比较多种纤维束成像流程在脑肿瘤患者皮质脊髓束重建中的应用
研究纳入23例脑肿瘤患者,按肿瘤位置和水肿程度分为四组,比较五种纤维束成像流程(SD-Stream、iFOD2、DSIstudio、TractSeg、UKF-2T)重建皮质脊髓束的质量。三位临床专家依据解剖判断评分,并辅以灰质覆盖率、体积、假阳性流线和重建率等定量指标。结论为不同肿瘤位置和水肿程度需选用不同流程:无水肿肿瘤TractSeg最佳,水肿肿瘤UKF-2T和DSIstudio更优。
要点
- 无水肿肿瘤患者中TractSeg获得最高专家评分,最适合用于皮质脊髓束重建。
- 近中央前皮质且伴水肿的肿瘤UKF-2T专家评分最高,深部伴水肿肿瘤DSIstudio评分最高。
- TractSeg产生的假阳性流线最少,UKF-2T重建的皮质脊髓束体积最大。
核心结论
- 不同肿瘤位置和水肿程度需要选择特定的纤维束成像流程;无水肿时TractSeg最佳,伴水肿时UKF-2T和DSIstudio更优。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入23例患者(男13例、女10例,平均年龄51.04±14.50岁),按肿瘤位置和水肿程度分为四组;采用扩散MRI数据(b=1,000 s/mm²,15个方向),比较SD-Stream、iFOD2、DSIstudio、TractSeg和UKF-2T五种纤维束成像流程,由三位临床专家依据解剖判断评分,并计算灰质覆盖率、体积、假阳性流线和重建率等定量指标。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 无水肿肿瘤组TractSeg获得最高专家评分;近中央前皮质伴水肿肿瘤组UKF-2T获得最高专家评分;深部伴水肿肿瘤组DSIstudio获得最高专家评分;DSIstudio和UKF-2T的灰质覆盖率半球间差异最小,健康侧略高;UKF-2T的皮质脊髓束体积最高;TractSeg的假阳性流线最低。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,无水肿肿瘤可选用TractSeg,近中央前皮质伴水肿肿瘤可选用UKF-2T,深部伴水肿肿瘤可选用DSIstudio进行皮质脊髓束重建。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Determining the best-performing corticospinal tract (CST) tractography pipelines based on the experts score for patients with four types of edema degree and tumor locations.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-three patients were stratified into four groups based on tumor location and edema degree: tumors near the precentral cortex without edema, tumors near the precentral cortex with edema, tumors located deep without edema, and tumors located deep with edema. The dataset included 13 males and 10 females, with an average age of 51.04 ± 14.50 years. Diffusion MRI data (b = 1,000 s/mm2, 15 directions) were used. Five tractography pipelines were compared: SD-Stream, iFOD2, DSIstudio, TractSeg, and UKF-2T. Three clinical experts evaluate the quality of tractograms based on anatomical expert judgment. Then, quantitative anatomical measures CST gray matter coverage, volume, false-positive streamlines, and reconstruction rate are calculated to provide additional support for expert judgment.
RESULTS: TractSeg performed best for tumors without edema, achieving the highest expert score. UKF-2T and DSIstudio obtained the highest expert score when tumors with edema near the precentral cortex, and tumors located in deep brain, respectively. Quantitative results showed minimal interhemispheric differences in gray matter coverage for DSIstudio and UKF-2T, with slightly higher values on the healthy side. UKF-2T exhibited the highest CST volume. TractSeg generated the lowest false-positive streamlines.
CONCLUSIONS: Different tumor locations and edema degrees require specific tractography pipelines. TractSeg is optimal for tumors without edema, while UKF-2T and DSIstudio are superior for tumors with edema.
引用
- He J, Cheng Y, Pan Y, et al. Comparison of multiple tractography pipelines for corticospinal tract reconstruction applied to brain tumor patients. Neuroradiology. 2025. PMID: 41160112. doi:10.1007/s00234-025-03793-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。