疑似儿童身体虐待影像学检查国际指南(IGISPA):改良德尔菲共识研究方案
该方案旨在通过改良e-Delphi共识流程制定疑似儿童身体虐待影像学检查的国际指南。共识组包括来自14个亚专科、六大洲、32个国家/国际组织的127名专家,分五个纵向亚组制定初步共识声明,经匿名投票和迭代修订至共识(≥80%一致)后定稿。
要点
- 现行疑似儿童身体虐待影像检查指南在关键问题上常不明确、不完整且差异大,增加临床异质性和漏诊风险。
- 共识组含127名专家,覆盖14个亚专科、六大洲、32个国家/国际组织,分五个纵向亚组。
- 共识通过改良e-Delphi匿名投票达成,共识阈值定为≥80%一致。
核心结论
- 旨在制定并报告基于证据和共识的国际指南,用于疑似身体虐待背景下索引儿童和接触儿童的影像学检查,并确定科学不确定性领域以指导未来研究重点。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲共识研究方案;共识组包括来自14个亚专科、六大洲、32个国家和/或国际组织的127名正式代表专家;参与者分为五个纵向亚组(影像检查指征、骨骼成像、内脏成像、神经成像和死后成像)及三个交叉主题(X线摄影、遗传学和低收入及中低收入国家的适应性调整);各亚组通过整合现行循证指南、系统文献综述和多国专家临床经验制定初步共识声明,经匿名e-Delphi投票和迭代修订至共识(≥80%一致),最终声明经内部和外部同行评审后获得认可。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: Radiological imaging is a central facet of the multidisciplinary evaluation of suspected child physical abuse. Current guidelines for the imaging of suspected child physical abuse are often unclear, incomplete and highly variable regarding recommendations on critical questions, thereby risking clinical heterogeneity, unstructured decision-making and missed diagnoses. We, therefore, aim to develop and report an evidence-based and consensus-derived international guideline for the radiological investigation of index and contact children in the context of suspected physical abuse and to ascertain areas of scientific uncertainty to inform future research priorities.
METHODS AND ANALYSIS: The international guidelines for the imaging investigation of suspected child physical abuse (IGISPA) consensus group includes formal representation from 127 recognised experts across 14 subspecialties, six continents and 32 national and/or international organisations. Participants will be divided into five longitudinal subgroups (indications for imaging, skeletal imaging, visceral imaging, neuroimaging and postmortem imaging) with three cross-cutting themes (radiography, genetics and adaptations for low- and lower-middle-income countries). Each subgroup will develop preliminary consensus statements via integration of current evidence-based guidelines, systematic literature review and the clinical expertise of a multinational group of experts. Statements will then undergo anonymised voting in a modified e-Delphi process and iterative revision until consensus (≥80% agreement) is achieved. Final statements will undergo both internal and external peer review prior to endorsement.
ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: As an anonymous survey of consenting healthcare professionals, this study did not require ethical approval. Experts provided written informed consent to participate prior to commencement of the modified Delphi process. The IGISPA consensus statement and any subsequent guidance will be published open access in peer-reviewed medical journals.
引用
- Sidpra J, Kemp AM, Nour AS, et al. International guidelines for the imaging investigation of suspected child physical abuse (IGISPA): a protocol for a modified Delphi consensus study. BMJ Open. 2025. PMID: 40998433. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2025-101693
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。