实习生间在准确量化分肾小球滤过率方面的一致性比较
本研究前瞻性纳入154例患者,比较实习生使用99Tcm-DTPA肾动态显像Gate法与应用99Tcm-DTPA双血浆清除法结合简化Gate法的新方法测量分肾小球滤过率的一致性。新方法在左、右分肾GFR的Kendall's W系数均为0.967,高于Gate法的0.846和0.776,且在不同肾功能不全阶段一致性均更高。
要点
- 新方法(双血浆清除法结合简化Gate法)测量分肾GFR的实习生间一致性Kendall's W为0.967。
- Gate法测量左、右分肾GFR的Kendall's W分别为0.846和0.776,低于新方法。
- 在不同肾功能不全阶段,新方法的分肾GFR一致性均高于Gate法。
核心结论
- 新方法为估算分肾GFR提供了标准化流程,使经验较少的实习生也能获得更可靠的估计值。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入154例患者,均行99Tcm-DTPA肾动态显像(Gate法,g-GFR)和99Tcm-DTPA双血浆清除法(t-GFR),新方法基于双血浆清除法结合简化Gate法(g'-GFR)计算精确分肾GFR(p-GFR)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 精确分肾GFR计算公式:p-GFRleft = g'-GFRleft/(g'-GFRleft + g'-GFRright) × t-GFR。
- Gate法:四名实习生左分肾g-GFR的Kendall's W系数为0.846,右分肾g-GFR的Kendall's W系数为0.776。
- 新方法:四名实习生左、右分肾p-GFR的Kendall's W系数均为0.967。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 新方法可提供标准化的分肾GFR估算流程,使经验较少的实习生获得更可靠的估计值。
- 四名实习生中三名结果一致,一名实习生报告的sk-GFR值显著低于其他人。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: The aim of this study was to evaluate the consistency of an innovative method that combines 99Tcm-diethylene triamine pentaacetic acid (DTPA) renal dynamic imaging with 99Tcm-DTPA dual plasma clearance to precisely quantify the split kidney glomerular filtration rate (sk-GFR).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: 154 patients were prospectively included in this study and underwent renal dynamic imaging using 99Tcm-DTPA (Gate's method, g-GFR) and the dual plasma clearance method (true glomerular filtration rate [t-GFR]). Our team developed an innovative method to precisely determine sk-GFR based on the 99Tcm-DTPA dual plasma clearance method combined with the simplified Gate's method (g'-GFR). The precise sk-GFR was calculated based on the following formula: precise glomerular filtration rate (p-GFRleft) = g'-GFRleft/(g'-GFRleft + g'-GFRright) × t-GFR. The variability and consistency of sk-GFR, calculated by four interns, were assessed using paired t-test, Pearson's correlation, and Kendall's W test. Furthermore, the consistency among the four interns with two methods was assessed across different stages of renal dysfunction.
RESULTS: All four interns used both methods to measure sk-GFR. Although three interns achieved consistent results, one intern reported significantly lower sk-GFR values than the others. Four interns used Gate's method with a g-GFRleft Kendall's W coefficient of 0.846 and g-GFRright Kendall's W coefficient of 0.776. Additionally, they used an innovative method, which resulted in a Kendall's W coefficient of 0.967 for both p-GFRleft and p-GFRright. The consistency of sk-GFR using the innovative method was higher than that using the Gate's method at different stages of renal dysfunction.
CONCLUSION: The innovative method provided a standardised procedure for estimating sk-GFR, thereby offering more reliable estimates by less experienced interns.
引用
- Xie L, Qin J, Li F, et al. Comparison of the consistency between interns in accurate quantification of split kidney glomerular filtration rate. Clin Radiol. 2025. PMID: 41027293. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2025.107071
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。