75%)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 稀释三维旋转血管造影评分者间信度最优:所有两两加权Cohen κ值均值(Light's κ)=0.82。
- 6个月未完全闭塞的61个动脉瘤中,12个月完全闭塞率:无BBS为10%,部分BBS为22%,完全BBS为71%。
- 与无BBS相比,12个月闭塞风险比:部分BBS为2.16(95%CI,0.30-15.5),完全BBS为7.14(95%CI,1.07-47.8)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 采用稀释三维旋转血管造影评估血流导向装置治疗后动脉瘤颈部的BBS,其评分者间信度优于纯三维旋转血管造影和高分辨率锥形束CT。
- 6个月随访时按无、部分、完全三级分级BBS,完全BBS与随后12个月完全闭塞相关(风险比7.14,95%CI,1.07-47.8)。
- 6个月二维DSA上的白领征可能与部分BBS及OKM B级共存,提示新生内膜形成不成熟。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Neointimal formation at the aneurysm neck is essential after flow diverter (FD) treatment; however, reliable imaging markers are lacking. The white collar sign (WCS), an established endothelialization marker after coil embolization, is paradoxically associated with incomplete occlusion after flow diversion. We aimed to propose the black belt sign (BBS), an endoluminal bandlike filling defect on 3D rotational angiography (3DRA), as a neointimal marker, determine the optimal imaging technique, and assess its association with aneurysm occlusion.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This single center, retrospective cohort study included consecutive patients who underwent FD placement from April 2015 to December 2024, completed 6- and 12-month followups, and underwent diluted 3DRA, pure 3DRA, and high-resolution conebeam CT at 6-months. Three blinded assessors graded the 6-month BBS (none, partial, full). The optimal technique was determined by interrater reliability. The BBS stage was compared across 6-month O'Kelly-Marotta (OKM) grades using the Cochran Armitage test. Among 6-month incompletely occluded aneurysms, 12-month complete occlusion rates were compared by BBS stage, and risk ratios were estimated using modified Poisson regression with cluster robust SEs at the patient level. The WCS on 6-month 2D DSA was recorded, and detection rates were examined across BBS stages and OKM grades.
RESULTS: We analyzed 142 aneurysms in 123 patients. Diluted 3DRA showed superior interrater reliability (mean of all pair-wise weighted Cohen κ values [Light's κ] = 0.82). The predominant BBS stage transitioned from none to partial to full as the 6-month OKM grades improved (none/partial/full: OKM A, 62/38/0%; B, 25/75/0%; C, 3/59/38%; D, 1/7/91%, respectively; P for trend < .01). Among the 61 incompletely occluded aneurysms at 6-months, the 12-month complete occlusion rates were 10% for none-BBS, 22% for partial BBS, and 71% for full BBS. Compared with none-BBS, the risk ratio for 12-month occlusion was 2.16 (95% CI, 0.30-15.5) for partial BBS and 7.14 (95% CI, 1.07-47.8) for full BBS. The WCS was most frequent in aneurysms with partial BBS and OKM grade B (75%).
CONCLUSIONS: Diluted 3DRA was identified as the optimal technique. The BBS aligned with the concurrent aneurysm occlusion status and predicted subsequent complete occlusion, supporting its potential as a neointimal biomarker after FD treatment. The WCS may reflect immature neointimal formation after flow diversion.
引用
- Egashira S, Hamada Y, Kawauchi S, et al. Black Belt Sign on Diluted Contrast 3D Rotational Angiography as a Potential Neointimal Marker Associated with Intracranial Aneurysm Occlusion after Flow Diversion. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2026. PMID: 41974512. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A9343
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。