文献速递心血管胸部外周血管CT

评估10比10规则的可推广性与有效性:可变管电压下血管与实质CT的个体化对比剂方案——多中心试验

Evaluating the Generalizability and Effectiveness of the 10-to-10 rule: Individualized Contrast Media Protocols for Vascular and Parenchymal CT Scans at Variable Tube Voltages-A Multicenter Trial.
PubMed 文献 · Invest Radiol · 2026-09-01

这项在荷兰、德国和瑞士5个中心开展的非随机多中心试验纳入1037例患者,评估10比10规则在冠脉、肺动脉、主动脉及腹部/颈部静脉期CT中能否实现一致均匀的强化。校正年龄和性别后多数扫描方案强化无显著差异,但近端高螺距CCTA、远端序列CCTA和近端CTPA有显著差异;多数95%CI下限超过诊断阈值,高螺距CCTA仅90 kV达标。

要点

  • 10比10规则:管电压每降低10 kV,血管检查碘流率或实质检查总碘负荷相应降低10%。
  • 多数方案在校正年龄性别后强化无显著差异,SNR和CNR在所有方案中均无显著差异。
  • 高螺距CCTA仅90 kV的95%CI下限超过325 HU阈值,序列CCTA 120 kV及CTPA 110/120 kV低于阈值。

核心结论

  • 该多中心试验在较大患者人群中显示10比10规则具有可推广性和有效性,不同管电压下血管与实质CT的碘强化仅有有限显著偏差。

研究设计与样本

  • 非随机多中心试验,纳入1037例拟行冠脉CT(高螺距和序列CCTA)、CTPA、主动脉CTA及腹部门静脉期或颈部静脉期CT的患者,在荷兰、德国和瑞士5个中心开展,各中心按临床申请采用标准扫描和重建方案,对比剂方案基于10比10规则。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 血管研究设定诊断充分性参考阈值:CCTA 325 HU、CTPA 200 HU、主动脉CTA 250 HU,以平均强化95%CI下限判断是否达到阈值。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 阅片时可关注各扫描方案95%CI下限与阈值的对应关系:高螺距CCTA仅90 kV达标,序列CCTA 120 kV及CTPA 110和120 kV的95%CI下限低于阈值。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Previous research has highlighted the benefits of reducing contrast media (CM), demonstrating positive impacts on patient safety, environmental sustainability, and health care costs. The 10-to-10 rule, introduced by a single-center study, adjusts CM dose to total body weight and tube voltage. This approach resulted in a reduced overall CM volume, with homogeneous attenuation and consistent diagnostic image quality (IQ) across varying tube voltages.

OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the 10-to-10 rule in achieving consistent and homogeneous attenuation in vascular and parenchymal CT in a multicenter clinical practice setting across Europe.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 1,037 patients scheduled for CT of the coronary arteries (high-pitch and sequential CCTA), pulmonary arteries (CTPA), aorta (CTA aorta), and abdominal CT in portal venous phase or venous phase scans of the neck were included in this nonrandomized multicenter trial, conducted at 5 centers in the Netherlands, Germany, and Switzerland. Each center followed its standard scan and reconstruction protocol based on the clinical request. CM protocols were based on the 10-to-10 rule: A 10 kV reduction in tube voltage should be accompanied by a 10% decrease in iodine delivery rate for vascular studies or total iodine load in parenchymal studies, and vice versa. Objective image quality (IQ) was assessed by drawing region of interests, measuring attenuation [Hounsfield Unit (HU)], and calculating signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). In vascular studies, a reference line was included, representing the threshold for sufficient diagnostic IQ (CCTA-325 HU, CTPA-200 HU, and CTA Aorta-250 HU). 95% CI of the mean attenuation was calculated, and the lower bound of each 95% CI was used as the reference to assess whether attenuation met these thresholds. Generalized mixed models tested for significant differences in objective IQ across varying tube voltages, presented both unadjusted and multivariate adjusted by age and gender.

RESULTS: Results demonstrated no significant differences in attenuation for distal high-pitch CCTA, proximal sequential CCTA, distal CTPA, CTA aorta, abdominal portal venous phase scans, and the thyroid gland and sternocleidomastoid muscle in venous phase scans of the neck after adjusting for age and gender. Proximal high-pitch CCTA, distal sequential CCTA, and proximal CTPA yielded significant results ( P =0.030, P <0.001, and P =0.002, respectively). SNR and CNR showed no significant differences for all scan protocols. The majority of 95% CI lower bounds exceeded the predefined threshold for sufficient diagnostic IQ. Exceptions included high-pitch CCTA scans, where only the 90 kV level met the threshold, as well as in sequential CCTA at 120 kV, and CTPA at 110 and 120 kV, for which the lower bounds remained below the threshold.

CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the generalizability and effectiveness of the 10-to-10 rule in a multicenter trial setting and a large patient population, showing limited significant deviations in iodine attenuation across varying tube voltages for both vascular and parenchymal CT studies.

来源:Invest Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Stammen L, Planken RN, Kok M, et al. Evaluating the Generalizability and Effectiveness of the 10-to-10 rule: Individualized Contrast Media Protocols for Vascular and Parenchymal CT Scans at Variable Tube Voltages-A Multicenter Trial. Invest Radiol. 2026. PMID: 41508601. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000001265

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。