文献速递骨肌儿科影像DR

模板匹配锁骨骨折图谱用于婴幼儿肱骨及股骨骨折替代性定年:一项六读者研究

Use of a Template-Matching Clavicle Fracture Atlas for Surrogate Dating of Humeral and Femoral Fractures in Young Infants: A Six-Reader Study.
PubMed 文献 · AJR Am J Roentgenol · 2025-07-02

本回顾性研究纳入145例90天龄以下婴儿的269张骨折X线片,评估模板匹配锁骨骨折时间轴图谱对放射科医生判断锁骨、肱骨及股骨出生相关骨折骨折龄的影响。使用图谱后读者间一致性从中等(ICC=0.69)提升至优秀(ICC=0.91),六名读者对锁骨及肱骨骨折、五名读者对股骨骨折的骨折龄平均绝对误差显著降低(p<.05)。结论认为图谱显著改善了放射科医生对婴儿锁骨、肱骨及股骨骨折的定年表现,锁骨骨折愈合模式可作为长骨骨折定年的替代参考。

要点

  • 使用锁骨骨折定年图谱后,读者间骨折龄估计一致性由中等(ICC=0.69)升至优秀(ICC=0.91)。
  • 六名读者对锁骨及肱骨骨折、五名读者对股骨骨折的定年MAE在使用图谱后显著降低(p<.05)。
  • 锁骨骨折愈合模式可作为婴儿长骨骨折定年的替代参考,有助于疑似虐待儿评估。

核心结论

  • 骨折定年图谱使放射科医生对婴儿锁骨、肱骨及股骨骨折的定年表现获得显著改善。
  • 锁骨骨折愈合模式可作为婴儿虐待中常见长骨骨折定年的替代参考。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入90天龄及以下婴儿,锁骨骨折影像取自2021年4月1日至2024年7月31日,肱骨或股骨骨折影像取自2011年12月1日至2024年7月31日。
  • 共纳入145例婴儿(87例男婴、58例女婴)的269张骨折X线片(锁骨104张、肱骨128张、股骨37张),每张骨折X线片作为独立观察纳入分析。
  • 以X线采集时患者日龄作为骨折龄参考标准。
  • 采用非刚性图像配准技术处理预先组装的非重叠锁骨骨折X线片数据库,构建骨折定年图谱。
  • 六名读者(三名培训期医师与三名儿科放射科医师)分别在无图谱与有图谱条件下独立阅片估计骨折龄。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 读者间一致性以组内相关系数(ICC)评估:无图谱时ICC=0.69(中等),有图谱时ICC=0.91(优秀)。
  • 锁骨骨折:六名读者使用图谱后骨折定年MAE均显著降低(p<.05),范围4.8-5.5天 vs 5.8-10.1天。
  • 肱骨骨折:六名读者使用图谱后MAE均显著降低(p<.05),范围6.0-12.1天 vs 3.0-3.8天。
  • 股骨骨折:六名读者中五名使用图谱后MAE显著降低(p<.05),范围7.4-17.2天 vs 3.3-4.8天。
  • 按读者资历:培训期医师MAE无图谱8.8天 vs 有图谱4.3天;主治医师MAE无图谱8.4天 vs 有图谱4.0天。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 在疑似婴儿虐待的骨折定年评估中,可参考锁骨骨折愈合模式图谱辅助判断锁骨、肱骨及股骨骨折的骨折龄。
  • 使用图谱后读者间一致性由中等提升至优秀,提示图谱有助于标准化骨折龄判读。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND. Fracture dating is important in suspected infant abuse. Birth-related clavicle fractures are common and may provide surrogates to aid long bone fracture dating in infants. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of a template-matching clavicle fracture timeline atlas on radiologists' performance in dating birth-related fractures of the clavicle, humerus, and femur in young infants. METHODS. This retrospective study included infants 90 days old or younger who underwent radiography of a birth-related clavicle fracture from April 1, 2021, to July 31, 2024 or a birth-related fracture of the humerus or femur from December 1, 2011, to July 31, 2024. All eligible radiographs of each fracture were identified, representing distinct observations for the purposes of analysis. Patient age (expressed as days) at the time of radiograph acquisition served as the reference standard for fracture ages. A nonrigid image registration technique was applied to a nonoverlapping preassembled database of radiographs of birth-related clavicle fracture, to create a fracture dating atlas. Six readers (three trainees and three pediatric radiologists) independently reviewed the radiographs in separate sessions without and with use of the atlas to estimate fracture ages. Interreader agreement was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Fracture aging performance was assessed using mean absolute errors (MAEs). RESULTS. The analysis included 145 infants (87 male and 58 female infants) with 269 fracture radiographs (104 of the clavicle, 128 of the humerus, and 37 of the femur). The mean fracture age was 26 ± 19 [SD], 22 ± 14, and 21 ± 13 days for clavicle, humerus, and femur fractures, respectively. Interreader agreement for estimating fracture ages improved from moderate (ICC = 0.69) without use of the atlas to excellent (ICC = 0.91) with use of the atlas. The MAE in fracture dating was significantly lower (p < .05) with than without use of the atlas for all six readers for clavicle fractures (range, 4.8-5.5 vs 5.8-10.1 days), for all six readers for humeral fractures (range, 6.0-12.1 vs 3.0-3.8 days), and for five of six readers for femur fractures (range, 7.4-17.2 vs 3.3-4.8 days). MAE without and with use of the atlas was 8.8 versus 4.3 days, respectively, across trainee readers and 8.4 versus 4.0 days, respectively, across attending physician readers. CONCLUSION. The fracture dating atlas yielded significant improvements in radiologists' performance for dating infant clavicle, humerus, and femur fractures. CLINICAL IMPACT. Clavicle fracture healing patterns can serve as surrogates for dating long bone fractures commonly encountered in infant abuse.

来源:AJR Am J Roentgenol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Iwasaka-Neder J, Wu S, Kurugol S, et al. Use of a Template-Matching Clavicle Fracture Atlas for Surrogate Dating of Humeral and Femoral Fractures in Young Infants: A Six-Reader Study. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2025. PMID: 40600513. doi:10.2214/AJR.25.33184

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。