对比增强数字乳腺断层摄影与对比增强乳腺X线摄影及磁共振成像在乳腺病变评估中的比较:一项先导研究
前瞻性纳入84例患者共91个经组织学证实的乳腺病变,比较对比增强数字乳腺断层摄影原型(CE-DBTp)、对比增强乳腺X线摄影(CEM)与对比增强乳腺磁共振成像(CE-MRI)的诊断效能。CE-DBTp准确度较高,但经验丰富读者(均86.8%)与无经验读者(76.9%和78%)间差异显著(P=0.021);CEM与CE-DBTp间无差异,CE-MRI准确度更高(P=0.002)。CE-DBTp敏感度89.1%至100%,与CEM相当但低于CE-MRI(P=0.003)。
要点
- CE-DBTp敏感度89.1%至100%,与CEM相当,但低于CE-MRI(P=0.003)。
- CE-DBTp准确度在经验丰富读者均为86.8%,无经验读者为76.9%和78%(P=0.021)。
- CE-DBTp与CE-MRI的病灶 conspicuity 高于CEM,一位读者对CE-DBTp的信心显著高于CEM(P<0.001)。
核心结论
- CE-DBTp达到高敏感度和良好准确度,病灶 conspicuity 和读者信心高于CEM,但CE-MRI敏感度和准确度最高。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,经伦理委员会批准,所有患者签署书面知情同意;纳入乳腺X线摄影、DBT或超声发现可疑征象的女性,共84例患者(平均年龄56岁,范围39-70岁)91个经组织学证实的乳腺病变(27个良性,64个恶性);患者接受可疑侧乳腺CEM和CE-DBTp及双侧CE-MRI检查,以组织学为参考标准;四位读者(R1和R2无经验,R3和R4经验丰富)在不知晓患者病史、既往影像和组织学的情况下分别独立评估CEM、CE-DBTp和CE-MRI,并对每个发现给出BI-RADS评分。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CE-DBTp准确度:经验丰富读者均为86.8%,无经验读者分别为76.9%和78%(P=0.021);CE-DBTp敏感度89.1%至100%(经验丰富与无经验读者间P=0.074),与CEM相当但低于CE-MRI(P=0.003);各模态特异度在不同读者间存在变异;CE-MRI准确度高于CEM和CE-DBTp(P=0.002)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Contrast-enhanced mammography (CEM) is an accurate competitor for contrast-enhanced breast magnetic resonance imaging (CE-MRI), but the examination is limited by the lack of 3D information. Digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) allows better lesion detection and characterization compared with mammography. The availability of quasi-3D contrast imaging could further improve the performance of CEM. The aim of our analysis was to compare the diagnostic performance of a contrast-enhanced digital breast tomosynthesis prototype (CE-DBTp) to CEM and to CE-MRI.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This prospective study was approved by the ethics committee, and all patients gave written informed consent. Women who presented with suspicious findings on mammography, DBT, or ultrasound were invited to participate in the study. Participants underwent CEM and CE-DBTp of the breast with the suspicious findings as well as bilateral CE-MRI. Histology was used as the standard of reference. Four readers (R1 and R2 non-experienced; R3 and R4 experienced) evaluated the images, blinded to patients' history, previous imaging, and histology. The readers evaluated CEM, CE-DBTp, and CE-MRI in separate sessions and gave a BI-RADS score for each finding. Sensitivity, specificity, lesion conspicuity, and readers' confidence were calculated and compared.
RESULTS: We included 84 patients (mean age, 56 years; range, 39-70) with 91 histologically verified breast lesions (27 benign, 64 malignant). The accuracy of the CE-DBTp was high, but significant differences were seen between experienced (both 86.8%) and non-experienced readers (76.9% and 78%, P = 0.021). No differences were found between CEM and CE-DBTp, whereas the accuracy of CE-MRI was higher ( P = 0.002). Sensitivity with CE-DBTp varied (89.1% to 100%) between experienced and non-experienced readers ( P = 0.074), and it was comparable to CEM but lower than CE-MRI ( P = 0.003). Specificity was variable between readers with all modalities. Lesion conspicuity was higher for the CE-DBTp and CE-MRI than for CEM, and confidence was significantly higher with the CE-DBTp than with CEM for one of the readers ( P < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: A high sensitivity and good accuracy were achieved with the CE-DBTp. Lesion conspicuity and readers' confidence were higher with the CE-DBTp compared with CEM. However, CE-MRI had the highest sensitivity and accuracy.
引用
- Clauser P, Pötsch N, Santonocito A, et al. Contrast-Enhanced Digital Breast Tomosynthesis Compared With Contrast-Enhanced Mammography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging in the Assessment of Breast Lesions: A Pilot Study. Invest Radiol. 2024. PMID: 39621875. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000001138
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。