孤立性骨病变RADS分类系统的比较分析:恶性风险分层性能与临床实用性
该回顾性分析纳入2005年3月至2021年9月间同时接受CT和MRI的207例孤立性骨病变患者,由三名放射科医生独立使用CT Bone-RADS、MRI Bone-RADS、OT-RADS和BTI-RADS进行分类。共识分析中OT-RADS的AUC为0.91,诊断性能最均衡但阅片者间信度中等(AC1=0.585);CT Bone-RADS、MRI Bone-RADS和BTI-RADS的阅片者间信度优秀(AC1分别为0.978、0.931、0.822)。
要点
- 共识分析中OT-RADS的AUC为0.91,敏感度93%、特异度71%,诊断性能最均衡。
- CT Bone-RADS和MRI Bone-RADS的AUC分别为0.52和0.60,恶性风险分层性能有限。
- CT Bone-RADS、MRI Bone-RADS和BTI-RADS的阅片者间信度优秀,AC1分别为0.978、0.931、0.822。
核心结论
- 在评估的骨肿瘤RADS系统中,OT-RADS表现出最均衡的诊断性能,阅片者间信度中等;CT Bone-RADS、MRI Bone-RADS和BTI-RADS表现出优秀的阅片者间信度。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析纳入2005年3月至2021年9月间同时接受CT和MRI的207例孤立性骨病变患者(平均年龄49±18岁,男111例、女96例),由三名放射科医生独立分类,参考标准为组织病理学确认或影像学监测。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 共识判读的恶性风险分层性能(AUC;敏感度/特异度/阳性预测值/阴性预测值/准确率,%)为:CT Bone-RADS(0.52;95/9/43/73/44)、MRI Bone-RADS(0.60;98/12/44/88/47)、OT-RADS(0.91;93/71/69/94/80)、BTI-RADS(0.89;98/39/53/96/63)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 了解各RADS系统的性能特征有助于临床医生恰当应用这些算法以优化孤立性骨病变的评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the malignancy risk stratification performance and inter-reader reliability of four Reporting and Data System (RADS) algorithms for solitary bone lesions: CT Bone-RADS, MRI Bone-RADS, Osseous Tumor (OT)-RADS, and Bone Tumor Imaging (BTI)-RADS.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This retrospective analysis included patients with solitary bone lesions who underwent both CT and MRI between March 2005 and September 2021. Three radiologists independently categorized each lesion using CT Bone-RADS (1-4), MRI Bone-RADS (1-4), OT-RADS (2-5), and BTI-RADS (1-4). Categories were dichotomized into high- versus low-risk for malignancy. Diagnostic performance metrics and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) were calculated for each reader as well as for a consensus interpretation generated using a majority-vote method. The reference standard was either histopathologic confirmation or imaging surveillance. Inter-reader reliability was assessed using Gwet's AC1 statistic.
RESULTS: A total of 207 patients (mean age, 49 ± 18 years; 111 men and 96 women) were included. Consensus malignancy risk stratification performance (AUC; sensitivity/specificity/positive predictive value/negative predictive value/accuracy, %) was as follows: CT Bone-RADS (0.52; 95/9/43/73/44), MRI Bone-RADS (0.60; 98/12/44/88/47), OT-RADS (0.91; 93/71/69/94/80), and BTI-RADS (0.89; 98/39/53/96/63). Inter-reader reliability (AC1) was excellent for CT Bone-RADS (0.978), MRI Bone-RADS (0.931), and BTI-RADS (0.822), and moderate for OT-RADS (0.585).
CONCLUSION: Among the evaluated bone tumor-RADS, OT-RADS demonstrated the most balanced diagnostic performance with moderate inter-reader reliability. CT Bone-RADS, MRI Bone-RADS, and BTI-RADS showed excellent inter-reader reliability.
KEY POINTS: Question Evaluation of solitary bone lesions is important but often challenging. This study compared four bone tumor-RADS algorithms to determine which provides the best malignancy risk stratification. Findings Among the four RADS algorithms, OT-RADS demonstrated the most balanced overall diagnostic performance in consensus analysis, while CT Bone-RADS, MRI Bone-RADS, and BTI-RADS showed excellent inter-reader reliability. Clinical relevance Knowledge of each RADS system's performance characteristics helps clinicians apply these algorithms appropriately to optimize the assessment of solitary bone lesions.
引用
- Azhideh A, Haseli S, Park C, et al. Comparative analysis of RADS classification systems for solitary bone lesions: malignancy risk stratification performance and clinical utility. Eur Radiol. 2026. PMID: 41792574. doi:10.1007/s00330-026-12408-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。