儿科放射学中确定性用语的使用:单中心分析
该研究回顾性分析了一家独立儿科医院系统2023年10月至2024年9月间309751份儿科影像报告,随机抽取10000份用自然语言处理识别出122个诊断确定性短语(DCP)。20.9%的报告在首次印象中至少含一个DCP,平均频率为每份报告0.27次。MRI、1至5岁患儿及急诊病例使用率显著更高,职业中期和早期放射科医生使用DCP多于资深医生。
要点
- 儿科影像报告首次印象中约20.9%含至少一个诊断确定性短语,平均每份报告0.27次。
- MRI检查、1至5岁患儿及急诊病例的DCP使用频率显著更高(均P < .001)。
- 最常用短语为「likely」「could represent」和「cannot rule out」。
核心结论
- DCP在儿科放射学中使用频繁,其使用因检查方式、患者年龄、临床场景和放射科医生资历而异;这种变异性可能加剧临床诊断过程中已有的不确定性,并可能提示标准化不确定性报告方法的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析一家独立儿科医院系统2023年10月至2024年9月的影像报告;从309751份符合纳入标准的报告中随机抽取10000份,使用自然语言处理流程(GPT-4o,OpenAI,旧金山,加利福尼亚州)识别DCP;排除并人工复核后识别出122个独特DCP,再统计这122个DCP在其余309751份报告首次印象中的出现次数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 在309751份可分析报告中,20.9%的首次印象含至少一个DCP,平均DCP频率为每份报告0.27次。
- MRI的DCP频率为0.54(P < .001),1至5岁患儿为0.34(P < .001),急诊病例为0.31(P < .001),均显著更高。
- 职业中期和早期放射科医生的DCP使用频率为0.30(P < .001),高于资深放射科医生的0.22(P < .001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Radiologists often employ diagnostic certainty phrases (DCPs) to convey levels of confidence in imaging interpretations. Prior research in adult radiology demonstrated wide variability in DCP usage, potentially complicating communication with clinicians and patients. Little is known about these practices in pediatric radiology. We aimed to characterize DCP use among pediatric radiologists in a large academic institution.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively analyzed radiology reports from a freestanding pediatric hospital system between October 2023 and September 2024. From 309,751 pediatric imaging reports meeting inclusion criteria, 10,000 were randomly sampled to identify DCPs using a natural language processing pipeline (GPT-4o, OpenAI, San Francisco, California). After exclusions and manual review, 122 unique DCPs were identified. We then counted the occurrence of these 122 DCPs across the remaining 309,751 radiology report first impressions. Usage rates were evaluated across patient demographics, imaging modalities, clinical settings, and radiologist seniority. Statistical significance was assessed using two-sided one-sample t tests with significance assigned to values P ≤ .001.
RESULTS: Of the 309,751 analyzable reports, 20.9% contained at least one DCP in the first impression. The mean DCP frequency was 0.27 per report. MRI (0.54, P < .001), patients aged 1 to 5 years (0.34, P < .001), and emergency cases (0.31, P < .001) showed significantly higher usage. Midcareer and early-career radiologists employed more DCPs (0.30, P < .001) than senior radiologists (0.22, P < .001). The most common phrases included "likely," "could represent," and "cannot rule out."
CONCLUSIONS: DCPs are frequently used in pediatric radiology, with variability influenced by modality, patient age, clinical context, and radiologist seniority. Such variability may compound existing uncertainty of the clinical diagnostic process and possibly indicate an opportunity for standardized uncertainty reporting approaches.
引用
- Li H, Moon JT, Yang Y, et al. Certainty Language Use in Pediatric Radiology: A Single-Institution Analysis. J Am Coll Radiol. 2026. PMID: 41833856. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2026.03.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。