MRI作为年轻女性亚急性/急性腹痛超声不确定后的CT替代方案:一项前瞻性多中心非劣效性研究
前瞻性多中心非劣效性研究纳入18-40岁非妊娠女性急性/亚急性腹痛且超声不确定者,在CT后6小时内行腹盆腔MRI,以3个月随访专家组诊断为金标准。MRI诊断准确性与CT相比达到非劣效(非劣效界值10%),条件性影像策略(MRI正常时再行CT)准确率达91%并可避免59%的CT检查。
要点
- 对于超声不确定的18-40岁非妊娠女性急性/亚急性腹痛,MRI诊断准确性与CT相比达到非劣效。
- 条件性策略(先行MRI,正常时再行CT)诊断准确率为91%,可避免59%的CT检查。
- 最常见诊断为非特异性疼痛(30.1%)、卵巢囊肿破裂(12.8%)和阑尾炎(9.7%)。
核心结论
- MRI诊断性能不劣于CT,用于18-40岁女性急性腹痛;基于MRI的条件性影像策略准确率达91%,可能可考虑作为该情境下的二线影像方式。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性、多中心非劣效性研究,纳入133例18-40岁非妊娠女性非创伤性急性/亚急性腹痛且超声不确定需追加CT者,在CT后6小时内行腹盆腔MRI,由专家组基于3个月随访确定金标准诊断,对CT和MR进行回顾性阅读并使用标准化列表给出诊断。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 非劣效界值设为10%;MRI诊断准确性估计在60.9%(81/133)至88%(117/133)之间,CT估计在64.7%(86/133)至83.5%(111/133)之间;条件性影像策略(MRI,随后当MRI正常时行CT)诊断准确性为91%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为基于MRI的条件性影像策略可能可考虑作为该情境下的二线影像方式;该策略(先行MRI,正常时再行CT)诊断准确率为91%,可避免59%的CT检查。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To assess the noninferiority of MRI diagnostic accuracy to CT scan as a second-line examination of acute/subacute abdominopelvic pain in a population of young women after an inconclusive ultrasound (US).
METHODS: This prospective, multicenter non-inferiority study included 18-40-year-old non-pregnant women with non-traumatic acute/subacute abdominal pain. They had an inconclusive US warranting the prescription of an additional CT scan. Within 6 h of the CT, all these women underwent abdomino-pelvic MRI. A retrospective reading of the CT and MR provided a diagnosis using a standardized list. The gold standard diagnosis, based on a 3-month follow-up, was done by a panel of experts. Statistical analysis was conducted to assess the noninferiority of the diagnostic accuracy of MRI compared to that of CT. The noninferiority margin was set at 10%. Inter-observer agreement and diagnostic performance of a conditional imaging strategy were estimated.
RESULTS: 133 participants were analyzed (median: 27 years). The most common diagnoses were non-specific pain (30.1%), ovarian cyst rupture (12.8%), and appendicitis (9.7%). MRI demonstrated non-inferiority diagnostic accuracy estimated between 60.9% (81/133) and 88% (117/133) compared to CT, estimated between 64.7% (86/133) and 83.5% (111/133). The conditional imaging strategy (MRI, followed by CT when the MRI was normal) had a diagnostic accuracy of 91%.
CONCLUSION: MRI diagnostic performances are not inferior to CT for acute abdominal pain in women aged 18-40. A conditional imaging strategy based on MRI would give an accuracy of 91% and might be considered a second-line imaging modality in that context.
KEY POINTS: Question Can MRI serve as an alternative to CT as a second-line imaging modality for acute abdominopelvic pain in young women (18-40) after an inconclusive ultrasound? Findings MRI accuracy after inconclusive US ranged from 60.9 to 88%. A conditional strategy (MRI first, CT if normal) reached 91% accuracy, avoiding 59% of CTs. Clinical relevance MRI is not inferior to CT for diagnosing uncategorized causes of acute abdomino-pelvic pain in young non-pregnant women. A conditional imaging strategy based on MRI as a second-line imaging modality would give an accuracy of 91%.
引用
- Charret O, Fournier L, Poncelet E, et al. MRI as an alternative to CT after inconclusive ultrasound in subacute/acute abdominal pain in young women: a prospective multicenter noninferiority study. Eur Radiol. 2025. PMID: 40307528. doi:10.1007/s00330-025-11629-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。