皇家放射学院影像检查解读与报告标准在法律诉讼中的意义:腹部放射学索赔的回顾性分析
该回顾性分析由五名腹盆部放射学法律专家证人审查其近期的法律案件,共112例患者、176次影像检查,其中CT 99次(56%)、MRI 36次(20%)。41例(37%)的索赔指控涉及未报告偶然发现的病变,该组最常见指控为未识别肿瘤(23/41,56%);该组中12例(29%)的解读被判定为不合格,而无偶然发现指控的71例中为23例(32%)。作者结论认为,皇家放射学院标准应认识到意外病变有时难以发现,尤其在没有转诊临床医生明确提示的情况下。
要点
- 腹部放射学法律索赔中37%(41/112)指控未报告偶然发现的病变。
- 偶然发现相关索赔组最常见指控为未识别肿瘤(56%,23/41)。
- 该组解读不合格率为29%(12/41),无此类指控组为32%(23/71)。
核心结论
- 腹部放射学法律索赔中有相当比例指控未报告偶然发现的病变;皇家放射学院标准应认识到意外病变有时难以发现,尤其在没有转诊临床医生明确提示的情况下。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性审查五名腹盆部放射学法律专家证人的近期法律案件,共112例患者、176次影像检查(CT 99次,56%;MRI 36次,20%),检查地点包括NHS 144次(82%)、外包14次(8%)、私人执业18次(10%)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 112例患者中41例(37%)的索赔指控涉及未报告偶然发现的病变。
- 该41例中未识别肿瘤为最常见指控,占23例(56%)。
- 该41例中12例(29%)的解读被判定为不合格,而无偶然发现指控的71例中23例(32%)被判定为不合格。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: United Kingdom medicolegal claims are rising. Many radiological allegations cite failure to report incidental findings, but these are often inconspicuous and asymptomatic and therefore difficult to detect. Nevertheless, claimants often support their allegations by citing the Royal College of Radiologists standards for the interpretation and reporting of imaging investigations. We examined our medicolegal practice to determine the proportion where allegations cited incidental pathology.
METHODS: Five medicolegal expert witnesses, working in abdominopelvic radiology, reviewed their medicolegal practice and determined the proportion of recent cases in which allegations of substandard reporting cited failure to diagnose incidental pathology.
RESULTS: We identified 112 individual cases, comprising 176 imaging examinations; 99 (56 %) were computed tomography and 36 (20 %) magnetic resonance imaging. One hundred forty-four (82 %) were reported in the National Health Service, 14 (8 %) outsourced, and 18 (10 %) private practice. Medicolegal allegations cited failure to report incidental pathology in 41 (37 %) of the 112 patients. The commonest allegation in this group was failure to identify tumour (23 of 41 patients, 56 %). Interpretation was judged as substandard in 12 (29 %) of these patients compared with 23 (32 %) of the 71 patients in whom allegations did not cite incidental findings.
CONCLUSION: A substantial proportion of medicolegal allegations in abdominal radiology cite failure to report incidental pathology. College standards should recognise that unanticipated pathology is sometimes difficult to detect, especially without a clear steer from the referring clinician.
引用
- Halligan S, Blunt D, Boone D, et al. Medicolegal implications of the Royal College of Radiologists standards for the interpretation and reporting of imaging investigations: a retrospective review of claims in abdominal radiology. Clin Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41338156. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2025.107162
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。