释放培训潜力:提升对比增强乳腺摄影背景实质强化评估的阅片者间一致性
研究纳入2018至2022年548例接受对比增强乳腺摄影的女性,A组6名放射科医生独立评估2135幅图像的背景实质强化(BPE),专项培训后两周内以新随机顺序复读;另邀4家机构4名放射科医生(B组)以同样方式评估800幅图像。培训后A组BPE正确率从62.3%(范围48.6%-73.6%)升至75.5%(范围69.0%-79.7%),B组从55.7%(范围52.0%-58.9%)升至66.9%(范围62.0%-71.0%);两组阅片者间一致性均由一般升至中等(A组κ=0.32-0.52,B组κ=0.40-0.53)。
要点
- 培训后A组BPE评估正确率由62.3%(范围48.6%-73.6%)升至75.5%(范围69.0%-79.7%)。
- 培训后B组BPE评估正确率由55.7%(范围52.0%-58.9%)升至66.9%(范围62.0%-71.0%)。
- 两组阅片者间一致性均由一般升至中等(A组κ=0.32-0.52,B组κ=0.40-0.53)。
核心结论
- 放射科医生初始评估BPE的阅片者间一致性为一般,培训后有所提升,凸显培训的必要性及应提供标准参考图像集用于培训。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入2018至2022年接受对比增强乳腺摄影的548例女性,共2135幅图像由6名放射科医生(A组)独立以四级序数评分(极少量、少量、中等、大量)评估BPE,专项培训后两周内以新随机顺序复读;另邀4家机构的4名放射科医生(B组)以同样方式评估800幅图像。
诊断标准与关键数值
- BPE采用四级序数评分:极少量、少量、中等或大量。
- A组BPE正确率从62.3%(范围48.6%-73.6%)升至培训后75.5%(范围69.0%-79.7%)。
- B组BPE正确率从55.7%(范围52.0%-58.9%)升至培训后66.9%(范围62.0%-71.0%)。
- A组阅片者间一致性κ=0.32-0.52,培训后由一般升至中等。
- B组阅片者间一致性κ=0.40-0.53,培训后由一般升至中等。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为培训提升了CEM上BPE评估的阅片者间一致性,凸显临床实践与研究中需要标准化培训项目以提高一致性。
- 作者认为应提供标准参考图像集用于培训。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to evaluate the inter-reader agreement of visual background parenchymal enhancement (BPE) assessment on contrast-enhanced mammography (CEM) and determine whether training can improve this assessment.
METHODS: Five hundred and forty-eight women who underwent contrast-enhanced mammography from 2018 through 2022 were included. A total of 2135 images were read by six radiologists (Group A) independently and rated BPE with the ordinal scale: minimal, mild, moderate, or marked. After a dedicated training, the same cases were reread in a new random order within two weeks. To further verify the effectiveness of training, four radiologists (Group B) from four different institutions were invited to assess BPE in the same way with 800 images. The accuracy of each reader and agreement on BPE categorization between radiologists and the reference standard were evaluated.
RESULTS: The percentage of correct BPE assignments increased from 62.3% (range, 48.6%-73.6%) to 75.5% (range, 69.0%-79.7%) after training in Group A and increased from 55.7% (range, 52.0%-58.9%) to 66.9% (range, 62.0%-71.0%) after training in Group B. With training, inter-reader agreement increased from fair to moderate in both Group A (κ = 0.32-0.52) and Group B (κ = 0.40-0.53), indicating that readers learned and the training can be rolled out to different institutions.
CONCLUSION: The initial inter-reader agreement in assessing BPE among radiologists was fair but showed enhancement following training, highlighting the necessity of training and standard sets of reference images that should be made available for training.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: This study demonstrates that dedicated training improves inter-reader agreement in BPE assessment on CEM, highlighting the need for standardized training programs to enhance consistency in clinical practice and research.
引用
- Huang D, Wang S, Luo Z, et al. Unlocking the potential of training: enhancing inter-reader agreement in background parenchymal enhancement assessment on contrast-enhanced mammography. Br J Radiol. 2026. PMID: 41025457. doi:10.1093/bjr/tqaf240
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。