超声内镜引导下胃肠吻合术的最佳实践:国际改良德尔菲法的技术推荐
针对超声内镜引导下胃肠吻合术(EUS-GE)技术差异大的问题,25名国际专家经3轮改良德尔菲法对35条预设陈述匿名投票,31条获批、4条被拒;专家在透视必要性、电灼增强型腔壁贴合金属支架徒手释放及并发症处理能力等方面达成早期强共识,在染料使用、导管辅助技术等方面为中度共识,造影剂使用和具体技术选择因缺乏共识被删除。
要点
- 专家强共识:EUS-GE需使用透视、电灼增强型腔壁贴合金属支架徒手释放,并具备处理穿孔、出血、功能障碍及误放的能力。
- 最终强共识(>90%)包括镇静方案、患者体位及生理盐水作为扩张溶液。
- 染料使用、优先选择导管辅助EUS-GE而非内镜或针引导注入、典型位置及支架释放所需操作空间为中度共识(>80%)。
核心结论
- 尽管技术存在差异(如偏好空肠导管或双球囊导管),多数EUS-GE专家就关键技术原则达成共识,为临床实践中EUS-GE的标准化提供有价值的指导;部分议题共识有限,提示该领域未来研究重点。
研究设计与样本
- 国际改良德尔菲法:25名国际EUS-GE领先专家参与3轮匿名投票,对35条预设陈述使用5点李克特量表评分;根据预设中位数[IQR]阈值批准、修订或删除陈述,获批陈述的同意强度由评分4或5的比例确定。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 陈述根据预设中位数[IQR]阈值批准、修订或删除,同意强度由评分4或5的应答比例确定。
- 早期非常强共识(>95%):需要透视、电灼增强型腔壁贴合金属支架徒手释放、处理穿孔/出血/功能障碍的能力及(经更广泛讨论后)误放的能力。
- 最终强共识(>90%):镇静方案、首选患者体位、生理盐水作为扩张溶液。
- 最终中度共识(>80%):染料使用、优先选择导管辅助EUS-GE而非内镜或针引导注入、EUS-GE的典型位置、腔壁贴合金属支架释放所需操作空间。
- 因缺乏共识被删除的陈述:造影剂使用及特定技术之间的选择。
局限性
- 技术存在差异(如偏好空肠导管或双球囊导管)。
- 某些议题共识有限,被确定为未来研究重点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: EUS-guided gastroenterostomy (EUS-GE) increasingly has been adopted for gastric outlet obstruction, yet significant technical variability exists, which might account for heterogeneous clinical outcomes. The aim of this initiative was to gather expert consensus on key aspects and open questions of EUS-GE.
METHODS: A total of 25 international leading experts in EUS-GE participated in a modified Delphi process over 3 rounds, involving anonymous voting on 35 predefined statements, using a 5-point Likert scale. Statements were approved, revised, or discarded on the basis of predefined median [IQR] thresholds; for approved statements, the strength of the agreement was determined by the proportion of responses rated 4 or 5.
RESULTS: rate was 88% in round 1 and 100% in rounds 2 to 3. Thirty-one statements were approved, whereas 4 were ultimately rejected. Early and very strong agreement (>95%) was reached on the need for fluoroscopy, free-hand release of electrocautery-enhanced lumen-apposing metal stent, and need for competence in managing perforations, bleedings, dysfunctions, and (after more extensive discussion) misdeployments. Final strong agreement (>90%) was reached on sedation regimen, preferred patient positioning, and saline as distending solution. Extensive discussion with final moderate agreement (>80%) was reached on the use of dye, the preference for catheter-assisted EUS-GE instead of endoscope- or needle-directed instillation, the typical location for EUS-GE, and the operative space required for lumen-apposing metal stent release. Statements on the use of contrast and the choice between specific techniques were removed because of a lack of agreement.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite technical differences (such as the preference of a jejunal catheter or a double-balloon catheter), most experts in EUS-GE agree on key technical principles, providing valuable guidance on the standardization of EUS-GE in clinical practice. Conversely, certain topics show limited agreement, identifying future research priorities in the field of EUS-GE.
引用
- Vanella G, Leone R, Frigo F, et al. Best practices for endoscopic ultrasound-guided gastroenterostomy: technical recommendations from an international modified Delphi process. Gastrointest Endosc. 2025. PMID: 41115478. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2025.10.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。