通用与个体正当性论证的实施:国际原子能机构技术合作计划欧洲和中亚地区调查结果
该研究通过四份电子问卷于2024年调查国际原子能机构技术合作计划下欧洲和中亚地区33个成员国的转诊指南可用性及正当性论证实践,共收到24个国家85份回复。结果显示仅55-70%国家有转诊指南,临床信息常不充分,放射科医生修改或拒绝CT转诊的能力有限,监管机构与专业机构沟通合作不足。
要点
- 仅55-70%国家报告有转诊指南,指南通常包含辐射剂量及儿童和孕妇指导。
- 转诊医生提供的临床信息常缺乏临床问题和既往检查信息。
- 仅13/18国家(72%)报告放射科医生可无阻碍修改或拒绝CT转诊。
核心结论
- 欧洲和中亚IAEA技术合作计划国家存在转诊指南可用性低、临床信息不足、放射科医生修改或拒绝不当申请的能力有限、监管机构与专业机构合作沟通欠佳等正当性论证问题。
研究设计与样本
- 通过四份电子问卷(Google Forms)于2024年调查,一份发监管机构、三份发放射学、核医学和口腔医学专业机构,链接邮寄至33个IAEA技术合作成员国代表,共收到24个国家85份回复。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 欧盟国家显示出良好的正当性论证实践,可能与更严格的监管和更好的临床信息提供有关。
- 改进策略应针对上述问题,可能包括更严格的监管和增进监管者与专业人员相互了解,或通过继续教育、宣传活动和协作工作实现。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study is to evaluate the framework and practice of generic and individual justification in countries from the Europe and Central Asia Region supported by the technical cooperation programme (TC) of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
METHODS: The information was obtained by four electronic questionnaires using Google Forms during the 2024. One was distributed to regulatory bodies and three to professional bodies of radiology, nuclear medicine, and dental medicine. The links were sent by mail to representatives from 33 IAEA TC Members States in the region, and a total 85 responses were received from representatives in 24 countries.
RESULTS: Respondents report availability of referral guidelines in only 55-70 % of countries but, where available, guidelines usually include radiation doses and guidance for children and pregnant patients. Clinical information provided by referring practitioners is lacking both for the clinical question and for information from previous procedures, with questions raised as to the completeness of clinical examination before requesting imaging. Radiologists' unencumbered ability to modify or reject a referral for computed tomography was reported by only 13/18 countries (72 %). Underlying issues include difficulties with communication and cooperation between regulatory bodies and professional bodies, limited understanding of regulatory requirements among medical professionals, and limited understanding of clinical practice by regulatory bodies. Good practices in justification were shown in EU countries possibly related to stronger regulation and provision of better clinical information.
CONCLUSIONS: Justification problems in the Europe and Central Asia IAEA TC countries, similar to other regions include: low availability and use of referral guidelines; inadequate clinical information for justification; limited time and ability for radiological medical practitioners to amend or reject inappropriate requests; and suboptimal cooperation and communication between regulatory authorities and professionals. Strategies for improvement should address these and may include stronger regulation and better mutual awareness between regulators and professionals, possibly through continuing education, campaigns and collaborative working.
引用
- Faj D, Žontar D, Remedios D, et al. Implementation of generic and individual justification: Findings from a survey under the IAEA technical cooperation programme in Europe and Central Asia. Eur J Radiol. 2025. PMID: 40865255. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2025.112381
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。