真实场景中AI辅助放射科医生、急诊医生及两种AI方案诊断附肢骨骼创伤骨折的表现
在两家中心连续纳入969例患者共1049套X线影像,比较AI辅助放射科医生、急诊医生及两种AI方案(BoneView、SmartUrgence)诊断骨折的表现,以5名资深骨肌放射科医生回顾确定的真值为参考。AI辅助放射科医生的敏感度93%、特异度99%、准确率97.6%,优于急诊医生和两种AI方案,且不受年龄和部位影响。
要点
- AI辅助放射科医生诊断骨折敏感度93%、特异度99%、准确率97.6%,表现优异。
- 急诊医生敏感度80.8%、特异度97.6%、准确率93%。
- BoneView敏感度89.5%、特异度93.8%、准确率92.7%;SmartUrgence敏感度85.7%、特异度94.6%、准确率92.2%。
核心结论
- 在真实急诊环境中,AI辅助放射科医生诊断骨折的表现优异,且无论年龄和部位均优于单独使用AI方案。
研究设计与样本
- 在两个中心连续纳入2021年1月至4月因附肢骨骼创伤就诊、接受X线检查且急诊医生初步结论可得并前瞻性编码的患者,共969例患者1049套X线影像,其中287例有骨折(27.4%)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以5名资深骨肌放射科医生回顾性评估(知晓全部临床、影像和AI数据)作为真值;AI辅助放射科医生敏感度93%、特异度99%、准确率97.6%;急诊医生敏感度80.8%、特异度97.6%、准确率93%;BoneView敏感度89.5%、特异度93.8%、准确率92.7%;SmartUrgence敏感度85.7%、特异度94.6%、准确率92.2%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the performance of artificial intelligence (AI)-aided radiologists, emergency physicians and two AI solutions for diagnosing bone fractures.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Consecutive patients treated at two centres for appendicular skeletal traumatic injury between January and April 2021 who underwent X-ray imaging and whose initial conclusions were available and prospectively encoded by emergency physicians, were also prospectively analysed via two AI solutions (BoneView and SmartUrgence) available for the real-life interpretation of AI-aided radiologists. The ground truth was retrospectively assessed by 5 senior musculoskeletal radiologists who were aware of all the clinical, radiological and AI data. Numbers of suspected fractures, true positives and false positives per AI were compared. Diagnostic performance metrics (sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values and accuracy with 95% confidence intervals) for detecting fractures were estimated for each interpretation (emergency physician, BoneView, SmartUrgence, AI-aided radiologist).
RESULTS: 969 patients with 1049 radiography sets were included, 287 of whom had fractures (27.4 %). The average number of any fracture and true positive fractures were greater with BoneView than with SmartUrgence (P = 0.0469 and P = 0.0022, respectively). The real-life sensitivity, specificity and accuracy for detecting fracture in the entire cohort were 93 %, 99 % and 97.6 % for AI-aided radiologists; 80.8 %, 97.6 % and 93 % for emergency physicians; 89.5 %, 93.8 % and 92.7 % for BoneView; and 85.7 %, 94.6 % and 92.2 % for SmartUrgence.
CONCLUSION: In a real-life emergency setting, the performance of AI-aided radiologists in diagnosing bone fractures was excellent, and these radiologists outperformed AI solutions alone regardless of age and location.
引用
- Crombé A, Cheikh AB, Seux M, et al. Real-life performance of AI-aided radiologists, emergency physicians and two AI solutions for diagnosing bone fractures in appendicular skeletal trauma. Eur J Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41108952. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2025.112469
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。