重新定义依从性:依从性定义对肺癌筛查项目基准的影响
该回顾性研究(2016-2023年)在纽约某医疗系统内评估肺癌筛查随访依从性,比较六种依从性定义对依从率的影响。在13,773例患者中,仅低剂量CT的二元依从率在15、24和无限个月分别为35.6%、47.8%和55.9%;放宽至任何胸部CT后升至45.8%、59.2%和68.4%。作者提出四分类依从性框架以描述整个筛查队列的状态。
要点
- 仅低剂量CT随访的二元依从率在15、24和无限个月分别为35.6%、47.8%和55.9%。
- 放宽至任何胸部CT后,相应依从率升至45.8%、59.2%和68.4%。
- 四分类框架下仅低剂量CT的依从状态为按时26.4%、延迟15.1%、从未随访32.7%、未逾期25.7%。
核心结论
- 不同的依从性定义会显著影响肺癌筛查随访率的评估,标准化定义有助于项目间比较,所提出的四分类框架可描述筛查项目整个队列的筛查状态。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究(2016-2023年),在纽约某医疗系统内评估肺癌筛查随访,纳入13,773例患者,采用广义线性模型评估随访时间框架和CT类型对依从性的影响,并开发四分类依从性框架。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 二元依从性定义为完成随访胸部CT,评估六种定义:三种随访时间框架(15、24和无限个月)与两种随访CT类型(仅低剂量CT vs 任何胸部CT)组合。
- 仅低剂量CT的二元依从率(n=10,237)在15、24和无限个月分别为35.6%、47.8%和55.9%。
- 任何胸部CT的二元依从率(n=10,436)在15、24和无限个月分别为45.8%、59.2%和68.4%。
- 24个月和无限时间框架的依从性显著高于15个月(P < .001),任何胸部CT的依从性显著高于仅低剂量CT(P < .001)。
- 四分类框架(n=13,773)下仅低剂量CT的依从状态为按时26.4%、延迟15.1%、从未随访32.7%、未逾期25.7%;包含任何胸部CT时分别为34.7%、17.1%、24.0%、24.2%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片和报告随访依从性时需明确所采用的依从性定义(随访时间框架和CT类型),不同定义得出的依从率差异显著。
- 作者提出标准化定义以促进肺癌筛查项目间的比较,并建议采用四分类框架描述整个筛查队列的状态。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Annual low-dose CT (LDCT) is recommended after a negative lung cancer screening (LCS) CT. Patient follow-up is inconsistent, varying in both timing and imaging type (LDCT or routine chest CT). This study evaluates how different definitions of adherence to follow-up affect LCS adherence rates.
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: This retrospective study (2016-2023) evaluated LCS follow-up within a New York health care system. Binary adherence was defined as follow-up chest CT acquisition and evaluated using six definitions of adherence. Variables included (1) three follow-up time frames (15, 24, and unlimited months) and (2) two follow-up CT types (LDCT only versus any chest CT). A generalized linear model assessed the impact of time frame and CT type on adherence. A novel four-category adherence schema was developed.
RESULTS: In 13,773 patients, LDCT-only binary adherence (n = 10,237) was 35.6%, 47.8%, and 55.9% at 15, 24, and unlimited months, respectively. Broadening the evaluation to any type of follow-up chest CT (n = 10,436), adherence rose to 45.8%, 59.2%, and 68.4%. Adherence was significantly higher with (1) the 24-month and unlimited time frames compared with 15 months (P < .001) and (2) considering any chest CT versus LDCT only (P < .001). With the four-category schema (n = 13,773), LDCT-only rates were: on time (26.4%), late (15.1%), never followed up (32.7%), and not overdue (25.7%). Including any chest CT, the respective values were 34.7%, 17.1%, 24.0%, and 24.2%.
INTERPRETATION: This study demonstrates the impact of varying adherence definitions on LCS follow-up rates. Standardized definitions would facilitate program comparison. The proposed four-category schema delineates the screening status of a LCS program's entire cohort.
引用
- Bade BC, Gandomi A, Hasan E, et al. Toward Redefining Adherence: The Impact of Adherence Definition on Lung Cancer Screening Program Benchmarks. J Am Coll Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41285338. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2025.11.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。