直肠癌基线MRI亚专科放射科医生二次意见解读的附加价值与临床影响
回顾性分析461例直肠腺癌外院MRI分期报告与亚专科放射科医生二次意见的完整性和不一致性,二次意见提高了报告完整性,53.8%病例存在不一致(56.5%为重大不一致),重大不一致病例中二次意见减少信息不足并改变38.1-46.3%的手术计划,外科医生对二次意见报告信心更高(中位4分 vs 2-3分,p<0.001)。
要点
- 二次意见可提高直肠MRI报告完整性(肿瘤形态66.4% vs 98.7%,壁外血管侵犯29.1% vs 93.9%)。
- 53.8%病例存在不一致,其中56.5%为可能改变治疗的重大不一致。
- 重大不一致病例中二次意见使手术计划改变达38.1-46.3%,外科医生信心评分更高(中位4 vs 2-3,p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 亚专科放射科医生的二次意见可能影响患者诊疗并提高外科医生治疗计划的信心。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2014年6月至2020年3月提交的直肠癌外院MRI二次意见解读,由亚专科放射科医生完成;共461例患者(中位年龄57岁,IQR 49-67;274例男性);两名对报告来源设盲的结直肠外科医生评估重大不一致病例的理论临床影响,并以五点Likert量表(1=最低信心)评定报告信心。
关键影像表现/征象
- 二次意见在肿瘤特征、局部范围及淋巴结/转移性疾病临床分期分类上均较外院报告提高了报告完整性。
- 报告缺口最大的是肿瘤形态(外院66.4%,306/461 vs 二次98.7%,455/461)和壁外血管侵犯(外院29.1%,134/461 vs 二次93.9%,433/461)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 不一致定义为外院与二次意见报告存在差异,共53.8%(248/461)病例出现不一致。
- 重大不一致定义为可能改变治疗的差异,占不一致病例的56.5%(140/248)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在重大不一致病例中,二次意见使信息不足病例减少:外科医生1从18.6%(26/140)降至7.1%(10/140)。
- 在重大不一致病例中,二次意见导致手术计划改变的比例为38.1-46.3%(43/113至44/95)。
- 外科医生对二次意见报告的信心评分中位4分,高于外院报告的2-3分(p<0.001)。
- 作者指出这些发现强调专家解读的价值,并突出优化MRI方案及在直肠癌分期中更广泛采用结构化报告的必要性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the completeness and discordance of outside rectal MRI initial staging reports compared to second-opinion reviews, and to assess the potential clinical impact of major discordance on treatment decisions in patients with rectal adenocarcinoma.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective analysis of outside rectal MRI reviews submitted for second-opinion interpretation by subspecialized radiologists from June 2014-March 2020 was conducted. Outside and second review reports were compared side-by-side; cases with discordance (and those with major discordance, i.e., may alter treatment, particularly) were identified. Two colorectal surgeons, blinded to report origins, reviewed cases with major discordance to evaluate their theoretical impact on patient management and rated their confidence level of the reports on a five-point Likert scale (1=lowest confidence).
RESULTS: In 461 patients (median age, 57 years [IQR: 49-67]; 274 male), compared to outside reviews, second reviews demonstrated improved report completeness across tumor characteristics, local extent, and nodal/metastatic disease clinical staging categories. The largest reporting gaps were in tumor morphology (66.4%, 306/461 vs. 98.7%, 455/461) and extramural venous invasion (29.1%, 134/461 vs. 93.9%, 433/461). Overall, 53.8% (248/461) of cases showed discordance, with 56.5% (140/248) classified as major. In this subset, second reviews led to fewer cases with insufficient information, e.g., 18.6% (26/140) to 7.1% (10/140) for Surgeon 1, and changes in surgical planning in 38.1-46.3% (43/113 to 44/95) of patients. Surgeons rated reports from second reviews with higher confidence scores (median, 4 vs. 2-3, p < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: Second-opinion reviews may impact patient care and improve surgeons' confidence for treatment planning.
KEY POINTS: Question Do subspecialist radiologist second-opinion reviews improve rectal MRI report completeness and affect treatment decisions in rectal adenocarcinoma staging? Findings While outside reviews often under-reported key imaging findings, second reviews improved report completeness, which led to increased confidence by our surgeons in treatment planning. Clinical relevance These findings underscore the value of expert interpretation and highlight the need for optimized MRI protocols and broader adoption of structured reporting in rectal cancer staging.
引用
- Golia Pernicka JS, Kim TH, Nougaret S, et al. Added value and clinical impact of second-opinion subspecialist radiologist interpretations of baseline rectal MRI in patients with rectal cancer. Eur Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41236658. doi:10.1007/s00330-025-12132-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。