对比增强脑MRI用于头痛门诊评估:全面还是过度?
回顾性分析874例成人头痛门诊脑对比增强MRI,18%有潜在相关发现,仅2%病例对比剂相关;100例盲法双读显示,加用对比剂后阳性病例比例基本不变,降低1.5%,小 incidental 脑膜瘤检出率翻倍。作者认为常规增强对头痛门诊产出低,非增强检查对可操作颅内病变敏感性相似。
要点
- 头痛门诊常规脑增强MRI中仅2%病例被判定为对比剂相关。
- 盲法双读显示加用对比剂后阳性病例比例基本不变,降低1.5%。
- 小 incidental 脑膜瘤检出率在增强序列上翻倍。
核心结论
- 成人头痛门诊常规脑增强MRI产出低;非增强检查对可操作颅内病变敏感性相似,而增强使 incidental 脑膜瘤检出率翻倍。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,连续纳入874例成人头痛门诊脑对比增强MRI,由2名神经放射科医生对100例对比剂相关病例行盲法双读(先非增强,3周洗脱后加增强)。
关键影像表现/征象
- 18%的检查有潜在与头痛相关的发现。
- 2%的病例被判定为对比剂相关。
- 4%的病例报告了与头痛无关的 incidental 发现。
- 所有伴实质水肿的轴内和轴外肿块均在非增强图像上检出。
- 小 incidental 脑膜瘤的检出率在增强序列上翻倍。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 18%的检查有潜在与头痛相关的发现。
- 2%的病例被判定为对比剂相关。
- 4%的病例报告了 incidental 发现。
- 盲法双读中,加用增强图像后阳性病例比例基本不变,降低1.5%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,更实用的初始方法可能是先进行非增强检查,对少部分患者进行召回或追加影像。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Headache is one of the most common indications for brain MR imaging. Our purpose was to assess the necessity and yield of contrast-enhanced brain MRI protocols relative to noncontrast protocols for the outpatient evaluation of headache in adults.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed 874 consecutive adult outpatient brain contrast-enhanced MRIs for the indication of headache. Examination impressions were reviewed for any findings contributing to headache and stratified into 18 categories. Incidental findings unrelated to headache but mentioned in the report impressions were recorded. A subset of 100 contrast-relevant cases were selected for independent blinded review by 2 neuroradiologists first without contrast and then after a 3-week washout period, with and without contrast. Reviewers were asked to classify cases as positive/negative and to describe relevant findings. Specific diagnoses were compared between reviews and readers on a case-by-case basis. Intrareader agreement was calculated between noncontrast and postcontrast reviews.
RESULTS: Eighteen percent of examinations had findings potentially related to headaches. Two percent of cases were deemed contrast relevant. Incidental findings were reported in 4% of cases. On the blinded double review, the percentage of positive cases remained essentially unchanged, decreasing by 1.5% with contrast-enhanced images available. All intra- and extra-axial masses associated with parenchymal edema were detected without contrast. Detection rate of small, incidental meningiomas doubled on postcontrast sequences.
CONCLUSIONS: Routine acquisition of contrast-enhanced MRIs for outpatients with an indication of headache had a low yield. Noncontrast examinations demonstrated similar sensitivity for actionable intracranial pathology, while contrast-enhanced MRIs doubled the detection rate of incidental meningiomas. A more practical initial approach may be starting with noncontrast examinations with callbacks or additional imaging for a small percentage of patients.
引用
- Barkovich EJ, Buch K, Mehan WA, et al. Contrast-Enhanced Brain MRI for Ambulatory Evaluation of Headache: Comprehensive or Excessive? AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2025. PMID: 40876949. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8780
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。