乳腺外科培训必须有哪些改变?国际调查及法国外科学院与国际乳腺学学会的建议
本研究由国际乳腺学学会与法国国家外科学院推动,于2023年7月至8月向两机构网络发放32题电子问卷,评估全球乳腺外科培训差异。121名来自42个国家的乳腺专家参与,多数为普外科医师(56%)和妇科医师(23%),66%有超过15年经验,75%为男性。50%报告乳腺外科专科培训非强制,多学科培训常缺失,仅半数国家要求放射科、肿瘤科或病理科轮转。结论指出高容量中心和专科医师治疗的患者结局更好(死亡率和复发率更低),建议制定标准化乳腺外科教育框架及十项可操作建议。
要点
- 全球乳腺外科培训缺乏标准化,50%受访者报告专科培训非强制。
- 仅半数国家要求放射科、肿瘤科或病理科轮转,多学科培训常缺失。
- 高容量中心和专科医师治疗的患者死亡率和复发率更低。
核心结论
- 高容量中心和专科医师治疗的患者结局一致更好,包括死亡率和复发率更低。
- 乳腺外科培训在全球范围内仍缺乏标准化,培训质量和认证存在明显差异。
- 国际乳腺学学会和法国国家外科学院推荐建立标准化乳腺外科教育框架,并提出十项可操作建议以解决差异、优化培训并提升全球照护质量。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为国际调查,由国际乳腺学学会和法国国家外科学院推动。
- 通过32题电子问卷于2023年7月至8月发放至两机构网络,覆盖个人经验、培训实践、认证项目和专科培训要求。
- 共121名来自42个国家的乳腺专家参与,其中普外科医师占56%、妇科医师占23%。
- 66%的受访者有超过15年经验,75%为男性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 50%的受访者报告乳腺外科专科培训非强制。
- 有要求的国家通常规定1年或2年经验及最低病例数。
- 仅半数国家要求放射科、肿瘤科或病理科轮转。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Breast cancer management has significantly evolved, particularly in surgical techniques, but breast surgery training remains unstandardized worldwide. This study, promoted by the Senologic International Society (SIS) and the French National Academy of Surgery (FNAS) aimed to evaluate training variability in the world and to provide ten recommendations to improve breast surgery training.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A 32-question electronic survey was sent between July-August 2023 to the SIS and FNAS network, covering personal experience, training practices, accreditation programs, and fellowship requirements.
RESULTS: A total of 121 breast specialists from 42 countries participated, including mainly general surgeons (56%) and gynecologists (23%). Most respondents (66%) had over 15 years of experience, and 75% were male. While 50% reported that breast surgery fellowships were not mandatory, countries with requirements often stipulated a one or two-year experience and a minimum cases number. Multidisciplinary training was often lacking, with only half of countries requiring rotations in radiology, oncology, or pathology. Disparities in training quality and accreditation were evident, particularly in regions without formal breast surgery programs.
CONCLUSION: High-volume centers and specialized surgeons consistently demonstrated improved outcomes, including lower mortality and recurrence rates for patients treated for breast cancer. Rising breast cancer incidence, combined with advances in surgical and multidisciplinary care, highlights the urgency for standardized training. Evidence shows that structured programs with volume thresholds, multidisciplinary approach, and modern surgical techniques improve patient survival and satisfaction. The survey underscores the need for international guidelines to ensure equitable, high-quality care. SIS and FNAS recommend a standardized breast surgery education framework with ten actionable proposals to address disparities, optimize training, and enhance global care quality.
引用
- Ozmen T, Bouche C, Buttignol M, et al. What Changes are Mandatory in Breast Surgery Training? An International Survey and Recommendations of the French Academy of Surgery and the Senologic International Society. Eur J Breast Health. 2025. PMID: 40437915. doi:10.4274/ejbh.galenos.2025.2025-3-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。