偶发或筛查发现的肺结节:低强度与高强度监测的放射科医生信念调查(Watch the Spot 试验)
该调查在非盲、整群随机实用性肺结节评估试验中比较放射科医生对低强度与高强度监测方案的信念,153/514名受邀放射科医生(29.8%)完成调查。两臂对方案的熟悉度和依从性均高,低强度臂更倾向认为所用指南为 preferred 且证据强、随访频率不过高。
要点
- 两臂放射科医生对分配监测方案的熟悉度>88%、依从性>94%,>70%认为依从获益大于危害。
- 低强度臂更常认为其 preferred 指南在研究中使用(78.9% vs 45.5%;aOR 13.9,95%CI 4.2-45.7)。
- 低强度臂更常认为支持证据强或很强(76.3% vs 54.6%;aOR 2.40,95%CI 1.13-5.07),更少认为随访建议过频(25.0% vs 41.6%;aOR 0.46,95%CI 0.22-0.96)。
核心结论
- 在该实用性临床试验中,执业放射科医生对分配的肺结节评估指南报告了高水平的熟悉度、依从性和认同;低强度臂对支持证据和监测频率的信念更有利,可能反映放射科医生对当前使用指南的偏好和适应。
研究设计与样本
- 非盲、整群随机、实用性肺结节评估试验中的自填式调查;153/514名受邀放射科医生完成调查(29.8%),低强度臂76名、高强度臂77名;方案参照 Fleischner Society(偶发结节)和 ACR Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System(筛查检出结节)建议制定;采用多变量逻辑回归比较两组回答。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 偶发结节:两臂>88%报告至少中等熟悉度,>94%报告至少非常频繁依从,>70%认同依从获益大于危害。
- 低强度臂 vs 高强度臂认为 preferred 指南在研究中使用:78.9% vs 45.5%(aOR 13.9,95%CI 4.2-45.7)。
- 低强度臂 vs 高强度臂认为支持证据强或很强:76.3% vs 54.6%(aOR 2.40,95%CI 1.13-5.07)。
- 低强度臂 vs 高强度臂认为随访建议过频:25.0% vs 41.6%(aOR 0.46,95%CI 0.22-0.96)。
- 筛查检出结节:两臂均报告高水平的方案熟悉度、依从性及认同依从获益大于危害。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 调查应答率为29.8%(153/514),原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To examine radiologists' beliefs about protocols for less versus more intensive surveillance imaging in patients with small pulmonary nodules.
METHODS: We developed a self-administered survey to measure familiarity, adherence, and satisfaction with assigned protocols for surveillance as implemented in an unblinded, cluster-randomized, pragmatic trial of pulmonary nodule evaluation. Protocols were modeled on recommendations from the Fleischner Society (for incidental nodules) and the ACR's Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System (for screening-detected nodules). We compared responses by study arm using multivariable logistic regression.
RESULTS: The survey was completed by 153 of 514 invited radiologists (29.8%), including 76 responders in the less intensive study arm and 77 in the more intensive arm. For incidentally detected nodules, large majorities of responders in both study arms reported at least moderate familiarity (>88%) and at least very frequent adherence (>94%) with assigned protocols for surveillance, and over 70% agreed that benefits of adherence outweigh the harms. Responders in the less intensive arm were more likely to agree that their preferred guideline was in use during the study (78.9% versus 45.5%; adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 13.9, 95% confidence interval [CI] 4.2-45.7), were more likely to believe that the supporting evidence for the assigned guideline was strong or very strong (76.3% versus 54.6%; aOR 2.40, 95% CI 1.13-5.07), and were less likely to believe that follow-up recommendations were too frequent (25.0% versus 41.6%; aOR 0.46, 95% CI 0.22-0.96). For screening-detected nodules, responders in both study arms reported high levels of protocol familiarity, adherence, and agreement that benefits of adherence outweigh the harms.
CONCLUSION: In this pragmatic clinical trial, practicing radiologists reported high levels of familiarity, adherence, and agreement with assigned guidelines for pulmonary nodule evaluation. Perceptions of the supporting evidence and beliefs about the frequency of surveillance were more favorable in the less intensive study arm, likely reflecting radiologists' preference for and comfort with guidelines currently in use.
引用
- Gould MK, Creekmur B, Qi L, et al. Less Versus More Intensive Surveillance of Pulmonary Nodules Detected Incidentally or by Screening: A Survey of Radiologist Beliefs About Guidelines Implemented in the Watch the Spot Trial. J Am Coll Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41338713. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2025.09.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。