西方人群肝细胞癌早期复发监测中非增强简化磁共振成像的可重复性与准确性:多读者研究
八名来自三家机构的放射科医生盲法独立回顾75例肝硬化患者(84%为HCV和/或酒精相关)消融术后二次筛查的143次常规MRI与简化MRI,评估读者间一致性及对2年内复发的敏感度。简化MRI对任何类型复发的读者间一致性高于常规MRI,但敏感度显著低于常规MRI(0.39 vs 0.83,p<0.0001),作者认为简化MRI不适用于该目的。
要点
- 简化MRI对任何类型复发的敏感度仅0.39,显著低于常规MRI的0.83。
- 简化MRI对任何类型复发的读者间一致性为0.73,高于常规MRI的0.56。
- 简化MRI对局部复发的读者间一致性与常规MRI相当(均为0.87)。
核心结论
- 与常规MRI相比,非增强简化MRI读者间一致性更高,但在以HCV和/或酒精相关肝硬化为主的人群中对早期检出HCC复发的敏感度很低,不适用于该目的。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多读者研究,纳入75例肝硬化患者(84%为HCV和/或酒精相关)消融术后二次筛查的143次常规MRI与简化MRI,由三家机构的8名放射科医生(4名经验<5年、4名经验≥5年)盲法独立阅片,两次影像评估间隔1–3个月;复发参考诊断基于组织学或影像学标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 早期HCC复发检出37例(49.3%),其中局部复发12例、新发肝内病灶21例、两者兼有4例;局部复发读者间一致性简化MRI 0.87(0.83–0.90)vs 常规MRI 0.87(0.83–0.92);新发肝内病灶简化MRI 0.85(0.81–0.90)vs 常规MRI 0.60(0.52–0.67);任何类型复发简化MRI 0.73(0.67–0.78)vs 常规MRI 0.56(0.49–0.64);任何类型复发敏感度常规MRI 0.83(0.78–0.87)vs 简化MRI 0.39(0.33–0.45),p<0.0001。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,在以HCV和/或酒精相关肝硬化为主的人群中,非增强简化MRI对早期检出HCC复发的敏感度很低,不适用于该目的。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Abbreviated MRI (AMRI) protocols may represent an alternative to conventional MRI (CMRI) for surveillance of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). We aimed to compare the inter-reader agreement and sensitivity of AMRI versus CMRI for HCC recurrence < 2 years after curative ablation in at risk-population.
METHODS: Eight radiologists (4 with < 5 years' and 4 with ≥ 5 years' experience) from three institutions reviewed a retrospective serie of 143 CMRI and AMRI from 75 cirrhotic patients (84% HCV and/or alcohol-related) undergoing secondary screening after HCC ablation in a blinded and independent manner, with imaging assessments separated by 1-3 month. We calculated the intra and inter-reader agreement by means Gwet's AC1 for detection of local recurrence at the ablation site, new intrahepatic, and any type of recurrence (either local and/or new intrahepatic) with CMRI and AMRI. Reference diagnoses of recurrent HCC were based on histological or imaging-based criteria.
RESULTS: Early HCC recurrence was detected in 37 (49.3%), including 12 local recurrence, 21 new intrahepatic lesions, 4 had both local recurrence and new intrahepatic lesions. Inter-reader agreement was similarly high for AMRI and CMRI for local recurrence [0.87 (0.83‒0.90) vs. 0.87 (0.83‒0.92)], but higher for AMRI than for CMRI for new intrahepatic [0.85 (0.81‒0.9) vs. 0.6 (0.52‒0.67)] and any type [0.73 (0.67‒0.78) vs. 0.56 (0.49‒0.64)] recurrences. Sensitivity for detecting any type of HCC recurrence was higher for CMRI [0.83 (0.78‒0.87) vs. 0.39 (0.33‒0.45) for AMRI, p < 0.0001].
CONCLUSIONS: Compared to CMRI, non-contrast AMRI showed higher inter-observed agreement but with very low sensitivity for early detection of HCC recurrence in a cohort with predominantly HCV and/or alcohol related cirrhosis, making it not suitable for this purpose.
引用
- Rimola J, Saborido B, Igual A, et al. Reproducibility and accuracy of non-contrast abbreviated magnetic resonance imaging of the liver in surveillance for early recurrence for hepatocellular carcinoma in a Western population: a multi-reader study. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2025. PMID: 40632166. doi:10.1007/s00261-025-05105-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。