基于德尔菲法的中国胎儿11+0至13+6周超声解剖检查专家共识
该共识通过文献综述和德尔菲法(35名专家组成员三轮在线投票,并征求27家代表性医疗机构122名专家反馈)制定,将早孕期胎儿超声解剖检查分为基本(I级)、详细(II级)和针对性(III级)检查,包含1个测量项目(6个子项)和9个解剖检查项目(26个子项),为不同级别医疗机构提供标准化框架。
要点
- 基本检查中双顶径、头围、腹围及原腭、肾脏、生殖结节等为建议项目,详细检查中均为推荐项目。
- 基本检查适用于有筛查资质的县级医院,详细检查应在有同等筛查资质的市级医院进行。
- 针对性胎儿中枢神经系统检查含11个平面,其中4个推荐、7个建议。
核心结论
- 该共识为不同级别和能力的医疗机构提供了早孕期胎儿超声解剖检查的标准化框架,并为未来早孕期胎儿畸形筛查提供了循证支持。
研究设计与样本
- 采用德尔菲法的专家共识:8名核心委员会成员初步起草,35名专家组成员进行三轮在线投票,并征求中国27家不同级别和地区代表性医疗机构122名专家的反馈;若四分之三专家组成员同意将早孕期胎儿解剖超声检查分为三类则采纳该分类,若四分之三专家同意某一项目或平面为检查的强制组成部分则定为推荐项目或平面,否则为建议项目或平面。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 早孕期胎儿超声解剖检查分为基本(I级)、详细(II级)和针对性(III级)检查。
- 检查包括1个测量项目(含6个子项)和9个解剖检查项目(含26个子项)。
- 基本检查中双顶径、头围、腹围等生物测量参数及原腭、肾脏、生殖结节等子项为建议项目(非强制)。
- 详细检查中上述参数均为推荐项目(强制)。
- 针对性胎儿中枢神经系统检查共11个超声平面,其中4个为推荐平面、7个为建议平面。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 基本和详细胎儿解剖检查均适用于低风险妊娠,两者主要区别在于检查所在医疗机构的级别。
- 基本检查适用于有筛查资质的县级医院,详细检查应在有同等筛查资质的市级医院进行。
- 针对性检查主要适用于高风险或疑似畸形胎儿,应由有资质的产前诊断中心认证医师进行。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: First-trimester fetal malformation screening via ultrasound has become increasingly important. This study aims to establish a standardized expert consensus on the ultrasound anatomical examination of fetuses during the first trimester.
METHODS: A comprehensive literature review was conducted on first-trimester fetal anatomical examinations and malformation screening. A draft of the Chinese Expert Consensus on Fetal Anatomical Examination at 11 + 0 to 13 + 6 Weeks of Gestation was initially prepared by eight core committee members. Using the Delphi method, three rounds of online voting were conducted by 35 expert panel members, and feedback was solicited from 122 experts across 27 representative medical institutions of various levels and regions in China. If three-fourths of the expert panel members agreed to categorize the first-trimester fetal anatomical ultrasound examination into three types, these classification methods were adopted. Similarly, if three-fourths of the experts agreed that a specific item or plane in the consensus should be a mandatory component of the examination, it was designated as a recommended item or plane; otherwise, it was classified as a suggested item or plane.
RESULTS: This expert consensus categorizes the first-trimester fetal ultrasound anatomical examination into basic (Class I), detailed (Class II), and targeted (Class III) examinations. The examination includes one measurement item (with six sub-items) and nine anatomical examination items (with 26 sub-items). The basic and detailed fetal anatomical examinations involve largely consistent measurement parameters and target organs. However, the detailed examination includes a greater number of sub-items. In the basic examination, biometric parameters such as biparietal diameter (BPD), head circumference (HC), and abdominal circumference (AC) are considered suggested items (not mandatory). Similarly, sub-items such as the primary palate, kidneys, and genital tubercle are also classified as suggested items. In contrast, all of these parameters are regarded as recommended items (mandatory) in the detailed examination. Both the basic and detailed fetal anatomical examinations are indicated for low-risk pregnancies. The primary distinction between the two lies in the level of healthcare facility where they are conducted. Basic examinations are suitable for county-level hospitals with screening qualifications, whereas detailed examinations should be performed at municipal-level hospitals with equivalent screening credentials. In the targeted examination of the fetal central nervous system (FCNS), a total of 11 ultrasound planes are included. Among these, 4 are designated as recommended planes, and the remaining 7 as suggested planes. In the targeted fetal cardiac examination, 5 planes are evaluated, with 4 being recommended and the bilateral subclavian artery plane classified as a suggested plane. In the targeted early pregnancy screening for cleft lip and palate, 5 planes are assessed, including 3 recommended and 2 suggested planes. Targeted examinations are primarily indicated for high-risk or suspected anomalous fetuses and should be performed at qualified prenatal diagnostic centers by certified physicians.
CONCLUSION: This consensus provides a robust framework for the standardized ultrasound anatomical examination of fetuses in the first trimester across medical institutions of varying levels and capacities. It also offers evidence-based support for future first-trimester fetal malformation screening.
引用
- Lyu G, Liao R, Jiang Q, et al. Chinese Expert Consensus on ultrasound anatomical examination of fetuses at 11 + 0 to 13 + 6 weeks of gestation based on the Delphi method. Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2025. PMID: 41240083. doi:10.1007/s00404-025-08231-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。