视觉评估与基于感兴趣区的扩散评估在成人型弥漫性胶质瘤中的诊断价值比较
本研究对303例2-4级成人型弥漫性胶质瘤的术前MRI(含DWI)由三名评估者进行视觉评估(Rembrandt特征17分类)与ROI评估(ADC绝对值/aADC及对侧正常白质标准化/nADC),并重复评估。ROI评估的观察者间与观察者内一致性优于视觉评估;视觉评估与ADC阈值显著相关,IDH预测总体准确率与ROI法相当,但视觉评估特异度高而敏感度低,ROI法敏感度提高但特异度降低。
要点
- ROI评估的一致性(ICC=0.56)优于视觉评估(Kendall's W/加权kappa=0.34)。
- 视觉评估与aADC 1,090、623×10-6 mm2/s及nADC 1.38、0.80阈值显著相关(P<.001)。
- 视觉评估IDH分类准确率69%,ROI法使用aADC 1,048×10-6 mm2/s和nADC 1.38分别为73%和70%。
核心结论
- 以视觉输入引导的ROI扩散评估重复性优于单独视觉评估;视觉评估与ADC阈值强相关且IDH预测总体准确率与ROI法相当,但视觉评估特异度高、敏感度低,ROI法敏感度提高但特异度降低。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入303例2-4级成人型弥漫性胶质瘤的术前MRI(含DWI),由三名评估者评估并在一个月后重复;从全队列中选取99例无坏死、无出血且有IDH状态的病例进行IDH预测的logistic回归分析。
关键影像表现/征象
- 视觉评估采用Rembrandt特征17分类,将扩散分为易化、可疑、受限三类。
- ROI评估在视觉感知的最低ADC区域放置圆形ROI(绝对/aADC),并在对侧表现正常白质放置ROI(标准化/nADC)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- aADC阈值1,090和623×10-6 mm2/s用于区分易化、可疑和受限扩散,与视觉评估显著相关(P<.001)。
- nADC阈值1.38和0.80用于区分易化、可疑和受限扩散,与视觉评估显著相关(P<.001)。
- 视觉评估IDH分类准确率69%,ROI法使用aADC 1,048×10-6 mm2/s和nADC 1.38的准确率分别为73%和70%。
- 视觉评估特异度99%、敏感度14%;ROI法(aADC/nADC)特异度81%/75%、敏感度57%/61%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 视觉评估与ADC阈值强相关,可用于快速分类扩散受限程度。
- ROI评估引导下重复性更高,但需注意其敏感度提高伴随特异度降低。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To evaluate the comparability and reproducibility of standardized visual versus region-of-interest (ROI)-based diffusion assessment and their prediction capacity for isocitrate dehydrogenase (IDH) mutation status in adult gliomas.
METHODS: Preoperative MRI scans, including diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI), of grade 2-4 adult-type diffuse gliomas (n = 303) were evaluated by three raters and repeated after one month. Visual assessment used the categorization of the Visually AcceSAble Rembrandt Images-feature 17 classes (facilitated, dubious, restricted). ROI-based assessment placed circular ROI on the visually perceived lowest apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) areas (absolute/aADC) and contralateral normal-appearing white matter (normalized/nADC). Agreement and correlation analysis between visual and ROI-based assessments were performed. Logistic regression was conducted for IDH prediction in the subgroup of 99 non-necrotic and non-hemorrhagic cases, selected from the full cohort with available IDH status.
RESULTS: ROI-based assessment demonstrated superior inter- and intra-rater agreement (intraclass correlation coefficient[Formula: see text]0.56 (95%-CI: 0.48-0.63)) than visual assessment (Kendall's W/Cohen's weighted kappa[Formula: see text]0.34 (95%-CI: 0.26-0.42)). Thresholds of 1,090 and 623 × 10-6 mm2/s for aADC, and 1.38 and 0.80 for nADC, distinguishing facilitated, dubious, and restricted diffusion, significantly correlated with visual assessments (P < .001). IDH classification accuracy of visual assessment was comparable to that of the ROI-based method using thresholds of aADC 1,048 × 10- 6 mm2/sn and nADC 1.38 (visual vs. aADC/nADC: 69% vs. 73%/70%). However, neither method achieved a balanced performance between specificity (99% vs. 81%/75%) and sensitivity (14% vs. 57%/61%).
CONCLUSION: ROI-based diffusion assessment guided by visual input showed superior reproducibility than visual assessment alone. Although visual assessment demonstrated strong correlation with ADC thresholds and comparable overall IDH prediction accuracy, the two methods differ in clinical profile: visual assessment offered high specificity but low sensitivity, whereas ROI-based assessment improved sensitivity at the cost of reduced specificity.
引用
- Azizova A, Prysiazhniuk Y, Cakmak M, et al. Visual versus region-of-interest based diffusion evaluation and their diagnostic impact in adult-type diffuse gliomas. Neuroradiology. 2025. PMID: 41204956. doi:10.1007/s00234-025-03832-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。