3D打印触觉股骨模型CT扫描上二维与三维股骨前倾角测量的准确性与可靠性:哪种方法对髋关节位置变化最稳健
以3例骨骼成熟儿科患者CT数据制作3D打印股骨模型,在中立位及不同屈曲、旋转、外展/内收角度下扫描,比较二维(Murphy、Lee、Reikerås)与三维重建法测量股骨前倾角。三维法平均绝对误差2.3°±1.3°、读者间平均绝对差2.9°,均优于各二维法,且股骨位置对三维法误差无影响。
要点
- 三维重建法测量股骨前倾角平均绝对误差2.3°±1.3°,读者间平均绝对差2.9°。
- 二维Murphy法误差最大(22.9°±23.7°),Lee法12.1°±8.5°,Reikerås法12.2°±9.6°。
- 各二维法在内收、屈曲及两者组合时误差最大,三维法误差不受股骨位置影响。
核心结论
- 基于三维重建的股骨前倾角测量比传统二维技术更准确、对股骨位置变化更稳健、读者间一致性更好。
研究设计与样本
- 使用3例骨骼成熟儿科患者(2女1男,年龄17.8±0.1岁)的CT数据制作3D打印股骨模型,以既定钻孔技术确定股骨前倾角解剖参考标准;模型在中立位及屈曲、内/外旋、外展/内收(15°、30°、45°增量)下接受CT扫描,两名放射科医生盲法用二维技术(Murphy、Lee、Reikerås)和三维重建模型测量股骨前倾角。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 全部股骨所有位置下,测量值与参考标准的平均绝对误差:Murphy法22.9°±23.7°、Lee法12.1°±8.5°、Reikerås法12.2°±9.6°、三维法2.3°±1.3°;读者间平均绝对差:Murphy法9.7°、Lee法4.7°、Reikerås法4.4°、三维法2.9°。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者结论认为三维重建法测量股骨前倾角比传统二维技术更准确、更稳健且读者间一致性更好;准确测量股骨前倾角对理解和治疗骨骼成熟儿科人群的下肢畸形重要。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the accuracy and reliability of 2D and 3D methods for measuring femoral version against an anatomic reference standard using 3D-printed femoral phantoms.
METHODS: CT data from three skeletally mature pediatric patients (2 females, 1 male; age 17.8 ± 0.1 years) were used as digital templates for 3D-printed haptic femur models. The anatomic reference standard for femoral version was determined by an established drilling technique. Models underwent CT scanning in neutral position and variations of flexion, internal/external rotation, and abduction/adduction (in increments of 15°, 30°, 45°). Two radiologists measured femoral version on axial datasets using 2D techniques (Murphy, Lee, Reikerås) and a 3D-reconstructed model in a blinded fashion. Mean absolute error (MAE) between measurements and the reference standard and mean absolute differences (MAD) between readers were calculated.
RESULTS: Across all positions in all femurs, MAE was 22.9° ± 23.7° for the Murphy technique, 12.1° ± 8.5° for the Lee technique, 12.2° ± 9.6° for the Reikerås technique, and 2.3° ± 1.3° for the 3D method. For all 2D methods, MAE was greatest with adduction, flexion, and combinations of both. For the 3D method, femur position had no impact on MAE. MAD between readers was 9.7° for the Murphy technique, 4.7° for the Lee technique, 4.4° for the Reikerås technique, and 2.9° for the 3D method.
CONCLUSIONS: Femoral version measurements based on 3D reconstructions are more accurate than traditional 2D techniques, more robust to femur positioning, and more consistent between readers. Accurate measurement of femoral version is important for understanding and treating lower extremity deformities in the skeletally mature pediatric population.
引用
- Maroyan A, Faria PH, Iwasaka-Neder J, et al. Accuracy and reliability of 2D and 3D femoral version measurements on CT scans of 3D-printed haptic femur models: which method is most robust to changes in hip position? Skeletal Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41310127. doi:10.1007/s00256-025-05090-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。