颈动脉斑块-RADS:CTA中的阅片者间与阅片者内一致性及学习曲线分析
本研究回顾性评估500例因疑似颈动脉粥样硬化行CTA的受试者,由3名不同经验水平的阅片者独立分5个区块使用颈动脉斑块-RADS评分。专家与中级阅片者间一致性为显著(κ=0.78–0.88),中级与初级间为中等(κ=0.50–0.74),专家与初级间随区块从显著(κ=0.68)提升至近乎完美(κ=0.86),显示学习曲线效应;阅片者内一致性初级为显著(κ=0.77),中级和专家均近乎完美(κ=0.88)。
要点
- 颈动脉斑块-RADS在CTA中专家与中级阅片者间一致性显著(κ=0.78–0.88),中级与初级间中等(κ=0.50–0.74)。
- 专家与初级阅片者间一致性随区块从κ=0.68提升至κ=0.86,提示存在学习曲线。
- 阅片者间百分比一致性对Plaque-RADS 1、2、3类最佳,对4类最差。
核心结论
- 颈动脉斑块-RADS在CTA应用中,经验丰富与中级阅片者间一致性为显著至近乎完美,初级阅片者存在明显学习曲线;经验丰富和中级阅片者阅片者内一致性近乎完美,表明该分级系统具有数据可重复性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入500例因疑似颈动脉粥样硬化行CTA的受试者,排除低质量检查后490例进入分析,进一步排除46条既往血运重建的颈动脉后评估934条颈动脉;3名不同血管影像经验水平的阅片者独立分5个区块评估所有CTA,以颈动脉斑块-RADS为分级标准,采用Cohen κ计算3对阅片者间每个区块的一致性,并在随机抽取的100例患者(192条颈动脉)区块上计算阅片者内一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 专家与中级阅片者间一致性范围为κ=0.78至κ=0.88。
- 中级与初级阅片者间一致性范围为κ=0.50至κ=0.74。
- 专家与初级阅片者间一致性跨区块从显著(κ=0.68)提升至近乎完美(κ=0.86)。
- 阅片者间百分比一致性对Plaque-RADS 1、2、3类最佳,对4类最差。
- 阅片者内一致性初级为显著(κ=0.77),中级和专家均为近乎完美(κ=0.88)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者指出颈动脉斑块-RADS在CTA应用中,经验丰富与中级阅片者间一致性显著至近乎完美,初级阅片者存在明显学习曲线。
- 作者指出经验丰富和中级阅片者阅片者内一致性近乎完美,表明该分级系统具有数据可重复性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Atherosclerotic disease of the carotid arteries is a major cause of ischemic stroke. Traditionally, the degree of stenosis has been regarded as the primary parameter for predicting stroke risk, but emerging evidence highlights the importance of carotid plaque composition and morphology. Recently, the Carotid Plaque-Reporting and Data System (RADS) has been introduced to standardize carotid plaque assessment beyond the degree of carotid stenosis. However, its reliability in routine radiologic practice has yet to be established. This study assesses the interreader agreement, intrareader agreement, and learning curve associated with Carotid Plaque-RADS.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, 500 subjects who underwent CTA for suspected carotid atherosclerosis were assessed. Three readers with varying experience levels in vascular imaging independently evaluated all CTAs in 5 blocks by using Carotid Plaque-RADS. To assess the impact of reader experience and potential improvement over time, interreader agreement between the 3 pairs of readers was calculated for each block by using Cohen κ, enabling a comparison of agreement sequentially across the blocks. Intrareader agreement was calculated on a random block of 100 patients (192 carotid arteries).
RESULTS: After exclusion of low-quality examinations, 490 patients were selected for analysis, but 46 carotid arteries were excluded due to previous revascularization procedures. The remaining 934 carotid arteries were assessed. The agreement was substantial between expert and intermediate readers, ranging from κ = 0.78 to κ = 0.88, moderate between intermediate and beginner readers, ranging from κ = 0.50 to κ = 0.74, and between expert and beginner improved from substantial (κ = 0.68) to almost optimal (κ = 0.86) across blocks, indicating the effect of a learning curve. The interreader percent agreement was best for Plaque-RADS category 1, 2, and 3 and poorest for 4. Intrareader agreement was substantial for the beginner (κ = 0.77) and almost perfect for both the intermediate and expert readers (κ = 0.88).
CONCLUSIONS: In the CTA application of the Carotid Plaque-RADS, interreader agreement is substantial to near perfect among experienced and intermediate readers, with a notable learning curve for beginners. Intrareader agreement is almost perfect in experienced and intermediate readers, indicating consistency of their grading, ensuring data reproducibility by using Carotid Plaque-RADS.
引用
- Saba L, Scicolone R, Chabert GL, et al. Carotid Plaque-RADS: Inter- and Intrareader Agreement and Learning Curve Analysis in CTA. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2025. PMID: 40194857. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8769
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。