诊断放射学引入能力导向医学教育后的住院医师病例量:10年回顾
加拿大诊断放射学住院医师项目于2017年实施能力导向医学教育(Q-CBME),2022年采用全国性Competence by Design(CBD)模式;本研究比较传统时间制、Q-CBME与CBD三种课程下住院医师在腹部、胸部及神经影像轮转中的病例量,发现CBME实施后病例量未减少,在存在显著差异的比较中Q-CBME与CBD平均病例量更高。
要点
- CBME实施后住院医师病例量未减少,部分轮转中Q-CBME与CBD平均病例量高于传统课程。
- 腹部CT、神经放射CT、腹部CT及胸片在部分组间比较中有显著差异,所有CBME与传统的显著差异均表现为CBME组更高。
- 全住院期分析仅MRI(p=0.0195)与核医学(p=0.0003)存在显著差异。
核心结论
- CBME实施后住院医师病例量未减少,支持能力导向培训可维持甚至增加临床暴露的观点;鉴于既往研究将病例量与能力相联系,结果支持在放射学培训中继续采用CBME。
研究设计与样本
- 10年回顾性分析,使用Nuance mPower Clinical Analytics提取传统课程(n=9)、Q-CBME(n=16)与CBD(n=5)住院医师在首个腹部、胸部及神经影像轮转中的病例量,按工作天数归一化并按队列平均;二次分析比较传统(n=8)与Q-CBME(n=12)住院医师全住院期总病例量;采用ANOVA与独立t检验。
诊断标准与关键数值
- ANOVA显示腹部CT病例量组间差异显著(p=0.0002)。
- t检验显示神经放射CT传统 vs CBD差异显著(p=0.0008)。
- t检验显示腹部CT传统 vs Q-CBME(p=0.0015)及传统 vs CBD(p=0.0005)差异显著。
- t检验显示胸片Q-CBME vs CBD差异显著(p=0.0262)。
- 全住院期分析仅MRI(p=0.0195)与核医学(p=0.0003)差异显著。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在CBME与传统课程的所有显著差异中,Q-CBME与CBD的平均病例量更高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: A Canadian Diagnostic Radiology residency program implemented a competency-based medical education (CBME) curriculum in 2017 (Q-CBME), followed by the national Competence by Design (CBD) model in 2022. These frameworks emphasize progression through frequent assessment of competencies rather than time in training. However, concerns remain that the time burden or "tick-box" mentality in the context of increased assessments may decrease clinical exposure. This study evaluated whether CBME implementation affected resident clinical case volumes compared to a traditional time-based curriculum.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Using Nuance mPower Clinical Analytics, case volumes were extracted for residents in traditional (n=9), Q-CBME (n=16), and CBD (n=5) curricula during their first abdominal, chest, and neuroimaging rotations. Volumes were normalized by days worked and averaged by cohort. A secondary analysis compared total volumes between traditional (n=8) and Q-CBME (n=12) residents over the entirety of residency. Comparisons were made using ANOVA and independent t-tests.
RESULTS: ANOVA revealed significant difference in abdominal CT volumes (p=0.0002). T-tests showed significant difference for neuroradiology CT (traditional vs CBD, p=0.0008), abdominal CT (traditional vs Q-CBME, p=0.0015; traditional vs CBD, p=0.0005), and chest X-ray (Q-CBME vs CBD, p=0.0262). Whole-residency analysis found significant differences only in MRI (p=0.0195) and nuclear medicine (p=0.0003). In all significant differences between a CBME and traditional cohort, Q-CBME and CBD had higher mean volumes.
CONCLUSION: CBME offers opportunities for enhanced feedback and mentorship. This study found no reduction in resident case volumes under CBME, supporting the view that competency-based training can maintain, or even increase, clinical exposure. Given prior findings linking case volume to competency, these results support continued CBME adoption in radiology training.
引用
- Isen J, Phillips B, Chung AD, et al. Resident Case Volumes Following the Introduction of Competency-Based Medical Education in Diagnostic Radiology: A 10 Year Review. Acad Radiol. 2025. PMID: 40841255. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2025.08.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。