基于MRI的胎儿体积正常参考范围及其与超声估计胎儿体重在16-36周的相关性:前瞻性研究
这项单中心前瞻性研究纳入260例孕16-36周健康单胎孕妇,用MRI手动分割T2加权图像测量胎儿体积(FBV)并建立正常参考值,以超声估计胎儿体重(US-EFW)为参考评估MRI估计胎儿体重(MRI-EFW)的误差,并与四种已发表的MRI或CT公式比较。结果显示MRI-FBV与US-EFW在整个孕期强相关,作者模型与US-EFW的一致性最强,提示MRI-FBV可能作为EFW的可靠替代方法。
要点
- 研究提供了孕16-36周基于MRI手动分割T2加权图像测量的胎儿体积正常参考范围。
- 作者模型MRI-EFW与US-EFW的差值平均为12.65±166.37 g,在五种公式中与US-EFW一致性最强。
- 孕16周时各公式相对误差均较大,随孕周增加而减小,提示早孕期MRI-EFW需谨慎解读。
核心结论
- 研究提供了孕16-36周MRI-FBV的正常参考范围,可用于临床和研究目的;MRI-FBV与US-EFW在整个孕期强相关,支持MRI-FBV作为EFW可靠替代方法的潜力,尤其在传统超声方法可能受限的临床场景中;与四种已发表公式比较,作者模型与US-EFW的一致性最强。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心前瞻性研究,为正在进行的Lumiere on the Fetus试验的子研究,纳入2021年12月至2022年6月评估的260例健康单胎孕妇(孕16-36周),采用MRI手动分割T2加权图像测量FBV,以MRI前7天内用Hadlock公式测定的US-EFW为参考标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- FBV中位数为1063.01 cm3(范围105.46-3262.4 cm3);推导出孕龄(天)与FBV的三次方程:GA(天)=(3.84×10-9×FBV3)-(3.02×10-5×FBV2)+(0.103×FBV)+113.13;在196例有MRI前7天内US-EFW的病例中,MRI-EFW与US-EFW差值:Baker公式-27.58±127.35 g,Kacem公式-57.54±130.19 g,Amgalan公式142.51±120.12 g,Debbi公式-113.43±150.21 g,作者模型12.65±166.37 g。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为MRI-FBV与US-EFW强相关,支持其作为EFW可靠替代方法的潜力,尤其在传统超声方法可能受限的临床场景中。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The aims of this study were to define normative values of fetal body volume (FBV) measured using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) from 16 to 36 gestational weeks (GW), to assess our MRI-based estimated fetal weight (EFW) using ultrasound (US)-based EFW as reference, and to compare it with EFW derived from previously published MRI- or computed tomography (CT)-based formulae.
METHODS: This single-center prospective substudy of the ongoing Lumiere on the Fetus trial included healthy pregnant women with a healthy, singleton, 16-36-week fetus evaluated between December 2021 and June 2022. FBV was measured using MRI with manual segmentation of T2-weighted images. Based on our previous work, we defined MRI-FBV as being equal to MRI-derived EFW. These measurements were compared to US-EFW that was determined using Hadlock's formula < 7 days prior to MRI, by calculating the difference between them (MRI-EFW - US-EFW) and the relative error of MRI-EFW using US-EFW as the gold standard ((MRI-EFW - US-EFW)/US-EFW) × 100)). We also compared with US-EFW the performance of a further four previously published MRI- or CT-based formulae to estimate fetal weight.
RESULTS: The study cohort comprised 260 healthy pregnant women with a healthy singleton fetus. FBV was measured using MRI in all 260 cases and we present these normative values. US-EFW was obtained < 7 days prior to MRI in 196 (75.38%) cases. All except four (1.54%) fetuses were followed up until birth to confirm normality. The median FBV was 1063.01 cm3 (range, 105.46-3262.4 cm3). We derived the following cubic equation showing the association between gestational age (GA) (from 16 to 36 GW) and FBV: GA (in days) = (3.84 × 10-9 × FBV3) - (3.02 × 10-5 × FBV2) + (0.103 × FBV) + 113.13. The mean ± SD difference between MRI-EFW and US-EFW was -27.58 ± 127.35 g for Baker's formula, -57.54 ± 130.19 g for Kacem's formula, 142.51 ± 120.12 g for Amgalan's formula, -113.43 ± 150.21 g for Debbi's formula and 12.65 ± 166.37 g for our model. The mean relative error on comparison of MRI-EFW according to Baker's formula with US-EFW was 29.33% at 16 GW and 2.98% at 36 GW, and the median was -0.74% (range, -34.36% to 29.33%) for the period 16-36 GW; according to Kacem's formula, the mean relative error was 24.10% at 16 GW and 1.87% at 36 GW, and the median was -3.31% (range, -36.14% to 24.10%) for the period 16-36 GW; according to Amgalan's formula, the mean relative error was 26.64% at 16 GW and 6.74% at 36 GW, and the median was 15.18% (range, -22.53% to 50.20%) for the period 16-36 GW; according to Debbi's formula, the mean relative error was 16.05% at 16 GW and - 0.63% at 36 GW, and the median was -7.25% (range, -42.26% to 16.54%) for the period 16-36 GW; and for our model, the mean relative error was 31.53% at 16 GW and 0.57% at 36 GW, and the median was 2.29% (range, -30.31% to 31.53%) for the period 16-36 GW.
CONCLUSIONS: We provide a normative range for MRI-FBV from 16 to 36 GW, which can be used for clinical and research purposes. The strong association observed between MRI-FBV and US-EFW throughout pregnancy supports the potential for MRI-FBV to be used as a reliable alternative for EFW, particularly in clinical scenarios in which traditional US methods may be limited. Furthermore, the comparison of the four published MRI- or CT-based formulae with US-EFW indicated that our model had the strongest association with US-EFW. © 2025 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Bouachba A, Bartin R, De Jesus Neves J, et al. Normative range of MRI-based fetal body volume and association with ultrasonographically estimated fetal weight at 16-36 weeks: prospective study. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 40418192. doi:10.1002/uog.29234
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。