透明报告是放射学人工智能研究可重复性的核心:行动呼吁
本文分析放射学人工智能(AI)研究中透明报告的主要障碍,指出报告常被当作稿件终稿要求而非研究设计的前瞻性组成部分、期刊与资助方对报告标准的执行不一致、AI专用报告指南碎片化且重叠、数据与代码可及性不足四大挑战,并提出前瞻性记录方法、强制统一应用报告标准、协调报告原则及明确数据代码可及性要求等可操作策略,认为加强透明报告是可重复且可临床转化的放射学AI研究的先决条件。
要点
- 透明报告应作为研究设计的前瞻性组成部分嵌入,而非稿件终稿阶段的附加要求。
- AI专用报告指南碎片化且重叠,增加作者与审稿人的解读负担并导致报告异质性。
- 数据与代码可及性有限妨碍独立验证,即使名义上已共享资源。
核心结论
- 加强透明报告是可重复且可临床转化的放射学AI研究的先决条件。
- 将报告嵌入研究设计、协调利益相关方期望并改善可重复性使能资源的获取,对提升可信度、促进独立评估及支持AI在放射学中的安全临床实施至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为针对放射学AI研究中透明报告障碍与解决方案的论述性文章(行动呼吁),非系统检索或定量研究,原文未报告样本量、中心数或参考标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 原文提出四项挑战:报告常被视为终稿稿件要求而非前瞻性设计组成部分;期刊与资助方对报告标准执行不一致;AI专用报告指南碎片化与重叠;数据与代码可及性与可用性有限。
- 针对每项挑战提出可操作策略:前瞻性记录方法、强制且一致应用报告标准、协调报告原则、明确数据与代码可及性要求并在共享受限时提供结构化替代方案。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者呼吁将报告要素前瞻性嵌入研究设计,而非在投稿阶段补写。
- 作者呼吁期刊与资助方强制且一致地应用报告标准,并协调AI专用报告指南以减少碎片化。
- 作者呼吁明确数据与代码可及性要求,并在共享受限时提供结构化替代方案。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly embedded in radiology research and practice, yet concerns about the reproducibility of AI studies remain a key barrier to regulatory acceptance and clinical translation. Transparent reporting across the analytic pipeline is essential for independent verification, evidence synthesis, and safe implementation.
PURPOSE: To examine major barriers to transparent reporting in radiological AI research and propose practical solutions to strengthen reproducibility.
RESULTS: We identify four interrelated challenges undermining reporting quality. First, reporting is often treated as a final-stage manuscript requirement rather than a prospectively embedded component of study design, leading to loss of methodological detail. Second, inconsistent operationalization of reporting standards by journals and funders makes it difficult to assess reporting completeness. Third, fragmentation and overlapping complexity of AI-specific reporting guidelines increase interpretive burden for authors and reviews and contribute to heterogeneity in reporting. Fourth, limited availability and usability of data and code restrict independent verification, even when resources are nominally shared. These issues are amplified by the methodological complexity and heterogeneity of radiological AI pipelines. For each challenge, we outline actionable strategies including prospective documentation of methods, mandatory and consistently applied reporting standards, harmonized reporting principles, and clearer requirements for data and code availability with structured alternatives when sharing is constrained.
CONCLUSIONS: Strengthening transparent reporting is a prerequisite for reproducible and clinically translatable radiological AI research. Embedding reporting within study design, aligning stakeholder expectations, and improving access to reproducibility-enabling resources are essential to enhance credibility, facilitate independent evaluation, and support safe clinical implementation of AI in radiology.
引用
- White SJ, Yaxley KL, To MS, et al. Transparent reporting is central to reproducible radiological AI research: A call to action. Eur J Radiol. 2026. PMID: 41806464. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2026.112777
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。